Robert Cannon
Dr. Ken Windrum
TVF 462
28 Oct. 2010
The Problem of Having Too Much Money
or
How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Take a Holiday
From the beginning, Holiday (1938) portrays a love which is ultimately doomed. While Johnny (Cary Grant) and Julia (Doris Nolan) seem to be the perfect couple, we know that there is an underlying tension which spells nothing but trouble for the new couple. But the film, unlike their relationship, is a success.
In choosing a film for this essay, Holiday seemed most interesting because I had never seen it before; I thought I might gain a better insight by watching a fresh film. Moreover, I chose to focus on the second option given to the class: analyzing a specific sign in the film and demonstrating how it expresses an ideology.
Holiday provides a great symbolic element which is worthy of examining and provides the thrust of this essay: Linda’s (Katherine Hepburn) play room demonstrates the deep divide between social class systems of the time. But the separation of these classes is the result of something much more significant than money. This paper seeks to analyze the narrative sign of the play room in order to not only understand the division of social classes of the 1930s, but to gain a better insight into what divides them, today. In order to illustrate this symbolism, we will first briefly discuss the plot of the film, then examine the symbolism of the play room, and finally glean some implications of what this connection holds for modern audiences who watch the film.
The story of Holiday is nothing new to savvy audiences. While the specifics have changed over time, we have seen this plot before. However, this characteristic alone does not preclude Holiday from being a fine film, but truly excels in demonstrating social class divisions.
The film’s backstory involves Johnny, fresh back from a short vacation to Lake Placid, who has met and fallen deeply in love with Julia. After a mere 10 days, he has already proposed to her, and the film opens with Johnny visiting her palatial estate, to meet her family. Right away, Johnny is portrayed as a fish-out-of-water, and this is a clear sign the romance is doomed. As if this weren’t enough, Johnny seems to get along with Julia’s sister, Linda, a little too well. Soon, Johnny has won Julia’s family over, and her father (Henry Kolker) throws a large engagement party for them both. But something is clearly rotten in Denmark, for Linda refuses to emerge from her room for the entirety of the party, much to the chagrin of the guests who await her. As Johnny’s friends, Mr. & Mrs. Potter, arrive at the party, they accidentally find their way into Linda’s play room and quickly befriend her. Once Johnny finds all of them hiding out in the play room instead of enjoying the engagement party downstairs, they end up having more fun in this little room than they would have had at the main party. It becomes all too clear that Johnny and Linda were meant to be together, while Julia now seems to be in the way.
As if this weren’t enough, Julia’s father offers a job to Johnny which he does not want to take. Instead, his desire in life is to go sailing, and he asks Julia to go with him. Julia balks and sides with her father, insisting that Johnny walk the straight and narrow. After lots of hoopla, Linda, the self-described “black sheep” of the family, breaks from her father’s rule. She sides with Johnny’s decision to go sailing once she discovers that Julia was secretly relieved to be rid of Johnny. Soon, Linda claims Johnny for herself. We end with Linda and Johnny, the true soul mates, sailing happily ever after.
Having examined the story behind the film, we can now take a closer look at the symbolism of the room in which Linda hides for the majority of the engagement party. But before we can look to the room, we must first examine the entire house, for the room only gains its symbolism through its contrast to the rest of the mansion.
As Johnny first walks through the house, he is in such awe of the architecture and ornateness that he stumbles over a small table and nearly breaks a vase. He, much like the audience, is amazed at the quantity of money clearly invested in the mansion, and Cary Grant’s performance clues the audience in Johnny’s outside class status. However, Johnny is a true individual. His reaction to being in such an incredible space is to perform a trademark cartwheel, which he regularly enacts when his mood is high. Johnny is in awe of the money he is about to marry into, but he never stops being himself, as is demonstrated by his cartwheel.
To say that the mansion is big is an understatement. At one point in the film, Johnny actually becomes lost within the house; the multiple staircases give the building a layered feel that is reminiscent of a tall wedding cake; and Julia’s brother Ned (Lew Ayres) remarks that the house has rooms inside of which he hasn’t seen for years. Only the finest paintings, crown moldings, and marble floors decorate the interior of the mansion. And as if the audience couldn’t take a subtle hint, Julia goes so far as to remark that her family is one of the “America Sixty Families:” a group of the sixtieth richest families in the United States, as defined by Ferdinand Lundberg in 1936. Clearly, money is not a problem for this household.
But Johnny is not impressed with the money, nor is he committed to marrying Julia for such means. Instead, he is a hopeless romantic, bound for his next adventure. Similarly, Linda is not impressed with her family’s money. Instead, she wishes that they were able to use the money for a good cause, rather than self indulgence. Her self-imposed nickname of “black sheep” becomes a running gag between Linda and Johnny for the entirety of the picture, as they make goat and sheep sounds at one another (this also serves as a method of foreshadowing the inevitable events at the end of the picture).
The crucial symbolism occurs during the engagement party scene. Linda originally puts herself in charge of planning the party, but this responsibility was quickly taken away from her by her father, who, in turn, squashes every design she had planned; it became the exact opposite of the party she envisioned. With the control of the party out of her hands, Linda hides herself in her favorite room in the house: the play room.
The play room is Ferdinand de Saussure’s dream. Filled with musical instruments and a ratty couch, the room represents the plight of the common people of the era. Most people during the 1930s had similar rooms (decrepit furniture and stained rugs). Audiences could relate to this. Additionally, one of the prime forms of entertainment during the era was to play music for one another, also serving to relate Linda and Johnny’s characters to the audiences of the 1930s. Had these audiences ventured into a mansion amidst the Great Depression, they would have felt just as uncomfortable as Johnny. This room becomes a lonely beacon of everyday Americans in the middle of an ocean of industrial wealth.
Holiday was released in 1938, right before the end of the Great Depression. With that in mind, the excessively large sets of Julia’s house dominate both the frame of the film, and the mind of Johnny. The audiences were weary of wealth during this time period, allowing the filmmakers to use this as a plot device to advance their own story. In fact, audiences’ minds were so devoted to monetary issues, that the cinema itself began to change, so as to meet the emotional demands of the day. One such cinematic development was the establishment of the screwball comedy genre, of which Holiday is a prime example. Simply put, The Great Depression made audiences so distrustful of wealth, that the very genre of film we are examining came to fruition (Thompson and Bordwell 211-212). The audience aligns themselves with Johnny — the everyman — and also becomes endeared to his friends when Mrs. Potter (Jean Dixon) discovers a run in her stocking at the engagement party; who hasn’t had this happen to them? While it may not be a run in a stocking, we’ve all had similar enough experiences that we immediately relate to these characters’ uncomfortable social situations. This solidifies the audience’s relationship with the lower class while also devaluing higher class culture.
The overall symbolism here is not that the film values the lower class over the poor; instead, it seeks to say that only the lower class hard-working people actually have character. And character is clearly more important than money. Linda’s room embodies this character in several ways. The musical instruments and toys inside the room show us a sillier side of life, and these types of trinkets are found nowhere else in the mansion. The furniture, too, is unlike the rest inside of the stuffy mansion. For example, the fun associated with the couch is far more than we could expect Julia’s father is having during the engagement party. The couch becomes relatable to mainstream 1930s audiences: the dance scene between Johnny and Linda has them “riding the couch” by standing on the back and performing a controlled fall. Moreover, the room itself serves as an emotional connection to one of the main characters: Linda stays in the room because of the relationship she has with the memory of her deceased mother. This, too, relates a lower class Gret Depression audience to Linda, and the room, since it seems nostalgic to hold on to these types of memories, thus giving Linda and the room character. These symbols serve to reassure the audience that there are greater things in life than money.
By not emerging from the room during the party, Linda is thumbing her nose at the bourgeoisie. She refuses to become a participate with their character-less gathering, even though many of her family members berate her for doing so. Linda views them as inferior, not because they have money, but because they have no spark for life inside them. Clearly the sin, here, is not that those with money are bad (indeed, both Linda and Julia are from the same family, which is clearly wealthy). Instead, the sin is not living life to its fullest. To dedicate oneself to working in a stuffy ol’ bank is the complete opposite of setting sail, like Johnny desires. To be anyone but yourself is the mortal sin of this film, and the only way to counter this sin is to live with a great heart. The only room in the house which has this heart is the play room, and it’s little wonder that this is where the two protagonists begin to establish their relationship.
Now that we’ve taken a closer look at Linda’s play room, we can begin to understand the meaning behind its presence in the film. Holiday was released during one of the most economically difficult times in the United States’ history. It was no accident that the portrayal of excessive money would have strong emotional reactions from audiences. A film of the reverse perspective (that is, a film which values those with money over those with a zest for life) would have been met with great animosity. The people of the era needed, more than anything, a pick-me-up. Even though these people had been financially beaten down over and over for the better part of ten years, they also understood that placing the blame on those with money was not the ideal solution to America’s problems. It is precisely this same concern which lead to the emergence of the musical and fantasy films (Thompson and Bordwell 210); audiences wanted to escape the drudgeries of life through film. This film gains the best of both worlds; it glorifies the money many audiences sought, but also praised what the lower classes had in spaded: character.
But what does this mean for us, today? The message of Holiday might be even better served today as it was seventy years ago: to thine own self be true. We are constantly bombarded with messages in today’s media that money is the root of happiness. Despite quaint notions of euphemisms such as “money can’t buy you happiness,” the practice of Americans seems to be quite the opposite. In music, film, television, novels, and countless other arenas, we are pushed the idea that money is extremely important. But, as the cliché goes, money isn’t everything.
According to a September 7th, 2010 article from Inc.com, a pair of researchers from Princeton University discovered that Americans do not gain any happiness once they’ve reached the $75,000 ceiling. The point of this tidbit ties into the film, demonstrating the central position of the movie, and the play room in particular: money isn’t bad, it’s great! We all want money. But what is bad is when those who do have money don’t use it to live life fully. Repeating the same conventions over and over proves to be about as useful as a chocolate kettle. Instead, what those who have money need to do is go out and do something.
To that end, the film is a success. I enjoy the aspect that they do not chastise those with money because, while it might have been an easier step for the filmmakers to take, it provides a deeper and more realistic look into human nature. The point of the the play room is to go out and be oneself. The beauty of that sentiment is that money doesn’t dictate that goal. Modern-day audiences don’t need $75,000 a year to do what we want, even if we want to do absolutely nothing. To quote the film Office Space (1999), “You don't need a million dollars to do nothing, man. Take a look at my cousin: he's broke, don't do shit.” This is what we can derive from watching Holiday: we can look back to the films of that era, when money literally meant the difference between life and death, and we can gain insight into our own lives. Money means very little, but character is what life is all about. With the right level of understanding, someone today might achieve the same level of zen as did Johnny from Holiday.
Ultimately, the cinematic signs within the film are plentiful, but the play room is, for me, the most representative of the entire film’s message. By taking a look at the film’s plot, the symbolism of the play room, and then examining the impact that this symbolism has on a modern-day audience, we can learn to appreciate the film on a deeper level: the film does not talk down to its audience. Instead, it suggest a philosophy and way of thinking about how we live our lives. With that in mind, we might begin to consider taking a “holiday” to find our own character.
Works Cited
“America’s Sixty Families.” Wikipedia. Web. 28 Oct. 2010. <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/America's_Sixty_Families>
Holiday. Dir. George Cukor. Perf. Cary Grant. Perf. Doris Nolan. Perf. Katherine Hepburn. Perf. Lew Ayres. Perf. Jean Dixon. Perf. Edward Everett Horton. Perf. Henry Kolker. Columbia Pictures, 1938. Film.
Office Space. Dir. Mike Judge. Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation, 1999. Film.
The Road Warrior. Dir. George Miller. Perf. Mel Gibson. Warner Brothers, 1982. Film.
Rubin, Courtney. “At What Price Happiness? $75,000.” Inc.com. 7 Sept 2010. Web. 28 Oct. 2010. <http://www.inc.com/news/articles/2010/09/study-says-$75,000-can-buy-happiness.html>
Thompson, Kristin and David Bordwell. Film History: An Introduction Third Edition. Boston; McGraw Hill, 2010. p 210; 211-212. Print.