Understanding What’s Truly Important: Not Understanding

“Understanding What’s Truly Important: Not Understanding”

by

Robert Cannon

TVF 460 Summer 2010


 Hall begins by pointing out that the concept of communication, while supposedly in a “loop” form, is actually rather linear: the traditional model of sender/message/receiver is a line, rather than a loop. Hall proposes that perhaps a stronger way of expressing the way communication works could be to think of it as “production, circulation, distribution/consumption, reproduction.” Thus, communication is a infinite loop, rather than a line, and the loop has no definite beginning and end.

 Through this manner, if information is sent, it must be understood, reproduced in some way, and then passed along the chain of communication. If, however, information is not understood, then it cannot, of course, be passed along the chain. Hence, Hall states, “No one moment can fully guarantee the next moment with which it is articulated.” This can be seen, as Hall points out, through a television program. While most people might say that a television program is created by the workers who labored on it, Hall would argue that these workers have been influenced in some way by other t.v. shows, which were, in turn, inspired by media which preceded it. This example shows us that the meaning inherent in all media is more of a cycle or a chain which never ends, rather than a straight line, which is the normal construct.

 In essence, the audience, too must be influenced by the show; those who watch The Simpsons will soon find themselves quoting Homer on a regular basis. Thus, the chain is never-ending, and each consumer is also a producer.

 Hall points out that the reception is the predominant element to communication, because it marks the time when the message is understood by the audience.

 Where things get tricky, is that many, if not all, messages are “encoded.” The encoding process is a way for the message to be sent so that it can move through the medium. For example, a scantily clad girl on television cannot perform lewd acts with a boy, because the standards and practices division of that television station would be up in arms. However, if she eats a banana in a suggestive manner, the audience at home becomes aware of what her character might do, sexually speaking. Through these means, the message has become encoded. To a five year-old, the scantily clad girl seems hungry for fruit. To the twenty-five year-old hormone-driven male, something else, entirely is suggested. Therefore, a “decoding” is happening on the part of the twenty-five year-old. With that in mind, Hall states that what the five year-old experiences by watching that image is a “distortion.” Essentially, the five year-old has misunderstood the message.

 Hall goes on to state that some codes are created in such a way that we take them for granted. Some codes, such as the display of human blood, seem so universal that anyone from any culture would have the same reaction. However, as universal as it might seem, these are still cultural conventions which have been created and then given to successive generations. Hall calls this phenomena naturalization.

 Hall then clarifies the distinction between “connotation” and “denotation.” Denotation, he states, is the essential meaning behind the sign. Using our example from earlier, if the scantily clad girl eating the banana is viewed and the five year-old believes she is merely hungry for fruit, then this would be called denotation. If, however, she was meant to be shown as being rather risque, then the connotation would be that she might be prone to offering fellatio.

 Hall says that by using these two concepts, we can gauge the levels where naturalization and communication intersect. The understanding of the message, whether it be denotative or connotative, is left up to cultural hierarchy, which can be changed depending on the values of that culture (usually designed and directed by economic and political power).

 Here, Hall points out that if our twenty-five year-old hormone-driven male were not to understand the sexual innuendo, the producers of the show might go through some trouble in order to straighten out the miscommunication. Hall argues that the producers of the show would say that the audience is “not within the dominant or preferred code.”

 Through that, Hall says that there are three ways to take the coded message: dominant, negotiated, and globally. The dominant way is such that the audience “gets it.” They understand the message in the way that the creator(s) intended it. The negotiated position is, essentially, a view which is not the intended understanding. Finally, Hall states that there is a third option; the global way would be to understand the intended meaning, but to choose an alternate position.

 Hall’s definitions of the way we communicate offer up a fresh approach on the traditional style of thinking about how we communicate. He allows for much more wiggle room in communication, in that, the more traditional theory about sender/message/receiver does not take into consideration the possibility of the receiver not understanding the message which was sent. Through Hall’s method though, we can begin to more readily understand both how we understand communication, and perhaps more importantly, how we miscommunicate.

Previous
Previous

Can TV See Class? Or How I learned to Stop Worrying and Believe in the American Dream

Next
Next

Rejection or The Coldness of Winter