America’s Future or How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love NJFL

America’s Future or How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love NJFL

by

Robert Cannon


 As we pulled into the sleepy town of Des Moines Iowa, the six Wilshire Academy students in the back of the van were beyond excited. Eager to see what the rest of America looked like, they quickly compared Wikipedia’s population statistics of Des Moines with our home town, Los Angeles. But while they were obviously excited, they were also a bit scared. We had traveled thousands of miles to take part in this year’s NJFL Tournament. While confident and prepared, we were unsure of what to expect, since we had never before been to such a large tournament.

 The National Junior Forensics League Tournament is a once-a-year competition which determines the best public speakers in grades 6-8. Having personally competed in the college equivalent of this tournament, I was well aware of what was in store for us. I understood how difficult it would be; managing time, eating the right foods, convincing judges with the right amount of confidence… It was both physically and emotionally draining. Having won college nationals in 2009 myself, I knew that these students would have a long road ahead of them if they were to be crowned a national champion.

 The first day of competition put me at a different school campus than the rest of the team. Since the tournament had so many teams compete, the events were split onto three different middle school campuses; the speeches are usually given in a school classroom, in front of a judge and a handful of others. Only the final rounds are given in front of a large audience. I was asked to judge Policy Debate. Having competed in collegiate debate from 2004-2009, I understood what was in store for me.

 The Policy debaters spoke at a blistering speed. For those unfamiliar with this type of debate, it can become confusing as to what is being said. These students are most likely to become lawyers, as they are already using legalese in their everyday speech. Some of the students are ill-prepared, and seem a bit overwhelmed. Others have a look similar to what experienced war veterans might have. It becomes a verbal bloodbath, and they all seem to enjoy every minute of it.

 During lunch, I have enough time to sneak away from my campus and join the Wilshire Academy students at their respective school. They’re tired. Their hair is out of place, their shirts are now half untucked, they’re sweaty from the heat. They look as if they’ve been taking the SATs nonstop for a week, and in all likelihood, they’ve probably spent more mental energy in one day than most students do in an entire school year. All six of the Wilshire students are competing in Public Forum Debate, which is a relatively new style of debate, and one that is becoming much more popular every year. For example, last year, only 18 teams entered the NJFL tournament in Public Forum. This year there are 44. We have our work cut out for us, too, because the other teams are easily just as prepared as our teams are.

 The debate focuses around research, which has been completed by the students ahead of time. The topic of the debate is given to the students two months ahead of time, and this topic is no picnic: Current trends in American political dialogue compromise meaningful democratic deliberation. This kind of topic would challenge most adults, however, these students are able to debate it with ease. For weeks, these same six Wilshire Academy students have poured over newspapers and internet sites, they’ve read thesis papers from PhDs in political science, and they’ve asked literally thousands of questions. All of it cumulates to this weekend.

 In all, each team debated five times that day, and each debate is close to an hour long. The rounds are “power matched” which means that the strongest teams go against the next strongest teams, so by the end of the day, the last couple of teams are very experienced. One of the highlights of the entire trip was waiting for our last team to finish their debate so we could go home. They came sprinting out of their classroom with huge smile pasted on their faces. After explaining to the rest of the squad the details of the round, I asked them if they thought they won. They both said that they didn’t have a clue if they’d won, but that they’d had more fun debating that round than ever before.

 By the end of the day, the students are exhausted. Four of the six don’t make it through the 10 minute drive without falling asleep, and the other two are clearly affected. After dinner, all six were fast asleep and ready for day 2.

 On the second day, the tournament was moved to one very large campus to accommodate the rest of the tournament. Fulfilling our team’s judging requirement, I was able to see a few more types of speech events other than the two previous styles of debate. Declamation was the first non-debate event I judged. Declamation is a unique type of speech, in that it requires the student to memorize and perform someone else’s speech as if he or she had been the original performer. For example, if a student were to perform Martin Luther King jr.’s “I Have a Dream” speech, the student would memorize it, and deliver it to the judge and audience as if he or she were the one delivering it on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial in 1963. After an impressive round five of speeches, a student who delivered a speech about what adults can learn from children grabbed my vote.

 Soon, it was time to find out how our team had done. Sadly, we did not have and advancements into the elimination rounds (only the top 16 of the 44 teams advance), but to my astonishment, there were relatively few tears. All six of the Wilshire students were, of course, saddened by the news, but understood the difficulty of what they were doing, and felt confident that they had done their best.

 At this point, it would have been easy for them to go back to the hotel, however, they elected to stay at the tournament and watch more speeches, especially debate; they wanted to find out how to improve their skills.

 I was off to judge a Dramatic Interpretation round. Often simplified to D.I., this is a type of speech which, to an average onlooker, might be confused with acting. True, there are some similarities, but this type of performance belongs in the speech field. The contestants must memorize and perform a cutting from a play which evokes a dramatic feeling. By the end of the semi-final round, much of the audience was crying. Clearly, this is a testament to the skill and talent that the performers carry.

 After D.I. came a round of Impromptu speaking. Impromptu is one of the most difficult types of speeches offered at the NJFL, because it takes a lot of work to be skilled at it. The event requires that each student create a five minute speech about a topic which they are given only moments beforehand. There is no preparation for the speech, only what each student’s experiences offer. The round I judged was centered on historical figures. Some students knew very little of Albert Einstein, other than that he was smart and “has some kind of formula.” But others were able to speak quite eloquently about the likes of Thomas Jefferson and Sacagawea.

 By then end of day two, everyone was exhausted, and yet, there was still one more day to go. As I mentioned earlier, I have competed at national college speech competitions. They are long events, and maintaining your energy for such durations is a definite aspect of the competition. Every team seemed to be wiped out on energy.

 The third day saw more speeches for the Wilshire squad. They sat in on Duos (a speech similar to D.I., but designed for two people instead of just one), and another round of debate. However, I was asked to judge the final round of Congress Debate.

 Congress Debate is a very unique style of debate. It is modeled after our government’s own deliberation of bills in Washington D.C. Each student must prepare a brief three minute speech on topics which were announced months beforehand. They must then deliver the speech and provide interesting thoughts during a question and answer session. Each student is judged on the quality of his or her speech, the answers provided during his/her question and answer session, and also on the quality of question he/she provides other students when it is their time to speak. In essence, the judges are watching about 30 students for a couple of hours, and making notes about how they interact with each other during that time. Many of these students are such skilled speakers that they hardly seem like middle schoolers. Instead, many of them carry themselves like middle-aged adults. They speak with authority and are better able to withstand questioning than some politicians I’ve seen. These children are truly America’s future.

 By the end of the day, the entire audience of literally hundreds of students were all drained of stamina. The awards ceremony, while long, thoroughly acknowledged all of the national champions in each event. Afterwards, goodbyes were said to new friends, and the long trek home began.

 That night, we ate a nice meal at a steakhouse in downtown Des Moines. The students looked over the results of the tournament, and read feedback from the judges. Some complained, some were proud, but all of them were eager to come back and try the experience all over again next year.

 With a fuller understanding of politics than most adults, the students learned lessons about life that few other experiences could match. They had all won at least two of their five rounds and done very well for themselves, but beyond that, they had the experience of traveling to the heart of America and seeing a different aspect to the U.S. culture. The were forced out of their shells and into the world, where they learned about politics, government, and media in a sophisticated way that very few students their age have. The researched so in depth, that it would rival many master’s degree thesis papers. They made lifelong friends with their teammates. They developed a thirst for learning which is unparalleled with students their age. They learned the hope of winning and the agony of defeat. Through it all, they learned a lot about each other, but most importantly, they learned a lot about themselves.

Previous
Previous

Letting Go at the Three O’clock Hour or How to Make the Man

Next
Next

Lasagna Recipe