“Privatization is Better”
by
Robert Cannon
TVF 460 Summer 2010
Heather Hindershot approaches the issue of censorship in an interesting way. From the beginning, she relates to us a specific instance of self-censorship on the part of MTV, and brings to light the 1993 story of a child in Ohio who set fire to his mobile home, and in the process, kills his younger sister. The television show Beavis and Butthead, which made constant references to fire, was blamed, and MTV pulled any references to “fire” from the show. Famously, it was later revealed that the household did not have cable television, and the boy had never seen the show.
Hindershot’s point, here, is that we are jumping to censorship issues rather quickly. She begins by defining a few terms. In this case, the difference between regulation and censorship.
Hindershot makes some interesting claims, such as the difference between permissive, paternalistic, and authoritarian as being related to 1st, 2nd, and 3rd world countries, respectively. She makes a wonderful point about how we can’t actually “vote” by turning off our television, unless we’re a Nielson family, which most of us aren’t. However, where she starts to veer off is that she often fails to see the benefit of self-censorship of the U.S. media.
The beauty of Hindershot’s perspective, I believe, is that it offers a sense of hope, even though I doubt she would see it that way. That is to say, because the regulation has been self-imposed by the media for so long, it allows itself to expand, never having faced government censorship, which would involve much more bureaucracy to undue. To put a face on it, the Internet has changed the acceptance of many words. The mention of “fuck,” for example, is so prevalent, that people barely fuckin’ notice it anymore, and they fuckin’ work it into their speech so much that they seem to have no fuckin’ concept of the underlying meaning to the word; it is often used as a pause in conversation by people, almost as if it were the sound of drawing in a breath of air. While some might say this is nothing new (people have been speaking in this way for centuries), what is new is the dissemination of messages and broadcasting of people who regularly speak in this way. Nowhere is this more obvious than through the Internet. With sensations such as YouTube, Facebook, and Twitter, the masses are expressing themselves to the rest of the world, and no one is offering regulation or censorship. Quite the contrary, the U.S. supreme court ruled it illegal in the 1990s. Because a “vulgar” lexicon is expressed en masse, watched by even larger masses, and then reflected back (read: mimicked either consciously or unconsciously by those who watch), certain words which held power in terms of obscenity (or more accurately “indecency,” as Hindershot might point out), no longer maintain their power. These words become watered down. However, advertisers continue to sponsor online shows, such as the Adam Carolla Podcast (which regularly uses every profane word imaginable); it lessens the fear that advertising is afraid of being risque. In stark contrast to many previously held beliefs, advertisers are flocking to new types of media which allow for profanity. An ad on YouTube probably cares very little about the content of the videos. Instead, it’s hoping to catch as many viewers as possible. Eventually, the regulation practices which are in effect now, will change. That is to say, at some point in the future, it may not be a big deal at all if Janet Jackson were to show her nipple during the Superbowl.
When point in time occurs, we will posses the ability to reverse decisions which are currently self-imposed. Much like the Hayes Code of the 1940s and 1950s, these regulations will seem outdated, and a new set of rules will come to take their place. However, if the government were to impose these regulations as opposed to self-regulation, we would find ourselves with an unbending bureaucratic nightmare to face. The government is always slow to action, so allowing governmental control of the censorship/regulation practices is not only ineffective, but also unconstitutional.
The overall lesson learned from this is that broadcasting breaks down our ideas of what should be censored/regulated. Because communication is reaching the masses, we are sharing ideals, and thus, all of the ideals become less potent. In 1896 the 47 second film The Kiss drew demands for police interaction and near riots all because of a kiss shared onscreen. Then, in 1939, David O. Selznick faced a similar situation when he released Gone With the Wind with Clark Gable uttering “damn” in the film’s last line. Hindershot herself makes this point when she mentions that the House of Representatives began investigating censorship of television as early as 1952, since there was a perceived correlation between what was depicted on television and juvenile violence. By today’s standards, this is the tamest of the tame. Similar kisses are shown in G rated films, and “damn” is not only regularly shown on television, it is included in most PG rated films. Additionally, the television of the 1950s is idolized for being safe (who doesn’t think of Leave It to Beaver as being good wholesome television?). Even today, television shows such as Married With Children are seen as quaint, even though, during their original broadcast time, they were seen as being the crudest show on television. Even The Simpsons has made converts out of some of the same protest groups who fought against the show in the early 90s, and who now epitomize it as one of the only shows running which exhibits core family values.
The issues of today will be defied; the films Saw and Hostel have hit censorship issues more recently, yet prove themselves to be wildly financially successful, and consequently, much more accepted in the main stream shortly thereafter. In fact, many new filmmakers are mimicking such filmmaking tactics in order to reap some of the financial success.
The point to all of this is that what society deems vulgar will change over time. Some of the images shown on MTV would never have hit the airwaves even 30 years ago. Due to the influence of the Internet, we must keep the ability to change the regulation in the hands of the people rather than the hands of the government. The lessons learned from the bureaucratic nightmare that was the health care bill should give us some sign that politicians rarely agree with one another, thus making it more and more difficult to affect change. If we don’t want to keep a stagnant society, then we must allow for private citizens and businesses to control the regulation of media… Fuck yeah.