2014 Nationals Article For The Korean Times

 Every year, the middle school national competition becomes more fierce. When we first attended, I saw a huge opportunity. Many of the students were not polished. They over-performed and had little subtly. They looked messy and disheveled.

 Each year, however, the students from participating schools refined themselves. I remember in 2012 seeing the first middle school performance that truly impressed me. A student performed a Prose Interpretation speech that actually intimidated me.

 Only a few years prior, I competed among the best college students in the nation. These college-level national competitions were always a bloodbath. Extremely talented college students lost to students with marginally more talent. At a certain point, it became impossible to tell the slight differences and nuances that each performer was bringing to the competition. So judging at this level became a matter of preference.

 Judging speech is like judging art. When students are just beginning their attempts at drawing bowls of fruit, it becomes easy to pick the best one. But when everyone develops their skills, it becomes not only difficult to judge, but it becomes a question of taste; do you like Picasso’s fruit or Rembrant’s? Dali’s apples and pears or van Gogh’s?

 At first, the middle school competitions were like comparing finger paintings of fruit. Some were better than others, but no one was really painting anything that shocked the world. These speeches were like the kinds of paintings that a student would bring home and hang on the refrigerator.

 But in 2012, when I saw that middle school student perform that Prose Interpretation, I knew that the whole middle school competitive speech community was about to change. That was two years ago. This year, the speeches were even more impressive. And not just one or two, but dozens of them were incredible. While some students are still rudimentary, many are becoming more sophisticated than what I‘ve seen at the college level.

 This year, 11 year-old golfer Lucy Li qualified to play in the U.S. Women’s US Open. I don’t know if it’s something in the tap water that kids are drinking, but they’re becoming more talented at younger ages. Lucy Li’s accomplishments are similar to those of the middle school students I saw this past week at the National Speech and Debate Association’s Middle School Competition. She’s young, but impressive. I saw debaters deftly handle an audience of, literally, thousands. I saw speeches that made students cry. I saw 6th graders carry themselves like young men and women. They wore suits with fashionable ties that would make most lawyers feel intimidated. The development in the speech community is a strong display of professionalism and maturity.

 As I walked through the halls of the competition, I ran into many of the college-level competitors that I used to compete against. Each year, more and more of them are taking jobs coaching middle school speech. These jobs generally pay well, and are fairly easy to get. What that means for the future of middle school speech and debate is that the quality of competition is becoming so difficult that most adults wouldn’t want to try competing against them. Former college competitors are gearing middle school students to work and perform like college students.

 So, while some students are still using finger paints, some students are painting like modern-day master artists. And those students will soon be running the country.

Previous
Previous

Ebb & Flow or Beavers: The True Threat to the Planet Earth

Next
Next

Hatred of True Change