The Ideology Warrior or How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Just Enjoy the Dang Movie

Robert Cannon

Professor Kristina Hackel

COMS 510

23 Oct. 2010


The Ideology Warrior

or

How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Just Enjoy the Dang Movie


 Pow! Straight from the start of the film, The Road Warrior (1982) is an adrenaline-pumped action flick which holds up today just as it did upon first release. However, many critics have noted that the plot of The Road Warrior is reminiscent of films audiences have seen before. In particular, The Road Warrior borrows so many plot elements from the B-movie Westerns of the 1950s that one might argue against classifying it as a sci-fi film. Aside from the difficulty in labeling the film’s genre for a video rental store, the ideologies are one of the most noteworthy aspects to the film. Here, I use the term ideology to mean any sort of economic or political standing, theory, position, or policy. Ultimately, this leads to the question: Does the lack of originality in The Road Warrior’s plot prevent it from having an original ideology? In order to answer this question, one might best look to Umberto Eco’s essay “Narrative Structure in Ian Fleming.” This essay is perfect for analysis, because Eco outlines clear plot actions within author Ian Fleming’s James Bond novels and also provides insight into the possibility of ideology being present in genre films. By first examining Eco’s essay, then applying it to the film The Road Warrior, we can gain a better understanding of the film’s ideology and draw conclusions about, not only the film in question, but perhaps, all genre films.


 In “Narrative Structures in Ian Fleming,” Eco makes the claim that all James Bond novels follow such a predictable pattern that we seem to know how James Bond will save the day as soon as we’ve seen the cover of the book. Eco crystalizes this for the reader by going so far as to reduce all his novels down to nine simple actions, which he notes similar to chess moves:

 A. M moves and gives a task to Bond.

 B. Villain moves and appears to Bond.

 C. Bond moves and gives a first check to Villain, or     Villain gives a first check to Bond.

 D. Woman moves and shows herself to Bond.

 E. Bond takes woman.

 F. Villain captures Bond.

 G. Villain tortures Bond.

 H. Bond beats Villain.

 I. Bond, convalescing, enjoys Woman, whom he then loses.

 These nine tenets help us understand any given James Bond novel, in that, according to Eco, all Fleming novels will have some elements of these plot lines. For example, when examining Fleming’s novel Diamonds are Forever (1956), Eco asserts that the sequence is as follows: A, B, D, B, B, E, C, B, C, F, G, H, E, B, H, I, H. By understanding this sequence of events and its application into Fleming novels, one can begin to draw conclusions about the originality of Fleming’s work; obviously, Eco feels that there was none. Eco furthers this idea by stating that a genre-typical novel, such as a James Bond spy book, could not provide any original ideology other than that inherent in the genre, itself. Granted, Eco notes that there is a possible ideology present even in the most stereotypical of plots, but he emphasizes that this ideology is actually expressed through the choice of the way in which they are structured instead of from the meaning behind these structures. It seems unlikely that Fleming was concerned expressing an ideology. Instead, it seems as if he was more concerned with the enjoyment of his readers than he was concerned with breaking new literary ground. Furthermore, asserts Eco, almost every detective/spy novel follows an expected similar plot structure, and readers ostensibly become upset when an author deviates from the established norm. To put a finer point on it, the author who uses these established norms does not seek to express any new ideologies. Instead, what is expressed are the ideologies which we find already embedded in the pre-established structure.


 Now that we’ve examined Eco’s essay, we can apply it to the film The Road Warrior. However, before we are able to successfully do so, we must establish a set of criteria similar to Eco’s which might better apply to The Road Warrior. Joseph M. Boggs’ book The Art of Watching Films (1996 385-8) does just this, by laying out a strikingly similar nine-point list of tenets found in a typical Western film. While The Road Warrior may not be classified as a Western in the eyes of Netflix, it does, by all accounts, follow a typical Western film structure.

 Boggs’ tenets of a typical Western genre film are paraphrased in the following formula:

 1. Setting: the edge of the frontier where civilization encroaches on the savage untamed land beyond.

 2. Hero: a rugged individualist, he is often a loner type. Aloof, he acts according to his own code, not in response to community pressures. Intelligent and resourceful, he is also kind, honest, and firm, never cruel or petty. Even-tempered, he does not seek violence, but responds with violent action when the situation demands it [emphasis original]. Extraordinarily quick, the hero’s guns are unique (pearl handles, hair triggers, etc). Additionally, the hero’s horse is always the fastest.

 3. Heroine: there are four basic types. (A) The rancher’s daughter of a wealthy background similar to a Southern belle. (B) The rancher’s daughter of the tomboy type. (C) The Schoolmarm. (D) The worldly-wise dance hall tough girl with a heart of gold.

 4. Villain: two types of villains seem to prevail. (A) The savages/outlaws who bully and threaten the town, usually taking what they want by force (Indians fall into this category quite easily). (B) Slick, underhanded villains who conduct their misdeeds under the guise of respectability (bankers, saloon owners, ranchers, etc.).

 5. Other Important Characters: a sidekick, quite often a crazy miner type, is usually met by the hero in the beginning of the film, before he comes into town. Often operating as the comic relief, the sidekick seems to understand the plight of the townsfolk but is not a part of them. The initiate hero is a kind of son figure to the hero; still a bit green, he seeks to follow the hero’s code.

 6. Conflict: society is threatened by corruption/greed or faces external threats from uncivilized forces.

 7. Resolution: the hero leads the community to fight off the threat. Once everyone is safe, the hero must move along.

 8. Values Reaffirmed: justice prevails and good triumphs over evil.

 9. Conventions: costumes are used to typify and differentiate the good guys from the bad guys; good guys wear white, bad guys wear black. In terms of the action sequence at the end of the film, most films will show either a shootout on the town’s only street or a prolonged chase on horseback. Although a love might ensue between the hero and heroine, it never reaches fruition, and the hero moves on at the end. A structural convention is that many films begin with a hero riding into frame from the left, and end with him riding off in the opposite direction, usually into a fading sunset.

 Now that we’ve examined Boggs’ tenets of a typical Western genre film, we can apply these traits to The Road Warrior.

 Set in the Australian Outback, the film certainly embodies the first of Boggs’ tenets. The action takes place at the edge of the frontier, so similar to typical American Westerns.

 Mel Gibson’s portrayal of “Mad” Max Rockatansky is a dead-on demonstration of the second tenet; Max plays by his own rules, though he is not cruel. His sawed-off shotgun is unlike any of the other weapons, and his car is by far the fastest.

 The first and only glaring dissimilarity is Boggs’ third trait, the heroine. No heroine is present in The Road Warrior, but this is the only tenet of Boggs’ which goes unmet.

 The villains, however, are spot-on. The marauders rape and pillage to such destruction that even Max is shocked. The villains in this case are Boggs’ former type; similar to Indians, they harass the civilization inside the compound. As if the similarities weren’t enough, the hairstyles chosen for the savages in The Road Warrior are reminiscent of Indians: many sport the mohawk hairdo.

 The fifth tenet is also fulfilled in both arenas. The sidekick is portrayed by the humorous Gyro Captain, and the initiate hero is exemplified by the Feral Kid character, who idolizes and mimics Max’s actions.

 The conflict is clear; the small civilization in the film, which has somehow managed to find, pump, and refine oil is threatened by the savages’ constant attack.

 As well, the resolution is upheld. Max leads the final breakout of the compound and successfully drives the savages in the opposite direction from the townspeople so that they can make their escape. At the end of the film, the initiate hero (the Feral Kid) is returned to society. Max does not join the society, and chooses instead to roam the countryside.

 As predicted, society’s values are reaffirmed, and order is restored. Justice is, once again, put in place.

 Finally, the conventions in the film are also demonstrated. The members of the civilization all wear white or light-colored clothes, while the members of the savages wear black or dark colors. The only exception is Max, himself. Max dresses like the savages, which is a sign to the audience that he rides the line between savage and civilized. Additionally, the shootout at the end of the film occurs on both “horseback” and on the town’s only street. Lastly, the bookending shots of Max are also used; the first time we see Max is a fast dolly-in shot of his car in the middle of the afternoon, and the last time we see him is in a slow motion dolly-out with the sunset in the background.

 Clearly, The Road Warrior demonstrates the qualities of a Western film, as Boggs’ defines it. Some might classify it as a Western genre film in a pair of sci-fi pants.

 But now that we’ve seen the qualities of a Western genre executed in The Road Warrior, what are we to glean? We can now return to our original research question: Does the lack of originality in The Road Warrior’s plot prevent it from having an original ideology? The answer here is a resounding no. In fact, there are quite a few ideologies present: responsible use of energies/fuel; the emergence of a dangerous punk subculture; and the fear of impending nuclear holocaust, to name only a few.

 If we return to Eco’s observation that the reuse of these plot lines does not “aspire to express any ideology,” one might assume that The Road Warrior does not push any agenda. In other words, Eco would have us believe that The Road Warrior does not demonstrate an overall teaching, because we’ve seen this type of film time and time again. However, a mere scratch at the surface shows that this isn’t the case. Given that The Road Warrior was released in 1982, one might begin to juxtapose the film with the political climate of the time. The world had just emerged from an oil and energy crisis during the 1970s and was clearly fearful of a worldwide nuclear war. Australia, America’s longtime ally, would certainly be caught up in both the energy crisis and the potential nuclear war, thus, the portrayal of these near-future occurrences was realistic for Australians.

 This flies in the face of Eco’s assumption that a genre-type film cannot produce an original ideology. However, the ideology that society’s future remains hopeful is illustrated by the diametric use of the Feral Kid and the terrorizing punks. This, in conjunction with the futuristic setting and the reveal at the end of the film that the narrator of the story was the Feral Kid, demonstrates that an original ideology is inherent within the film, thus proving Eco wrong. This example shows how the youth of today’s world will not let society down, despite the misguided and destructive choices other generations have made. This ideology is nowhere evident in the typical genre-type Western film.

 Eco would have us believe that by using the same structures over and over again, audiences have come to expect an “entertainment flick.” Eco might further assert that, while we fully enjoy these flicks, they don’t provide any real insight into an original ideology, only a new repackaging of that ideology; same ol’ shit, brand new wrapping paper. He likens the probability of an original idea in a genre-type medium to the chances of The Harlem Globetrotters being beaten by a local basketball team. However, I would like to make the counterclaim that every dog has his day: a clever and resourceful team of filmmakers might utilize these stereotypical elements of genre to make ideological arguments, as was the case in The Road Warrior.

 Moreover, The Road Warrior holds up over time and is well-received by fans and critics alike. While one might assume that audiences may stray from a film which bends the expected use of genre stereotypes such as this one, this is not so for The Road Warrior. According to Eco, audiences would come to expect the lack of ideology in the film. Succinctly put, some people might feel disappointed in a film which injects an ideology into the typicalities of a genre film, but The Road Warrior defies this logic. Currently, the film holds a coveted 100% rating from RottenTomatoes.com, proving that it has a strong positive stance with film critics. Similarly, imdb.com users rate the film at 7.6, just shy of the top 250 films of all time. Furthermore, Empire Magazine has placed it in their “Top 500 Movies of All Time” list, The New York Times has it on their “Best 1000 Movies Ever Made” list, and Entertainment Weekly placed Mad Max as the 11th “Coolest Hero in Pop Culture.” Truly, the film is well regarded as an action and sci-fi masterpiece.

  With this in mind, how did The Road Warrior succeed in inserting ideologies without alienating it’s audience. Personally, I believe it was the spirit which was somehow captured in The Road Warrior which separates it from more modern similar takes, such as Waterworld (1995). Perhaps Waterworld alienated audiences because of its ironic agenda of saving the Earth from global pollution, while simultaneously being such a monstrous big-budget project that it more than doubled the pollution of most other films of the era. Perhaps audiences were alienated because of the disingenuous and uninspired wardrobe which seemed forced and stolen from The Road Warrior. Or, perhaps Costner’s acting was just that bad. Either way, the magic of independent cinema and a true ideology infused within every frame results in the success of an entertainment flick, and if properly executed, will cement its place in film lore.

 

 Having examined Eco’s essay and applied it to the film The Road Warrior, we can now take umbrage to the notion that a “machine (120)” which merely repositions the same tenets cannot provide insight about a new ideology. As illustrated, original ideologies are present in the film, and both audiences and critics recognize them, thus keeping the popularity of the film quite high. If you haven’t seen The Road Warrior, I would urge the reader to rush out and rent it; as the title of this essay suggests, you’ll just enjoy the dang thing. While you’ll see every plot turn coming, that doesn’t devalue the film. Moreover, you may never see the ideology sneaking up on you until Mad Max fades into the sunset.

Works Cited


“20 All Time Coolest Heroes in Pop Culture.” Entertainment Weekly. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. <http://www.ew.com/ew/gallery/0,,20268279_10,00.html>.


“The 500 Greatest Movies of All Time.” Empire. Web. 15 Oct 2010. <http://www.empireonline.com/500/41.asp>


Boggs, Joseph M. The Art of Watching Films Fourth Edition. Mountain View, California: Mayfield Publishing Company, 1996. 385-386. Print.


Eco, Umberto. “Narrative Structure in Ian Fleming.” The Narrative Reader. Ed. Martin McQuillan. New York: Routledge, 2000. 115-120. Print.


The Film Critics of the New York Times. “The Best 1,000 Movies Ever Made.” New York Times. 2004. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. <http://www.nytimes.com/ref/movies/1000best.html>.


The Road Warrior. Dir. George Miller. Perf. Mel Gibson. Warner Brothers, 1982. Film.


“The Road Warrior.” imdb.com. 15 Oct. 2010. <http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0082694/combined>.


“The Road Warrior.” Rotten Tomatoes. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. <http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/road_warrior/>.


Waterworld. Dir. Kevin Reynolds, Kevin Costner. Perf. Kevin Costner. Universal, 1995. Film.







Previous
Previous

15 Minute Warhol or What We’ll All Get Someday

Next
Next

Whiches or Why Glenda was a Witch with a Capital B