A Truth or Death by a Thousand Lies

A Truth

or

Death by a Thousand Lies


A True Beginning


 The combination of a million things makes the whole. Love is not one idea, but a thousand small moments that are assembled over time. Some are lost forever to the abyss of memory and others are distorted through time. In fact, few are authentic. But the feeling is one that is an amalgamation. And while flawed in it’s build, it is sincere in it’s pull on the human heart. Most frustratingly, the loss of love suddenly causes a person to shift perspective. In my recent life, I have had the odd experience of wanting to end a relationship only to have by partner end it for me, and then suddenly want it back. The brain and the heart cannot agree.

 As I explain the smashing of this love, I think it’s important to bear in mind that we are all flawed. I know that, as I read over this, I come across as very petty. I should be more accepting and patient. I expect too much from others, sometimes. I know that I complain about shit that shouldn’t be complained about. But the point of this writing is to be honest about my emotions at the time and the rationale for what split us apart.

 Almost a year ago, I caught Rocio in a lie. Actually, several strings of lies, which involved her secretly sending Snapchat texts to another guy named Tony. We almost split up over it and I wrote everything out in painstaking detail. I found that it helped me process the information and I was able to go back and review it later so that I could better understand what happened. Basically, it helped me not forget the tiny details.

 I write this because I don’t want to forget the details of what has transpired over the past month or so.


The Past Year

 To set the stage, Rocio and I had, for the most part, been getting along pretty well. We had problems, but they were fairly minor. I had voiced a complaint about her lack of sexuality. But it was not usually a source of a fight. We would discuss it, she would say that she would work on it, and then nothing would change.

 While trying to sort out usual relationship problems, I had suggested that every week, we ask each other about what the other’s needs were. I set an alarm on my phone and every Sunday at 2:52, it would ring. I would ask Rocio what her needs were and sometimes she would ask me mine. When she did, I would explain that I would like for her to be more sexual with me. That I would like it if she were to touch me instead of me touching her all of the time. I pointed out that I was a willing partner; I would perform oral sex on her and do whatever she liked. However, our sexual routine became predictable. I would go down on her and after she had an orgasm, there was little focus on me. Instead, she would climb on top, ride me until she had another orgasm, and then it was my turn to come. After a while, it became extremely routine and predictable. Moreover, it was too rare for my taste. We had sex about once a week, maybe less. I complained that I wanted to have sex at least twice a week. She also began wearing less attractive clothes around me. She would wear frumpy jackets and sweatshirts despite a resolution to wear more dresses and skirts this year.

 I also grew a little resentful of some things: she suggested that we buy Rock Band for each other on Valentine’s Day and split the cost. We played it twice. She never chipped in money for it, either. She had suggested (sort of playfully) that I buy a sex chair. Thinking that this might be something that would increase her sexual desires, I was eager to oblige her. We looked at several together and I bought one for a couple hundred bucks. We used it a couple of times, as well. Now it sits in the corner gathering dust. When I first moved into the loft, she agreed to chip in for her parking of $175 a month. She did it for the first couple of months and then stopped. I knew that I was making more money than her, so I never said anything about it. This summer, once she knew she was going to make money from her debate camp coaching, she gave me a check for $200 to cover that month’s parking. But the check was written in red ink and, for some reason, my bank wouldn’t take it like that. I returned it to Rocio and she said she would give me a new check, but she never did. I even brought it up once or twice, jokingly, just to give her a chance to remember. But she never made an effort.

 I guess even the gift certificate bothered me: last Christmas, she bought me a that we returned to a store and she never gave me the gift certificate. I made a few comments that we should go redeem the certificate, but they seemed to fall on deaf ears.

 When we would have arguments, I would find myself saying that she didn’t care about me. This would upset her and she would respond by saying that she does care about me. But I don’t think she ever fully understood that I wasn’t feeling that she cared. Her approach towards the relationship was one that is typical of a person who doesn’t seem to care. Which isn’t to say that she didn’t. I have no way of knowing her thoughts, of course. And I know that we spent so much time together that she had to have cared about me deeply, but when it came time to do something profound for the person that she supposedly cared deeply about, she was unwilling to do so.

 I think most of my frustration came from my insecurities about our future. I was worried about money for our future baby and I had suggested that she consider a career in make-up design, since she was already drawn toward that field. I set up a meeting with a make-up artist friend of mine so that she could ask a few questions and think about it as a possible future. She dismissed me when I tried to talk about it, but she did agree to meet my friend. Afterwards, she spoke very little about the meeting and I vowed to not push her about it again. The whole experience was a letdown because I was hoping to discuss our future and she repelled.

 I was feeling some resentment, but most of the time I was thrilled to be with her. I only found myself having negative feelings for her when we weren’t near each other. We enjoyed each other’s company and got along very well. But, I also had a bit of fear and a little resentment with Rocio about our future. We had discussed baby names quite a bit and were planning on starting a life together. But I was growing more and more concerned with how we would pull everything off. With the money I made from teaching, I couldn’t support both of us, much less a baby. So, I started to get concerned that the future of the relationship would be the same as my previous marriage: me pulling most of the weight and wondering what I was getting out of the deal since I wasn’t even having sex (to be honest, I wouldn’t have minded working an extra job or something if Rocio would have made sex a bigger priority).

 In early August, Rocio got a job teaching at a debate camp at Stanford. She was gone for two weeks. When she had done the same camp last year, we were sure to speak every day. But this year, we spoke much less often. When she returned from camp last year, I made her homemade lasagna (her favorite), bought her several gifts, stopped off at a 7-11 for her favorite slushy, and spread roses all over the bed in a romantic gesture. This year, I made the lasagna, and bought some gifts, but didn’t do the whole rose thing (they were messy, stained some sheets, and I was picking them up for weeks after I thought I’d cleaned them). But also, I didn’t feel the need to go the full distance because, in truth, I was harboring some butthurt from previous gift exchanges. Simply put: Rocio is an awful gift-giver.

 My birthday last year was kind of a disaster, which I outlined in another journaling. But one of the big sticking points was that she asked me what I wanted and I told her that I wanted to spend the entire day with her in bed. About a week before, she asked me what kind of cake I liked, and I said that I didn’t really like cake. I liked pies. On my birthday, she showed up around 7:00 with a cake she had made. I was frustrated at that point because I hadn’t gotten to spend the day in bed like I’d hoped, and... I don’t like cake.

 To Rocio’s defense, the cake was homemade and beautiful; it was rainbow colors, each layer different in shade from the last. But I was still frustrated. This year, for my birthday, Rocio bought me cupcakes from the bakery across the street. Cupcakes... A version of cake...

 But she isn’t bad at only birthdays. Halloween is Rocio’s favorite holiday. Last Halloween, I went to great lengths to get her several gifts. I elegantly wrapped each one and took careful time to plan everything out, even buying tiny coffins from the 99¢ store to hold the smaller gifts. She procrastinated and gave me a painting of a pinup girl the day after we traded gifts. Now, to her defense, the painting was beautiful. It was cute, creepy, and visually interesting, but she had waited until the last moment to start and didn’t finish it in time to give it to me when we traded gifts.

 That Christmas, I carefully thought out a multitude of gifts that I thought were fitting and special. A lot of time went into each one. Rocio bought me a jacket and some shoes. The jacket didn’t fit, so we took it back and got store credit. I felt that the gifts were almost impersonal; like she hadn’t taken the time to do something special. I know this reads as being petty, but the impersonal gift from someone who you’ve been dating for almost a year is kinda rough to handle.

 So, when her birthday came around this year, I pulled back a little. I had gone all out last year and was worried that I was going to go too far again this year and then end up resenting her when she gave me something impersonal. I still bought her several gifts: tickets to a couple of shows she wanted to see and tickets to a Boston/Angels game. I had hoped to curb my enthusiasm for celebrations a bit. I knew I was getting too excited for opportunities to give gifts and thus, was becoming disappointed when she didn’t return the intensity.


Aug. 28, 2016

 So, when my birthday rolled around, I was secretly hoping that she would try to make up for last year’s debacle. She asked me once again what I would like for my birthday. And once again, I told her that I would like to spend the day in bed having sex. This year, my birthday fell on a Tuesday, and it was the first day of her new college classes, so we agreed to spend the previous Sunday in celebration. She spent the night on Saturday, and on Sunday morning, we had sleepy sex. I had politely implied that this was not my favorite way to do it because I felt gross, I hadn’t brushed my teeth, and I just felt unsexy. She hadn’t shaved her legs and it was prickly. That was the only time we had sex that day. We spent the rest of the day watching Netflix. There had been no special sexy outfit or striptease. She hadn’t even put on fresh make-up; it was still smeared from the night before. We did get to watch a movie that I had been bugging her to watch with me. But then she complained about having to watch it and kinda ruined the experience. We then watched a tv show she had been bugging me to watch. I relented.


Aug. 30, 2016:

 On my actual birthday, we exchanged texts. She told me happy birthday, and I told her that I loved her and was, “So glad to have you in my life.” She came over after her classes. It had been a very long day for her, so I’m sure she was exhausted. But she put on a happy face that night. When she came over, she told me to close my eyes, which I obliged. I thought that maybe she was going to be wearing something sexy or even just pop out naked from an oversized trench coat like in the movies. She was wearing her large baggy Boston Red Sox sweatshirt that her ex-boyfriend David had given her. She sprayed me with silly string and screamed, “Surprise!” as she handed me a balloon, some party hats, and cupcakes from the store across the street... Even though I don’t like cake.

 But, to her credit, she was extremely vibrant and upbeat. It was the mood that I most loved of hers. She was extremely nice that night and even gave me a handjob because she was on her period.

 Still, there wasn’t any sort of real thought that went into any of the gifts. They felt very last-minute, and I was frustrated that she hadn’t tried to do anything special. I was ashamed to even have those thoughts; she bought me some cupcakes and a balloon. But that felt like the kind of thing you do for a good friend or coworker that you see every day, not something that you do for a person you’ve been dating for a year and a half. (Well, all except the handjob. Hopefully, you’re not jerking off your coworkers.) It seemed like she could have done something with a little thought behind it. I dunno, make a playlist of some music that reminds her of me... SOMETHING other than cupcakes. She didn’t write a letter or a poem. It just felt empty. No extra money needed to be spent, but she could have been creative.

 Something that seemed to enflame my frustrations was that she had planned to get another tattoo. I told her that I really wanted to go with her when she got it. However, the night of my birthday, she told me that she was going the following day and that she didn’t want me to go. It hurt because there was no logical reason to deny me the chance to go. It seemed spiteful. Moreover, she had taken the time to plan out her tattoo and make an appointment, but hadn’t taken the time to think about a solid birthday gift.


Sept. 2, 2016

 I tried to suck it up, but after a few days, I finally said something to Rocio about the impersonal gifts. I knew it was tacky to complain, but I needed to let it out. Rocio said that she understood, but I could tell she was paying me some lip service. She was saying what she needed to say in order to get me to shut up and move on. But I didn’t feel vindication. That night, things were tense, and I went to bed thinking that, perhaps the relationship wasn’t the one I was looking for. I was angry and starting to wonder if I should start looking for someone else.


Sept. 3, 2016

 The next day, she was supposed to come over around 4:00. When 8:00 came and went without a word from her, I texted her asking if she was coming. She replied that she was waiting to hear from me. I knew she wouldn’t admit it, but it felt like she was upset with me because I complained about my birthday presents. We fought a little and she agreed to try to make it up to me.


Sept. 4, 2016

 On Sunday, she made no attempt. She didn’t work until the afternoon, but she never tried to see me that morning or early afternoon. I was becoming more frustrated with the fact that she wouldn’t try to make things right. That night, she asked what I was doing on the next day and I told her that I was going to a museum with my mom. She made no attempt to see me Monday night, either.

 But to be fair, neither did I. I was pissed because I felt like I was being ignored. When she returned from debate camp this year, I had explained to her that it felt like we rarely saw each other.

 I think my problem is high expectations. Perhaps that comes from years of watching too many romantic movies where a person who has wronged someone makes up for it in a sweeping romantic gesture. I mean, I would have been satisfied with her just fucking me a few times (I think sex heals all my wounds). I think all I wanted was for Rocio to show that she cared. At least a little more of showing it, anyway.

 

Sept. 6, 2016

 On Tuesday night, she came over after class and we had a talk. By this point, I was steeling myself for the breakup that I thought I wanted. As we began talking, I realized that she had been thinking similar thoughts and, suddenly, we were on the brink of actually ending the relationship. She said that it was causing her too much stress in her life. I explained that I was willing to work on my issues. I made her feel like I was a dad scolding her, and she resented that.

 I think the frustrations she was feeling were stemming from her own insecurities about her path in life, but I was the scapegoat. She wanted to sweep the conflict under the rug, but here I was pulling up the rug and forcing her to address the situation. That didn’t fly so well with her.

 That Tuesday night, we spoke for a while about the relationship. I suggested that we see a therapist and she flatly refused. I told her that I had been considering paying for her to go to make-up school, to which she said, “You don’t have to pay for me to go to school.” I told her that I didn’t see it that way; I wanted to pay for her to go to make-up school as an investment in us. I wanted to get her career started in some way so that we could make enough money to raise a baby or two. She commented that she really felt that she needed to finish school right now, which seemed odd to me because she still hadn’t picked out a major.

 I made it a point to bring up the discussion about my birthday. I told her that I was disappointed because she didn’t invest herself in any sort of way. She claimed that it was unfair because I had more money than she did; she couldn’t afford big gifts. I pointed out that she needn’t spend money on me, but that she could do something that would have meaning. I noted that the gift she’d given me for Halloween was very sentimental, but birthday cupcakes weren’t.

 I told her that I was willing to work on myself to make things right. Now, with the threat of love leaving me, I became frantic to save it. I didn’t want the relationship to be over, I just wanted it better. But Rocio said that she wasn’t sure if she could do the work on the relationship. She said that she needed to think about things. I walked her to her car and asked her to go one a date with me to the movies in a couple of nights. I stated that I had plans this Friday and she said that she had plans on Wednesday. I will never forget the exchange that took place next: we both teasingly squinted our eyes at one another as if we were suspicious of the other’s activities those nights. She said that she was going to a Dodger game with her brother’s girlfriend the following night (Wednesday), and I said that I had plans with my mom on Friday. I was hoping to go to the movies the night after her Dodger game (Thursday). I found it a little weird that Rocio would take Luz to the game without ever mentioning it to me, but I let it go.

  Later that night, I sent her a text saying that I missed her, but that I didn’t know if I should text her anymore or not, because I didn’t want to be annoying. She didn’t text me back at all for the next day and a half.


Sept. 7, 2016

 That night, she went to a Dodger game. I assumed she went with with Luz, her brother’s girlfriend. (I hacked into her accounts with some passwords I had figured out and discovered that Rocio had purchased two tickets to see the Dodger game. This raised my spidey-senses because Rocio told me that she was going with Luz and that her brother might join them. Obviously, that kind of thing needs to be worked out ahead of time so that he could sit with them, so I knew it was only two people going. I tried to give her the benefit of the doubt and kept telling myself that her relationship with Luz had been getting closer and closer over the past few months, so that’s why it made sense to buy two tickets. But in the back of my mind, I suspected that she might have gone with someone else. It turns out that she had gone with David. She even washed her car especially for him.) (Fake: That night, I got a phone call from Rocio’s ex-boyfriend, David. I had found him on Instagram months earlier during the incident with Rocio emotionally cheating on me with this guy named Tony. I had also noted that Rocio was looking into David’s Instagram at the time, so I found him and direct message-d him. I gave him my phone number in case he wanted to discuss things. He never called, until now. He started bragging about how he was at the Dodger game with Rocio. I told him that this was the kind of thing that would get his ass kicked, and he responded by saying, “Bring it on, fucker!” He then gave me the seat numbers at the Dodger game: 123LG Row E, seat 5/6. He said that if I wanted to come down there and start some shit, he would kick my ass in front of Rocio. For a minute, I thought about actually going, but I realized that the idea of buying a ticket to get punched is kind of an insane idea. So, I let them be and never said anything to her or him about it.) I saw a photo on her Instagram of the stadium. Luz wasn’t in the picture.


Sept. 8, 2016

 I finally texted her again asking if we were going to the movies. Unsurprisingly, she said that she was too tired from class and had to get up early the next day.

 At this point, I knew the relationship was over. She wasn’t communicating with me, and things were already pretty broken. So, after work that night, I boxed up all of her stuff and took it over to her house. As I set everything inside the gate to her driveway, I saw that her car wasn’t there. It was well after 11:00 at night, so I knew that she had gone somewhere. I texted her to let her know that I had left her stuff for her.

 Later that night, she finally texted me back saying, “You didn’t have to drop off stuff at my house, I could’ve just picked it up.” I told her that I wanted it gone, which was only a half-truth. I pointed out that she had lied about being too tired to see me that night because her car wasn’t there. But she said she had been driving around, thinking. This seemed out of character for her, but even still, I felt that it was misleading for her to say that she didn’t want to hang out because she had to go to bed early. She led me to believe that the reason why she didn’t want to see me was because she had to get up the next morning, but it was really because she didn’t want to see me. But I dropped it. Things were spiraling out and the relationship was almost completely splintered. We exchanged a few texts that night and she said that she still wanted me in her life, which I thought was an odd thing to say since she was claiming that she wanted space. I pointed out that remaining in each other’s lives would not work well for either of us. Having to sit on the sidelines as the other person found newer love(s) was a recipe for disaster.


Sept. 9, 2016

 The next afternoon, while I was at work, she came by and dropped off some of my things while I was at work. When I got home, it felt raw that she didn’t want to fight to make the relationship work. I was a little numb, but also anxious. That night, (I used some of her passwords that I’d hacked to find out more about what she was doing. I discovered, through her Google account, that she had dropped my stuff off around 5:30 or so. Then, she Googled directions to a middle school across town. But the most damning part was that she had Googled directions to her ex-boyfriend’s house. At first, it was difficult to grasp. I had found her ex-boyfriend’s address through Google, so I knew what area of town he lived in. When I saw the address, I double-checked my password cheatsheet and confirmed that it was his house.) (Fake: Late that night, her ex-boyfriend, David, called me again to brag that she had come to see him. When they dated over a year and a half ago, David had repeatedly cheated on Rocio and done several other things that had hurt her. I thought about how fucked up it was that he wanted to brag about her coming back to him.) I thought about how fucked up it was that she had gone to him. He had cheated on her, shown nude pictures of her to his friends, lied to her, and never shown an interest in furthering himself either academically or career-wise. It suddenly made me think that, perhaps Rocio hadn’t actually gone to the Dodger game with Luz, but that she had gone with David. I wondered if she had not wanted me to go with her to get her tattoo because she was with him. (Fake: I didn’t have the wherewithal to call David back and ask him about it, but I had my suspicions.) I felt like a sucker: I’d just a few days told Rocio how glad I was to have her in my life, and now it was being torn apart.

 That night, I texted her, asking, “Can I ask you one thing, please?” but she never responded. I wanted to ask her if she was going back to David.


Sept. 10, 2016

 That night, I didn’t sleep at all. Literally, the entire night, I tossed and turned, took a bath, and wrote. When the sun came through the windows, I knew I was going to have trouble at work that day. I had found some funny pictures of Rocio and they made me laugh.

 Then, I came to the conclusion about how I would react to the whole relationship issue: I would give her the space she wanted, and try to date her. No longer would we be in a relationship, but I would ask her on dates and try to woo her off her feet once again. That afternoon, between classes, I sent her a funny video in hopes of rekindling a conversation. It worked. She texted me back, but unfortunately, she killed the conversation. (She will sometimes end conversations with texts that go nowhere. If I say, “How was your day?” She won’t actually answer. Instead, she’ll respond with, “Good! Yours?” And after whatever I say, she will react with things like, “That’s good.” This effectively kills the conversation and forces me to have to restart it once again.)

 I left her alone for most of the day, but I’d asked her if she wasn’t busy that night. I was hoping that we could go to a taping of my friend Joe’s television show. I thought it would be fun for her to meet celebrities like Oscar de la Hoya and Jay Mohr. She said that it would have been fun, but that she had to work that night. I told her that if she was free the following week, I would put her on the list and we could go then. She said that she would let me know once she found out her schedule from work.

 That night, after the show, I asked her if she would like to go to the movies with me the following night. She said that she had a closing shift, so she couldn’t go. I told her that I was planning on going to a late-night movie around 11:00 or midnight. She never responded to that text.


Sept. 11, 2016


The next day, I managed to get a little sleep, but was awoken when Anika texted me in the morning. She was very upset and I offered to come get her and take her to lunch. She was extremely upset over some family drama she was having, and I needed to get out of the house, anyway. We went to lunch and talked all day about both of our problems. She was sympathetic to mine, and I was the same for her. I told her that Ira and I had made plans, and invited Anika to join us. I texted Ira to make sure he was comfortable with it, and that night, we all three had a wonderful time together.

 But on the way home, after I dropped Anika off, I started to get the queasy feeling again. I texted Rocio to ask her if she was ever going to reply to my request to go to the movies. She apologized, but said she was too tired to meet up. I asked her if she was willing to go to the Denny’s by her house, but she declined again. During this time, I drove by her house to make sure that she was home and I was relieved to see her car there. The knot in my stomach immediately evaporated. I asked her if she would FaceTime me, and she agreed. I explained all of the drama that had happened since I’d last seen her. I wanted to talk about our relationship; I was curious where we stood. I wanted to tell her that I had decided to try to give her the space she wanted and to just return to a simple dating relationship. But she said that she didn’t want to talk about it.

 I couldn’t let everything with David go; it was plaguing me. I wanted to ask her if she really did go over to David’s house and what it meant for them/us if she did. So I asked her if all of the sudden problems with our relationship was due to another guy, and she said no. I asked her if she’d seen David, and she said no. I said, “So, you didn’t go over there on Friday after you dropped off all my stuff at my house?” and she said no. I said, “Rocio, I obviously know that you did, why don’t you just admit it?” She said that his grandfather had died and that she went over to comfort him. I asked her if she was planning on seeing him again, and she said that she needed to give him back his sweatshirts (no idea why this couldn’t have been done a year and a half earlier when they broke up the first time).

 Understandably, she was very creeped out. She repeatedly asked me how I knew she went over to his house, but I wouldn’t tell her. She said she was hurt and I explained that I felt the same way. She claimed that it was a breech of trust (she thought that I followed her there), but I told her that she had done the same thing to me: breached my trust.

 She got silent, which is what she always does when she’s confronted, and I tried to pick the conversation back up. I mentioned that she was welcome to come over on Wednesday to watch the premiere of the new American Horror Story. She said that if I was to watch all the remaining episodes of season 3 and all of season 4, she would be willing to come. I said that I would do it. This seemed to make her giggle and she perked back up.

 I also mentioned that I wanted to take her to school on Tuesday. She asked why, and I said that I missed her and that I wanted to spend some time with her. She declined my request, but I said that I wanted to bring her lunch. I had figured that since she was trapped at school all day, she needed to have someone bring her food and sustenance. She agreed to lunch. I figured that she didn’t want me to pick her up in the morning because she was probably going over to David’s that night. But I didn’t press it with her.


Sept. 12, 2016

 The next day, we texted minimally, and I tried to leave her alone. I did ask her if she was ever planning on paying me the $200 from the check written in red ink and if she was planning on reimbursing me for the Uber ride she’d charged to my credit card. She said that she would pay me on Friday once she got paid. (However, I was still checking her e-mails and Google searches. Halfway through the day, I saw that she changed her phone settings to remove the Find My Phone option. Clearly, she thought I was tracking her through that. That night, when I got home, I checked her e-mail and saw that) (Fake: That night, David called me again and bragged that) she had purchased tickets to Halloween Horror Nights at Universal Studios for Saturday night; the same night I had asked her to go to the show with me. My heart sank, so I called Anika and talked to her for an hour or two about it. Then, when I felt that I was only repeating myself with her, I called Sally, who always gives great advice. I spoke with her for two hours. Things were exacerbated when it occurred to me that she had claimed poverty as the reason why her birthday gift had been so skimpy, yet here she was spending hundreds of dollars on her ex-boyfriend. I almost hypothesized that she had purchased the Dodger tickets for her and I to go, but when David came into the picture, she changed her mind and asked him to go, instead.

 By the time I had finished with both of them, it was clear that the relationship was completely over, but that she wasn’t being honest with me about it. After a year and a half, I wanted closure.

 Rocio texted me that she didn’t want me to come the next day to bring her lunch. I explained that I had something special for her. She still rebuffed me and I pleaded my case. Finally, she agreed. I got a little sleep that night.


Roam if you must...

 I know that the relationship is done. I know that tomorrow, I am going to ask her if she will be willing to go to the tv show taping with me this Saturday and she will say that she has to work. Then, I will say that she really has plans with David and that will be the end of everything. She will no longer trust me, just as I already no longer trust her. But in a way, perhaps I only want to catch her in a lie so that I can protect myself. If things don’t work out with her and David, she might contact me some months or even years down the line, and I would remember only the good times. Then, I would get back involved with a liar and a cheater. “We have a really great time together” is a very dangerous statement for a relationship; it makes excuses for the bad things that people do to one another. It’s like, you can be as abusive to each other as you’d like, but if you keep thinking to yourself, “we have a really great time together,” you’ll find a way to forget the awful pieces.

 I am definitely bothered that she is leaving me for him, of all people. She has told me about all of the awful things he’s done to her, and for her to have the low self-esteem to return to that is disheartening. If she were leaving me for another, better man, then I would still be hurt, but not crushed. It’s a crushing blow to think that she hasn’t learned to love herself. That she’s not strong enough to walk away. That she hasn’t learned to have self-respect. It feels like she is wasting her 20s; she should be moving forward, not backward.

 Almost a year ago, right before the meltdown with the Tony-watch situation, I asked her if she would have ever cheated on David if he’d never cheated on her. She said, no, she never would have. At the time I believed her, but I’m not sure if I do, anymore. I think Rocio is, simply, a cheater and a liar. And she has to live with herself that way. She will always know her own character. I begin to wonder about what other thousands of lies has she told me? Her hopes, dreams, and thoughts could have all been lies.

 I began to realize that the parent-child relationship we had was stemming from the way she behaved. She acted like a rebellious teenage daughter, and I was the one trying to keep a family together. No wonder I was coming across like a parent! For example, I was trying to get her to think about what kind of career she wanted, like an adult. David would never do that to her. His lack of drive was what she wanted because it meant that she didn’t have to grow up.

 If I was only friends with her, I would advise her to ditch him. We were close friends before we started dating, and I even remember saying that if she wasn’t into the relationship with him, why didn’t she just break up? I know that if I were my own friend, I would give myself the same advice about her, and I don’t seem to want to take it.

 My question to her: Why does she keep going back to him? He keeps cheating on her!

 My question to me: Why do I keep trying to get her back? She cheats and lies to me...

 David’s the kind of guy who would repeatedly degrade her and take her for granted. (Fake: He’s the kind of guy who would call me to brag that he got her back) And she’s the kind of girl who would go back to that. Luckily, I think that I may have dodged a bullet. While my heart still pounds and aches, I know that if we’d had kids like we’d discussed, she would have been a bad mother to them in that same way. She would have set the example to them that they can cheat and that they can lie. She would have shown them a life without integrity, and I wouldn’t want my kids raised like that.

 It hurt that she went to him for a thousand reasons. So many of them, in fact, that I find myself finding new ones all the time. The money was a big one: she had spent practically nothing on me for my birthday and claimed that she was too poor to afford something nice. Meanwhile, she had spent hundreds of dollars on her ex-boyfriend and her tattoo. It hurt that she would lie to me so many times after I’d been so forgiving; the sound of her sitting in my living room saying, “I want to be honest with you... You, of all people, deserve that.” It hurt that she never wanted to approach me about any of this. I know it will continue to hurt for weeks or maybe even months to come because she will never apologize the way she should. It will hurt because I know that after I catch her in her lie, she will still go to Halloween Horror Nights with David. It will hurt because she will know that she is doing something without dignity, and she’ll do it anyway. It hurts to think about all the nights she never said goodnight to me because she was talking to him. It hurts because she seems to understand that she’s flawed, but that she’s not willing to make changes about her life to fix those flaws. It hurts because she wouldn’t try to make herself better for me. It hurts because I know I will miss her terribly, but I will have to leave her.

 I found it fitting that, a few weeks ago, she changed her Instagram status to an Atmosphere lyric: “Roam if you must, but come home when you’ve seen enough.” When we first started our romance, I had told her that I would torch my entire life for her, but that’s not always enough to make things work. One person cannot love enough for both people in a relationship.

 She had constantly proved the truth about herself and her character to me.


A True Ending

 The love has smashed into its millions of pieces. I was reminded of the book title Death by a Thousand Cuts. It seemed that this was what happened to our relationship, and I think my high expectations caused a lot of them. I also think that Rocio had become unwilling to adapt herself to the relationship. I had been whiny and she had been a prude. I expected too much of her, and she had been unwilling to change.

 We shattered our bond into a million pieces. These millions of pieces are what made the love work.




 Quite possibly the thing I will miss most is that incredible smile she gave me when she sprayed me with silly string on my 37th birthday. Memories are the only way to love.




 I can only wonder: if I had treated her worse if she would have loved me more.







Previous
Previous

Reason

Next
Next

Putting the ‘Post’ in Post-Apocalyptic