Giving a Minor Voice or Childism Theory and Its Relevance to the Rhetoric of Narratology

Robert Cannon

Professor Kristina Hackel

COMS 510

8 Dec. 2010


Giving a Minor Voice

or

Childism Theory and Its Relevance to the Rhetoric of Narratology


 Since the beginning of cinema, children have played a central role as characters within the narrative. The Lumiére brothers captured an epic child performance in one of the earliest film narratives The Waterer Watered (1895). As cinema progressed, each aging child film star was replaced by another. As Jackie Coogan gave way to Shirley Temple, who, in turn, gave way to Mickey Rooney, audiences came in droves to see the newest youth star sensation.

 However, while children have always been present in cinema, their stories, have not. Similarly, the study of cinema’s effects on children has been examined time and time again, but the depiction of children’s stories within cinema are given a backseat. All too often, children are used as a foil for the central adult of the narrative, leaving children’s stories largely untouched. Historically, this has not always the case for cinema, but films of the last decade seem to have forgotten the child narrative almost completely.

 While many narrative theories focus on the underrepresented side of a binary, few scholars seem to take notice of the stereotypes associated with children in cinema. Many oppressed groups have an avenue in which to speak back against repressive communication: feminist theory, queer theory, and racial theory flip the binary for marginalized groups to bring light to the way in which they are depicted. But children are one of the most stereotyped groups in all of cinema, and few children, if any, are rushing to their own defense. Perhaps because so few children engage in narrative theory, scholars seem to forget about this disenfranchised group. At no time has this been more evident than in the past decade of filmmaking.

 In order to understand the ways in which children are being depicted in modern narratives of cinema, we must first briefly define what a child is. Then we can examine a feminist theory which we can apply to what I call: childism. Finally, we can explore the stereotypes currently used in cinema, and the few exceptions which should serve as a guide to future filmmakers.


 It would be prudent to define the term ‘child’ before venturing into the theory of childism. In her book The Second Sex, writer Simone de Beauvoir asserts that, Humanity is male and man defines woman not in herself but as relative to him; she is not regarded as an autonomous being.” The same could be said of children; humanity is adult and defines child as being relative to adult-ness. This is the type of thinking which pushes children to the fray by depicting them as plot-slaves to the central adult character.

  While some countries/governments declare the age in which a child to become an adult (e.g. the age of 18 in the U.S), this is an arbitrary line drawn in the sand. Furthermore, many cultures insist that a ritual must be achieved in order for a child to pass through to adulthood (e.g. menstrual bleeding, bar mitzvah, etc.).

 However, perhaps the most universal definition is that children lack education. This education may come in the form of attending traditional school, such as we see in the character of Tom Sawyer, or in the way of learning how to cope with the world, such as the character Tate in Little Man Tate (1991).

 But, while the lack of education serves as our base definition of child, it doesn’t exclude many adults who also lack education. In order to further limit the playing field, we must also include some sort of age range. Most societies think of children as either prepubescent or in the early years of puberty. This definition certainly opens itself to exceptions, but there is no clear cut cross-culture definition of child, thus, there will always be some wiggle room. For the purposes of this paper, however, the term ‘child’ will refer to an undereducated prepubescent boy or girl.


 Now that we have defined what a child is, it is imperative to compare the depiction of children to another disenfranchised group, so that we might draw similarities between the two. Feminism springs to mind, because of the longstanding effort of the feminine gender to be recognized by a predominantly masculine narrative world, though any cultural studies methodology would be appropriate. Indeed, many of the following arguments could be substantiated through the use of racial theory, post-colonialism, queer theory, or a multitude of others.

 In her essay “Toward a Feminist Narratology,” Susan S. Lanser seeks to convince narratology itself to become more sensitive to gender issues. By comparing narratology to the texts which it analyzes, Lanser provides a feminist approach to the study of narratives, which she claims, has been largely overlooked, until now. By identifying specific areas in which literature maintains its bias against any gender other than masculinity, she is able to apply these same conventions to narratology. It is my goal to use these same arguments to make the case for the representations of children in narratology; using Lanser’s article as the backbone, I hope to create awareness of another disenfranchised group.

 Lanser begins by making the claim, “It is readily apparent that virtually no work in the field of narratology has taken gender into account, either in designating a canon or in formulating questions and hypothesis.” So, too, is the analyzation of children in narratology. While children are certainly underrepresented in the writings of narratology, this has some practical basis; the study is largely a higher educational study, and few, if any, children are reading such works, much less contributing to scholarly journals. However, perhaps this should serve as a wake-up call to narrative studies: make your writings more universally accessible, and this will generate more interest in the subject matter, even for kids. Children can learn complex ideas, if only the language is simplified and someone takes the time to clearly explain the concepts.

 Narratology must acknowledge characters within the narrative, but this is not the sacred area of study. Lanser points this out, “Most narratologists […] treat characters, if at all, as ‘patterns of recurrence, motifs which are continually recontextualized in other motifs.’” This schema is negligent to the issues of the underprivileged, and is well within narratology’s arena of study. In much the same way that narratology has the responsibility to represent non-hegemonic groups, so, too, must it address the largely unrepresented child perspective.

 Lanser further asserts, “the narratives which have provided the foundation for narratology have been either men’s texts or texts treated as men’s text.” Taking Lanser’s claim one step further, I would hazard to say that these narratives are adult men’s texts. In the same way in which women have been excluded, so too have children. Moreover, as the critique over female-ness has been labeled feminism, the critique over child-ness should be dubbed childism. Lanser would seem to agree with this concept by writing, “‘When narratology does attempt to account for the contextual, it does so in terms of narrative conventions and codes. Yet their capacity to account for social, historical, or contextual differences always remains limited by the original formalist closure within such codes and conventions are defined.’”

 Finally, Lanser writes, “A narratology that cannot account for women’s narratives is an inadequate narratology for men’s texts as well.” Clearly, the same could be said of adult texts which bypass the narratives of children.


 Now that we’ve examined feminist theory and applied it to youth in cinema, creating ‘childism,’ it will serve us to put a face on the matter by briefly examining a few films which depict children in both a negative and a positive ways.

 First: the negative aspect. Children are most often utilized in narratives as a way to enhance the adult character’s arc. While children are present within films, for the most part, their stories are ignored. In Lynn C. Miller’s essay, “Spectacle, Spectator, Screen: Feminisms and Film Theory,” Miller makes the claim that women have become victims of a cycle which portrays them, “as objects for viewer consumption” first and foremost. Rarely are women given a narrative of their own. This echos my own sentiments regarding children, as they are portrayed in narratives as mere foils to the main adult character. Instead, the arc of a character, the change which occurs by the end of the film, belongs to the adult. In films such as The Game Plan (2007), Madison Pettis’ character, Peyton Kelly, has no real arc. The structure of the plot requires that the internal change which takes place is accomplished by Dwayne Johnson’s character, Joe Kingman.

 Additionally, children in cinema usually fall into one of two stereotypical categories, neither of which posses a narrative arc from beginning to end: The first type is the naive newcomer whose sole narrative purpose is to serve as a sounding board so that the main character can explain elements of the story to the audience. The second type is the smartass. This worldly-wise often foul-mouthed character serves as a comic foil for the main adult character.

 The rare film such as Alice Doesn’t Live Here Anymore (1974) depicts a child who does not easily fit into these stereotypes; the child in such a narrative is much more dynamic than most. However, again, these stories revolve around the adult, and the child does not posses his own character arc. Films such as The Bad News Bears (1976), Curly Sue (1991), and The Pacifier (2005) all seem to focus on the narrative of the child, but upon closer examination, the plot actually revolves around an adult.

 There are, of course, exceptions to this rule, which brings us to the more positive depiction of children in cinema. These exceptions reached a fever pitch in the 1980s when films like The Breakfast Club (1985), Weird Science (1985), and Stand by Me (1986) inspired later films such as The Sandlot (1993), and The Professional (1994) to take a more dynamic approach to child characterization and to give children their own stories.

 But the modern depiction of children has changed dramatically. Tooth Fairy (2010), RV (2006), Cheaper by the Dozen (2003), and Are We There Yet? (2005) are but a few examples of the films released in the past decade which have cast aside the lessons of the 1980s and instead engaged in outright childism. About a Boy (2002) might most ironically express this sentiment, because it is, in fact, not about a boy. Clearly, the films of the ‘80s and ‘90s did not have a lasting effect.

 One of the few exceptions in the past ten years is the Jim Sheridan effort, In America (2002). Here, Sarah Bolger’s dynamic character of Christy is given a fantastic arc, separate of her father’s.

 From the beginning of the film, Christy is introverted. She lives her life through the use of a video camera, never directly viewing reality, but instead, viewing a small three-inch screen which displays it. At first glance, her character seems to be just another variation of the first stereotype: the naive newcomer. However, her narration tells the audience her innermost thoughts. These are her secrets, and she confides in us that she clings to the memory of her recently deceased younger brother, Frankie. This is Christy’s story, and her hard emotional loss, yet pleasant tone gives the audience a fresh approach to multiple realistic layers in her character. Christy’s father, Johnny, is also tormented by the loss of Frankie, to the point that he is no longer able to emote and has trouble connecting with his remaining daughters. The father’s arc in the film is evident, but as we see, it is not the central arc of the narrative.

 Christy befriends a seemingly scary man, Mateo, who lives in the same apartment building. Christy soon begins to suspect that he, too, is dying. After giving Mateo mouth-to-mouth in an effort to save him, she exposes herself to Mateo’s disease. Realizing that she is at risk, she begins to contemplate her own death, a rarity in children’s narratives, but a testament to their capacity for depth. By the end of the film, Christy uses her own character arc to urge her father to let go of his demons concerning Frankie’s passing. She is no longer introverted and dealing with Frankie’s death, and shares this perspective with her father. She has let go.

 The film is primarily about Christy. We see the world through her eyes, and this is supplemented by her narration. Moreover, the scenes throughout the film are inter-spliced with scenes shot from Christy’s camcorder. As the film progresses, we see Christy using the camera less and less. By the end of the story, she decides to turn the camera off to experience life as it happens. The last lines of the film epitomizes this sentiment, “It was as hard for Frankie to smile when the tumor was malignant as it was for my dad to cry after. But they both managed it. I'm going to switch this off now. It's not the way I want to see Frankie anymore.”

 More than just an excuse to give a child a character arc, the story represents a child’s perspective. Truly, In America is a child’s narrative. Though the arc of the father is prominent, his change is always shown through the lens [pardon the pun] of the child. By the same token, the child characters are more dynamic than the simple stereotypes seen so often in modern cinema. Both Christy and Ariel are dynamic and have multiple layers to their personalities, in much the way real humans do, regardless of age.

 Similar to Lanser’s view of marginalized femininity, the child perspective is largely disregarded. Moreover, to borrow from her central argument, a narratology that cannot account for children’s narratives is an inadequate narratology for adults’ texts as well. Modern filmmakers need to acknowledge the way in which they depict children and should become as sensitive to youth plight as they would be to other non-hegemonic groups.


 Having defined what a child is, examining Lanser’s text on feminism, and applying childism to the film In America, we can clearly understand how children are poorly represented in narratives within cinema. By examining this imbalance, new questions begin to arise, such as: Should narrative contain characters who do not posses a character arc? Must all films which portray a child have some level of arc for this character, even if he or she is not central to the general plot? The answers to these and other such questions is outside the scope of this essay, which only hopes to bring attention to this oversight, especially in modern cinema. By comparing the exclusion of feminine narratives to the exclusion of child narratives, I hope to lend credit to the idea that narratives often marginalize groups which have little to no representation in the field of narratology.

 By examining these aspects of current narrative film structures, we can awaken the ways in we depict, not just children, but any other disenfranchised minority group. If we value the equal representation of women in cinema as we do depictions of queer characters in cinema, then why do we so blatantly ignore youth? Perhaps even more groups should gain focus in narratology. The purpose of this writing is to do just that: bring light to one group which has not received a significant portion of the narratology pie, so that next time, we might serve a whole pie to everyone.


Works Cited


About a Boy. Perf. Hugh Grant. Perf. Nicholas Hoult. Dir. Chris Weitz and Paul Weitz. Tribecca Productions, 2002. Film.


Are We There Yet? Perf. Ice Cube. Dir. Brian Levant. Revolution Studios, 2005. Film.


Alice Doesn’t Live Here Anymore. Perf. Ellen Burstyn. Perf. Alfred Lutter III. Dir. Martin Scorsese. Warner Bros. Pictures, 1974. Film.


The Bad News Bears. Perf. Walter Matthau. Perf. Tatum O'Neal. Dir. Michael Ritchie. Paramount Pictures, 1976. Film.


de Beauvoir, Simone. The Second Sex. 1949. Translated by H. M. Parshley. Penguin, 1972. 8 Dec. 2010. Web <http://www.marxists.org/reference/subject/ethics/de-beauvoir/2nd-sex/index.htm>


The Breakfast Club. Perf. Emilio Estevez. Perf. Anthony Michael Hall. Perf. Judd Nelson. Perf. Molly Ringwald. Perf. Ally Sheedy. Dir. John Hughes. Universal Pictures, 1985. Film.


Cheaper by the Dozen. Perf. Steve Martin. Perf. Bonnie Hunt. Dir. Shawn Levy. Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation, 2003. Film.


Curly Sue. Perf. James Belushi. Perf. Alisan Porter. Dir. John Hughes. Hughes Entertainment, 1991. Film.


The Game Plan. Perf. Madison Pettis. Perf. Dwayne Johnson. Dir. Andy Flickman. Walt Disney Pictures, 2007. Film.


In America. Perf. Paddy Considine. Perf. Sarah Bolger. Perf. Emma Bolger. Perf. Djimon Hounsou. Dir. Jim Sheridan. Hell's Kitchen Films, 2002. Film.


Lanser, Susan S. “Toward a Feminist Narratology.” Style, 20 (3), 1986. p 342-6. Sexual Difference. In Martin McQuillan, The Narrative Reader. p. 198-201. New York: Routledge, 2005.


Little Man Tate. Perf. Jodie Foster. Perf. Adam Hann-Byrd. Dir. Jodie Foster, 1991. Film.


Miller, Lynn C. “Spectacle, Spectator, Screen: Feminisms and Film Theory.” Text and Performance Quarterly, 1 Oct. 1992. California State University Database EBSCOhost. n/d. 8 Dec. 2010. Web. <http://web.ebscohost.com.mimas.calstatela.edu/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?vid=3&hid=15&sid=376589bb-a226-4eb4-a393-d4ed303438d3%40sessionmgr14>


The Pacifier. Perf. Vin Diesel. Dir. Adam Shankman. Walt Disney Pictures, 2005. Film.


The Professional. Perf. Jean Reno. Perf. Natalie Portman. Dir. Luc Besson. Les Films du Dauphin. 1994. Film.


RV. Perf. Robin Williams. Dir. Barry Sonnenfeld. Columbia Films, 2006. Film.


Stand by Me. Perf. Wil Wheaton. Perf. River Phoenix. Perf. Corey Feldman. Perf. Jerry O'Connell. Dir. Rob Reiner. Act III Communications, 1986. Film.


The Sandlot. Perf. Tom Guiry. Perf. Mike Vitar. Perf. Patrick Renna. Perf. Chauncey Leopardi. Dir. David M. Evans. Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation, 1993. Film.


Tooth Fairy. Perf. Dwayne Johnson. Dir. Michael Lambeck.

Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation, 2010. Film.


The Waterer Watered. Perf. Benoît Duval. Dir. Louis Lumiére. Lumiére Prod, 1895. Film.


Weird Science. Perf. Anthony Michael Hall. Perf. Ilan Mitchell-Smith. Dir. John Hughes. Universal Pictures, 1985. Film.

Previous
Previous

Five Years or The Whimper We Will Go With

Next
Next

The Bad Robot or How I Messed Up a Perfectly Good Breakfast and Had the Best Conversation With Someone I Never Would Have Spoken With, Otherwise