The Culture Industry

“The Culture Industry”

by

Robert Cannon

TVF 460 Summer 2010


 Are we in control of our entertainment? Or is our consumption of entertainment a product, much like a Barbie doll, designed and directed by mysterious puppeteers who also control the world’s wealth? Interestingly, there might be a third option, which is that both could be true; we may very well be in control of our entertainment, and yet, also be guided by a cultural elite who dictate what is and isn’t entertainment.

 In The Culture Industry, Theodor Adorno makes several claims which, while rather pessimistic, ring true. However, Adorno’s thoughts prevail only so far. That is to say, his theory about the way media is both produced and consumed can be applied to a segment of media (perhaps even the majority), but at a certain point, his claims can not be applied to all media.


 Adorno claims that there is, essentially, a “culture industry.” By this, he means that the culture we experience is designed, much like any other industry would be created. He compares the culture industry to an automobile industry: there is an overall design, plan, execution, and sale of that automobile. In much the same way, the culture of the masses is designed, planned, executed, and then sold to the general public.

 But who, one might ask, is this group of people who are directing the flow of entertainment? Adorno states that the dependence of the culture industry upon other industries, necessarily ties them together. For example, the film industry needs banks to finance the films, so both industries must be reliant on one another. Theaters need the electricity created by power companies in order to operate, and they must, according to Adorno, be in cahoots. Thus, the operators of the culture industry are the same as the operators of other industries: those with money and power.

 Furthermore, Adorno asserts that the public is pushed to accept certain types of entertainment, depending on what category best suits them. The public can be separated into groups by race, gender, class, education, and a multitude of other ways. Based on this, the entertainment industry can create a few types of entertainment which would appeal to these demographics in a preordained way. Someone of a certain age, race, and education might enjoy watching Inception, while a member of a different age, race, and education level might detest the experience. Adorno would claim that the film was designed for only the first group, while other entertainment is designed for the second group.

 He goes on to state that all media is designed in this way. Even entertainment which tries to be different only reinforces these practices. When someone (perhaps Orson Welles) defies these regulations, they only “serve all the more strongly to confirm the validity of the system.”


 On some levels, Adorno might very well be correct. One needs only to take a brief look at media created by corporations such as Disney to realize that much of it is highly repetitive and serves only to create a zombie-like audience out of the viewers/listeners. Much like a marionette, Disney is controlling the strings by which many people experience culture. Television shows such as American idol, The View, Real World, I Love New York, The Hills and Jersey Shore all consist of the same vapid fulfillment. However, this complaint is nothing new. Television shows since the early 1950s have received similar complaints; who can forget shows such as Mr. Ed, My Mother the Car, and even Gilligan’s Island which all reused plots over and over again? To this extent Adorno is correct. There is definitely a group of people (those with the financial means) who are controlling what is/isn’t popular in an attempt to move society a direction which favors them financially.

 However, where Adorno begins to break down is when he applies this theory to all media. He claims the puppeteers of the culture industry, benefit by trying to promote “rubbish” to the consumers. Given that those who want rubbish are satisfied, those who want more are occasionally happy when a slight deviation of the rubbish is presented, even though it is, essentially, the same rubbish, only repackaged. By assuming that all media is held subject to the same puppeteers’ regulations is naive, in that, there are far too many outlets for true innovation to prevent the true artist from reaching his or her audience.

 Filmmakers of Adorno’s time such as Maya Deren were able to create avant-garde films which became widely known and defied all conventional plot-logic. Moreover, in terms of cinema and television (on which Adorno primarily focuses) many plots and plot devices were taken from stage and early radio plays, which ipso facto means that they were devoid of the influence of the puppeteers. In fact, many who were employed by the stage soon became employed by the celluloid, bringing with them the old style thinking of how to structure cinema. While Adorno would assert that these people, too, were controlled by the puppeteers, he cannot have his cake and eat it, too. If Adorno would not have anyone, including Maya Deren be truly creative (since he might say that she, too, is a product of this system), then one might begin to categorize his theory with other general philosophers such as Plato in his Allegory of the Cave theory. Essentially, at such a point, Adorno is making the claim that humans are either incapable of ever being truly creative, or that humans will never again become truly creative.

 Because so much media borrows from previous incarnations of other types of media, it is always updating itself and reinventing itself. At the same time, there are always new variations on these old ideas which spark new creativity. While Adorno might say this is the same old pair of socks, one might claim that all true change comes from smaller incremental changes. Biological evolution stems from minor changes, or mutations, which then cause, over time, for the species to become so varied that it no longer resembles the original. So, true, is the artistic evolution of mankind.

 Adorno claims that as soon as a film begins, one can predict the direction it will end. In some aspects of certain films, this is true. However, in genres such as film noir, there is never a definite ending to the typical plot. Perhaps one of the few defining features of this genre is that it is, regularly, unpredictable. Adorno goes on to state the same of “light” music. Assuming this to mean popular music, one could provide multiple examples of the contrary; “Freebird” hardly ends where its musical introductions would imply. The length of short stories, which Adorno next attacks, are anything but “rigidly adhered to [sic].” Writings such as the novella, the novellette, and various other lengths defy this regularly. Humor, such as gags in movies and television, is also assailed, however, what Adorno fails to recognize is that there are new jokes and gags written on a regular basis. While Adorno has a point on some level (many films do, indeed, repeat storylines and gags), there is also some level of innovation.

 One might argue that the true innovation becomes copied by less talentless “hacks” who try to benefit off of others’ originality. However, there will always be more innovation by humans, with or without the backing of the puppeteers. They are not a “mockery” to art which has come before.

 Futhermore, the advance of technology does not limit creativity, but instead it enhances it. The advent of sound technology does not limit film, as Adorno would have it, rather, it adds another element. By his rationale, if no paintings were to have ever used the color red, and then such a pigment were invented, paintings which now use the new color would “leave no room for the imagination or reflection […} of the audience.” Sound, and technology in general, is a tool which artists may or may not use, nothing more or less. To imply that we cannot imagine things when sound is present again implies that the masses are zombies. While to some extent, this may very well be true, not everyone is bitten, and some non-infected humans still exist. Many artists willfully enter the mainstream, even though many would consider them to be on the social fringes of society. Nirvana’s music was, by their own definition, pop music first and punk music second. But with that said, films such as Koyanaskatsi and Mulholland Drive and bands such as The Residents and Ween shatter such molds. Even comedian Adam Carolla proves Adorno’s theory untrue, in that he was fired from his corporate morning drive time radio DJ show, only to create a new show, this one podcasted online, which has very little overhead costs, and which allows him the freedom to say literally whatever he wishes, including gags and jokes which would never be allowed to hit terrestrial radio airwaves.

 Through this, the Internet seems to be the great equalizer of the masses. Historian and Internet theorist Clay Sharky addresses skeptic thoughts regarding the Internet, which mirror Adorno’s. Sharky states that technology allows “base” thoughts which are already in us to escape, not that technology creates “base” thoughts. This holds true whether these base thoughts are the invention of pornographic images (which were present almost immediately after the invention of both cinema and photography) or whether it is the controlling puppeteers who use the medium for mass control. Sharky goes on to state in the July 5, 2010 issue of The Guardian that erotic novels were created almost immediately after the invention of the printing press, however, it took 150 years for the first English scientific journal to make the scene. In much the same way, Adorno seems to romanticize the pre-World War I era of cinema, yet fails to recognize that this era, more than any other, was dictated by monetary gains, since it was controlled by a relatively few and was generally seen by those few as nothing more than a passing fad, which should provide only temporary profits. In the previously cited Guardian article, Sharky goes on to state that “I think every bit of time spent fretting about the fact that people have base desires which they will use this medium to satisfy is a waste of time – because that's been true of every medium ever launched." Yet, at the same time, Sharky is the first to admit that television leads to passive viewing, thus he does not own a television and feels that it has more drawbacks than benefits. Thus, his opinion supports the claim that on some levels Adorno is correct, however, to encompass all media into his theory is a mistake, since there are so many exceptions to prove otherwise.


 Ultimately, there are simply too many exceptions to Adorno’s theory for it to hold water for all art and mass media. While it certainly holds true to some extent, it cannot be considered a Theory of Everything in mass media.

 Adorno’s viewpoints seem to be more true, historically, when the power of the church or government was more almighty. Perhaps several hundreds, if not thousands of years ago, this theory would hold more weight, but with the proliferation of mass communication, it becomes less likely. In today’s western culture, total control over anything is almost impossible, even for the governments. Luckily, however, Adorno seems to find a ray of hope. When he writes “[the culture industry’s influence] will be broken […] by the hostility inherent in the principle of entertainment,” he seems to be saying that it is possible to change the direction of the culture industry, and perhaps even take it back into the hands of the people. Perhaps the invention and wide spread use of the Internet has already made this possibility a reality.

Previous
Previous

Putting the ‘Post’ in Post-Apocalyptic

Next
Next

Raven