Robert Cannon
Professor Hackel
TVF 454
24 Jan. 2011
20 Films of Influence in as Many Years
or
The Top Twenty Transformational Talkies in Twenty Twelvemonth
While thousands of top movie lists have been made, many of them are written based on which movies the author likes best. While this doesn’t limit the value of such a list, they ultimately become a reflection of what the author experienced when watching the film. In other words, if an author had a bad day and saw Dumb and Dumber (1994), then the likelihood of that film showing up on his top twenty list is remote. Likewise, if his mood was good, chances are that Anaconda (1997) might rear its ugly head—in more ways than one.
This list is constructed, not by which films I enjoyed most (though I did enjoy most of them), but by what kind of influence the film has had on later American films. While the list is not limited to American films, what is important in consideration is the influence on American cinema. Clearly one of the most impressive films in the last twenty years is Titanic (1997), however, while certainly influential on some level, I’m not convinced that it influenced as many films as others as seen through my perspective.
20. The Sixth Sense (1999 Dir. M. Night Shyamalan)
Not only was this sleeper film one of the best examples of a film with ‘legs,’ it opened the Pandora’s Box which we now call ‘M. Night Shyamalan.’ Few people had heard of Shyamalan before The Sixth Sense, but quickly after this film hit theaters, his became a common household name.
This is damn fine film. No way about it, it deserves a great deal of the hype surrounding it. The performances are all subtle and yet intriguing. Few movies have instilled in audiences the desire to run out and right away see the film again like this one did. The film is intriguing the first time around, and only becomes better on the second helping.
Quite possibly, one of the most interesting aspects of the film is the influence that it’s had on American audiences. It signaled the end of the slasher era in horror films, and the beginning of a newer psychological horror film which paved the way for films like The Ring (2002), and The Grudge (2004). While these two films were based on Japanese originals, American audiences were not used to horror films with such little blood and gore. Scream (1996) had been released only a short time before, and it revitalized the slasher sub-genre. However, the noose was tied for this type of film, as The Sixth Sense ushered in the new era of fuck-with-your-head-after-the-film type of storytelling.
As for Shyamalan’s subsequent work? Note that none of them are on this list…
19. Home Alone (1990 Dir. Chris Columbus)
There was an era when films at the box office just became prodigious. It seemed to start in 1989 with Batman (1989). While blockbusters certainly existed long before then, Hollywood seemed to have things down to a science. Look Who’s Talking (1989), The Little Mermaid (1989) and Ghostbusters II (1989) were topping the family film box offices, but in 1990 a new kid on the block changed everything.
Home Alone roped in kids like few films before it. While I remember being slightly annoyed at the dopey audiences falling for such schlocky humor, I must admit that I found myself chuckling a few times. The film is cheesy and Macaulay Culkin’s acting is less than stellar, but the film changed the game for big budget family comedies. If films in the 1980s such as Honey I Shrunk the Kids (1989) were the dress rehearsal, then Home Alone was the opening night performance. Theaters everywhere were selling out, and the entire nation went Culkin crazy, the aftereffects are still being felt today when we watch a Culkin brother in a low-budget indie film.
Home Alone had its moments. While certainly not everyone’s cup of tea, the film is not embarrassing. In fact, it’s rather quaint. It’s a shorthand we all understand because we’ve all seen that film. The film is comforting, and nostalgic. We saw this type of film reflected over and over again ad nauseum, however, Home Alone gets a pass on the cheesiness and forced moments because we can all collectively share the cultural experience of Kevin McCallister.
18. Ace Ventura: Pet Detective (1994 Tom Shadyac)
Jim Carrey has had a nice long run. In the middle of the 1990s through the early 2000s, no one could sweeten a film’s financial draw as much as Carrey, and it seemed that every film was, in some way, trying to replicate Ace Ventura.
There is absolutely nothing notable about this film other than Jim Carrey. I defy anyone to find something about this movie that is funny other than what Jim Carrey brings to the table. But while that might seem like a negative trait, it speaks to the volume of Carrey’s abilities. He is, unquestionably, Ace Ventura, through and throughout.
Assuming that the only significant quality about the film is Carrey, other films such as Dumb and Dumber (1994) and Liar Liar (1997) would not be the staples that they are without Ace. In a way, we needed Ace Ventura. It boosted comedy in the most base-level way possible. While Carrey’s performances can become tiring at times and many viewers might point out that his breadth of acting ability is not nearly as flexible as his face, we all have to admit that it’s almost impossible not to at least chuckle during Ace Ventura. Perhaps that’s what makes it so frustrating…
While other films may have failed to capture the sincerity of Carrey’s performance, Ace came out of nowhere and introduced America to someone we never knew we missed. Though I’m still not sure if unleashing Jim Carrey is a good thing or not (The Riddler!), there is no doubt that Ace Ventura set a new low for comedic films to follow, and sometimes fart jokes can be funny.
17. Ocean’s Eleven (2001 Dir. Steven Soderbergh)
Ocean’s Eleven is just good clean fun. Pure and simple, it’s a large cast of America’s sweethearts who are all having a blast working together, and it is apparent in virtually every frame. Let’s put it this way: when I had my last root canal, they asked if I wanted to watch a film, and I chose Ocean’s Eleven because I hadn’t seen it in a while. I don’t remember a thing about the root canal, but I remember every shot of Ocean’s Eleven.
More than just a star-studded event, the film had an energy which became it’s unique signature. While the sequels tried (sometimes unsuccessfully) to recapture this energy, they were still fun. But the vibe can still be seen today in films like The Losers (2010) and Red (2010).
While not Soderbergh’s strongest work, the film represents what got most people interested in filmmaking in the first place; it was fun. It was fun for the creators, it was fun for the audience, and did well enough in the box office that it was fun for the studios. Movies became a lot more fun because of this film, so whether you liked Ocean’s Eleven or not, its ‘fun’ influence is profound.
16. Punch Drunk Love (2002 Dir. Paul Thomas Anderson)
While many hipsters and film enthusiasts alike will chastise me for including this P.T. Anderson film over the likes of Magnolia (1999), Boogie Nights (19997), or the fan favorite There Will Be Blood (2007), I stand by this film as being not only the most influential, but also the best film of the bunch.
While it’s difficult to be influential when nobody sees the film, the accolades which were lauded upon Punch Drunk prove that it is possible to do so. A departure for Anderson, Punch Drunk centers on relatively few characters, considering the extensive casts in previous Anderson films and is super short by Anderson standards: 95 minutes. Furthermore, Adam Sandler proved to America that he was capable of being entertaining in a film without acting like an idiot, something Jim Carrey has yet to do. Sandler moved with a quiet rage, and wile he was certainly creepy at times, we chalked it up to his character being a social misfit. We were endeared by Sandler, and moved when he flies to Hawaii just to see a woman he has barely met.
The film is a favorite for many filmmakers, including Judd Apatow, who displays his fondness of the film in The 40-Year-Old Virgin (2005) and even Superbad (2007). While Punch Drunk is much darker than it’s successors, the awkward underdog was reinvented for audiences. Napoleon Dynamite took this aspect and ran with it, cashing in on the genius that probably should have been Sandler’s. Irrespectively, Punch Drunk Love holds up as one of the defining moments in awkward comedy classics.
15. The Bourne Identity (2002 Dir. Doug Liman)
The James Bond franchise is starting to look its age. While there was always a certain classiness associated with the films, by today’s action film standards, something seems missing. Enter: Jason Bourne.
The Bourne films injected a shot of adrenaline into the arm of American spy films and gave us our own version of James Bond, this time with a more realistic side. While other action films might have been executed with more style and other thrillers might have been written more cleverly, this film combines elements seen in other films and shows how strong a spy/action film really can be.
Clearly an inspiration to the sequels, The Bourne Identity set the benchmark of how much action is needed to make a film shine with audiences and critics. The follow-ups were equally as strong, and the time shifting narrative between all three films adds a mind bending aspect which most audience members never see coming. The film is great action with great performances; a rare treat for spy thrillers up to this point. While I will watch just about any film featuring Bruce Willis, his acting leaves something to be desired, at times. Damon’s performance as Bourne, however, is grounded and real. While few of us have ever met a rouge American super-agent, I think it’s safe to assume that we picture that agent to be more like Bourne than Ethan Hunt from Mission Impossible (1996).
Bourne seemed to give Spielberg the courage to make a more violent interpretation of Munich (2005), which resulted in a more gritty, bloody version of the real life events. Other spy films such as Traitor (2008), Syriana (2005), and The Good Shepard (2006) drew influence from the Bourne series.
But perhaps most importantly, 007 himself took a cue from Jason Bourne. The Bond franchise rebooted themselves by selecting a new, more vulnerable, and surprisingly blonde James Bond, played by Daniel Craig. Only four years after Bourne was released, Bond was flipped into a one-woman sensitive type who was filled with anger and frustration in 007: Casino Royale (2006). Just like Jason Bourne, The Bourne Identity flies under the radar, but does real damage when inspected.
14. Star Wars: The Phantom Menace (1999 Dir. George Lucas)
This is an example of what not to do. It’s been several years since this debacle, so we seem to have forgotten how angry people are about Jar Jar Binks. Like a bad dream, we’ve tried to move along to newer characters to hate, such as Lindsey Lohan and Oprah, but I think it’s important to note that this film is an exercise in how not to do things.
Fans were initially excited: the rerelease of all three original Star Wars films in the late 1990s gave way to huge rumors that Lucas was coming back! And he would be dusting off his directing hat for the new installments. The buzz began at a dull roar, and never really let up until opening day. But then, like a wall made of lima beans, it all came crashing down… Thanks to one Rasta-inspired Gungan and a bratty little boy named Anakin.
The graphics were less than stellar. Jar Jar annoyed anyone with eardrums. The general tone of the film seemed to be geared towards kids, unlike the grittier dark versions, especially The Empire Strikes Back (1980). The train was clearly coming off the tracks, and all of the audiences… came out in droves? Oddly, the film was a financial success; the franchise was preserved (absolutely nothing could stop that), but this effort sucked the wind out of the sails for the next two films. While it certainly made money, that’s not the reason why it made my list: I firmly believe that we should look at some of the films we made incorrectly so that we might learn from our past mistakes, and we must ensure that we never do them again. For the betterment of all humanity, Jar Jar should never be repeated. Ever.
13. Shaun of the Dead (2004 Dir. Edgar Wright)
While easy to dismiss as a simple parody film, this zombie spoof is more influential than one might think. True, 28 Days Later (2002) probably served more to awaken the zombie sub-genre to mass audiences, but this film brought it out of the strict horror category. While at times truly frightening, the film was funny, and quite clever (who can forget the moment when Shaun leads his team down a wooden fence only to discover a group of doppelgängers headed in the opposite direction?).
But more than that, Shaun of the Dead signaled that it was high time we return to the horror-comedy sub-genre. However, this time, the films needed to actually be funny. America had been hit over the head with countless Wayans brothers parodies, but we had never seen a smart, yet relatable English spin on things.
Clearly Shaun was a strong influence on Zombieland (2009) which is less slapstick-y than Shaun, but similar in tone nonetheless. Films such as Fido (2007) and the upcoming First Platoon (2011) both rely on the foundation set by Shaun.
Shaun’s success also prompted new English comedies to become promoted in America such as Death at a Funeral (2007), along with launching the career of a new comedic favorite, Simon Pegg. Plus, the English make great zombies; their teeth require little in the way of makeup…
12. Goodfellas (1990 Dir. Martin Scorsese)
Scorsese had been snubbed by the Oscars so many times that it became comical. However, most everyone agreed that aside from Raging Bull (1980), Goodfellas was his best film and most deserved to win for best picture. Instead, Dances With Wolves (1990) was honored, and millions of New Yorkers cried.
While not my favorite Scorsese film, this certainly became the milestone of his career which he is remembered for. I thought The Departed (2006) and Casino (1995) were more interesting films, but I have to admit that Goodfellas has a much stronger influence than either of the others.
The Joe Pesci, “I amuse you?” scene alone is worth the price of admission, and gives a flavor of the mafia which makes audiences’ hair stand on end. The drug use and paranoia are classics as well, and set an early stage for films like Boogie Nights (1997) which draws a clear influence. As if the editing and acting weren’t influential enough, Scorsese’s work with timely music is a clear setup for subsequent modern film school filmmakers like Paul Thomas Anderson.
While I’m still not certain that Scorsese deserved the Oscar for this film, I will agree that it was way better than Dances With Wolves.
11. Braveheart (1995 Dir. Mel Gibson)
Say what you will about the man, but Mel Gibson knows how to make a movie. While pleasantly (and ‘peasant-ly’) cheesy at times, this film also rang true in terms of its sincerity. Perhaps it’s the juxtaposition of sappy love story with incredible gore and violence, or perhaps it’s seeing Gibson deliver a passionate speech on horseback to a thousand troops while starting to get a little choked up yourself, or maybe it’s a simple as seeing a man with strong values and refusing to alter them, even in the face of death. Whatever it is, the film’s got moxie, and earned the best picture nod that year.
The battle scenes went on to inspire dozens of films: The Lord of the Rings Trilogy (2001-2003), Gladiator (2000), Troy (2004), and even The Chronicles of Narnia series (2005-present) are clearly inspired by this cinematic effort, along with countless others. Gibson, who employed amputees and actually military soldiers, went to great lengths to make these epic battles both more realistic and more bloody. The result is the go-to film when directors and stuntmen are planning their epic sword-and-sandal-esque battle scenes.
10. Toy Story (1995 Dir. John Lasseter)
Where would we be without Pixar? I really feel as if that single question does more to sum up the past twenty years of filmmaking than any other combination of six words I can come up with. We owe a debt of gratitude to Pixar for sharing some of the most influential and heartwarming stories of our generation. Toy Story was what started it all.
While not necessarily a children’s film, per se, Toy Story is certainly geared towards the younger audiences. However, its appeal to adults is what gives it a place on this list. Pixar captured the heart of kids, but also the minds of adults. The humor is smart and edgy, yet never inappropriate. Pixar has churned out a long string of home runs, but Toy Story trumps most of the others.
Clearly ahead of its time, the writing is stellar, but we quickly forget just how wonderful the animation is, too. In 1995, this film blew audiences away with the smoothness and style that, by today’s standards, pales in comparison. Toy Story made way for the ‘fur scene’ in Monsters Inc. (2001), which dazzled audiences. The history of cinema has provided few instances of films which operate on the multitude of levels as did Toy Story and subsequent Pixar efforts. However, since Toy Story’s release, we virtually see this caliber of family movie released every other weekend.
9. The Blair Witch Project (1999 Dir. Daniel Myrick & Eduardo Sanchez)
A lot can be said about Blair Witch… While that might read as an understatement, there’s really no other way to begin discussing it. It set world records for box office receipts, and deservedly so. It mastered the Internet in a way never before seen, and many would say hasn’t been seen since. It fooled thousands of people into thinking it was real, but came clean about the whole thing and admitted to the fakery. And yet, America seems to have punished them for being too clever.
This film teaches audiences a lesson. However, the audiences I am writing about aren’t the audiences puking in the aisles due to motion sickness. Instead, I mean the audiences to cinema history. This film teaches us about gimmicks (have some, but not too many). This film teaches us about getting ripped off by the studios (read your contracts carefully before you sign). This film teaches us about America’s feelings about being tricked (they’re resentful and will forget your name, quickly). But most importantly, this film teaches us about the importance of integrating a film with online media. Numerous papers have been written about the Internet’s role in Blair Witch’s financial success. However, what we as an audience have failed to note is that none of the actors, writers, or directors have gone on to make another significant film. While many scholars write about the power of the web, few, if any, have addressed the longevity that the web brings. Like a new season of American Idol, audiences have already forgotten who was on last time and are looking at the new shiny penny. Such is the double-edged sword of American taste. We’re fickle, and we’ll bite you just as soon as we can. Like a rabid dog, if we feel even the slightest threat (read: clever twists and a low enough budget that would barely buy a low-end luxury car), we will attack.
Perhaps Blair Witch would have been better off never revealing that it was a forgery. That might involve having to murder three college kids in the middle of the forrest, but hey, you have to suffer for your art. Americans don’t want to know how the magic is done. They’ll cry and whine and bitch and moan that they want to know how everything works, but as soon as they know the secret, all respect is lost for the magician. So, like a well-trained illusionist, a strong filmmaker needs to keep his secrets absolutely quiet. At least for a few years.
For all it’s worth, Blair Witch is a type of film that was great when you saw it, sucks when you see it again a few months later, and then somehow gets better when you see it on television six years down the line. Its influence is magnificent, and it’s an important film. Maybe it’s good, maybe it’s not. Either way, it terrified audiences with the simple creepy ending and the delight in letting them figure out the magician’s trick: the film was faked!
8. Heat (1995 Dir. Michael Mann)
Audiences waited for this moment since 1974. Al Pacino and Robert De Niro had both been in the same movie before, The Godfather II (1974), but they never appeared on-screen with one another. Mann cast two of the greatest actors of modern cinema at the apex of their careers. Like two rams butting their heads against one another, neither character backed down in fear and their on-screen chemistry was great… for all ten minutes.
OK, so out of the 170 minutes, only a few frames actually have both De Niro and Pacino’s face in the same shot, but that doesn’t take away from the power of the overall film, nor the influence it’s had. In particular, the bank robbing sequence set the new tone for action films to follow. Reportedly, director Christopher Nolan based the opening sequences of Dark Knight (2008) on the action from Heat. As if this wasn’t enough credit to the tempo and pacing, only two years after the initial release of Heat, two real-world bank robbers based their escape strategy on the bank robbing scene: firepower. The robbers were obsessed with the film, that sequence in particular, and often cited it as being influential to their nefarious activities.
Ultimately, the film works because of the stellar performances from easily the best talent in Hollywood all working at the peak of their prime. Even Natalie Portman holds her own in the film by playing dead. There is rarely a false note in the huge casts’ performance; Val Kilmer even seems to understand that he helps the picture more by playing second fiddle as opposed to his usual role of first chair violin. Aside from the action sequences, this film is influential in how to direct an exceptionally large cast in an exceptionally complex story. Films such as The Departed (2006) and Black Hawk Down (2001) certainly owe a thanks to Heat for establishing a sophisticated way of dealing with a large number of characters.
7. No Country for Old Men (2007 Dir. Ethan Coen & Joel Coen)
When I saw this film for the first time, I’d never heard of it. For some reason, all mention of it had escaped me, but I frequently take risks at the theaters and see films I’ve never heard about. No Country blew my socks off. Perhaps the most frustrating thing about the film was that no one else seemed to have seen it; I couldn’t discuss the ending with anyone. Clearly the Coen brothers have proved themselves in the American cinema canon, but this film took many by surprise.
What seems most influential to me, however, doesn’t belong solely to the Coens. The author of the novel on which the film is based, Cormac McCarthy, destroys his hero in the final pages. Interestingly enough, the Coens remain true to this aspect of the written word, and, without so much as a cutaway shot, the main character is killed offscreen (spoiler alert). The audience is deprived of at least seeing this act play out, which is drastically unlike other American films.
Additionally, this film gave a kick in the butt to modern western films. While efforts such as 3:10 to Yuma (2007) and The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford (2007) were respectable additions to the genre that same year, No Country added just enough weight to the tipping point to make America feel that Westerns were back, for real.
Moreover, the Coen brothers’ insistence to stay true to the novel is an element becoming more common in a Hollywood so centered on remakes and adaptations. While the original True Grit (1969) featured a happy ending, it’s 2010 counterpart was anything but perky. The Coen brothers, who helmed the 2010 remake, were dead-set on keeping it true to the book. Additionally, when The Road (2009) was filmed, director John Hillcoat stayed right in line with the original work. Apparently Hollywood is starting to learn that audiences who read millions of sad books each year can handle an ending to a film which may not be all sunshine and lollipops.
6. Amelie (2001 Dir. Jean-Pierre Jeunet)
One of the finest foreign films to emerge in the past twenty years, Amelie is a great example of how to tell a clever story in the correct way. While both romantic and depressing, the film never comes across as trite, even though we seem to know what’s going to happen at the end of the story. Like a warm fuzzy blanket, this film is comforting, and holds up well upon repeat viewings.
The influences for this film are huge. While other foreign films may have more notoriety (though I can’t think of any), or may have stronger performances (though I can’t imagine how), this film wow’d American audiences so much that they—gasp—went to see a foreign film. For weeks after the film’s release in American theaters, I could catch snippets of hipster conversations: “Ya know, I didn’t even mind the subtitles all that much! I barely even remembered that I was reading them.” Upon hearing this, I would quietly smile to myself and share a knowing nod with no one.
Amelie pumped new blood into the romantic comedy film. Since it was slightly tragic in tone, it gave a fresh perspective away from the Hitch-type films (2005). For example, Shopgirl (2005) would not have been possible without it’s French predecessor. While I actually prefer Shopgirl to Amelie, I have to give the latter the benefit for paving the way for the former. Even films like About a Boy (2002) and Love Actually (2003) show signs of influence from Amelie. Hugh Grant’s typical happy-go-lucky tone was radically shifted in more recent films, likely thanks to the French effort.
While Jean-Pierre Jeunet was already familiar to some before 2001, this film became the crown jewel in his work. Besides being visually stunning, the film a hallmark romantic film which does more than add to the genre, it defines it.
5. Up (2009 Dir. Pete Docter & Bob Peterson)
I’ll give a dollar to anyone who can honestly claim that they didn’t shed a tear during the sequence near the beginning of the film when Carl’s wife dies. When I first saw the film, I remember explaining to my girlfriend before the movie started that Pixar films were getting better and better, and that Wall-E (2008) was my favorite: Wall-E almost made me cry! Then the opening credits began to roll and we ended our conversation. Twenty minutes later, both she and I were sharing glances at one another as big crocodile tears streamed down our cheeks. Mere minutes after that, we were in hysterics, laughing at the interaction between Carl and Russell. Not long afterwards, we were crying again, and so on it went for the entirety of the film, until we were both reduced to a puddle of emotions. We were emotional puppets at the mercy of Up and would emote any way the film told us.
This film, like others on the list, has not had time to germinate, yet. Its influence is still taking effect, and as such, it is difficult to compare films to it. However, it seems almost certain that future family films will take a more mature role. Pixar has clearly inspired itself, as Toy Story 3 (2010) took a few cues from Up. Soon, I am convinced, we will see more and more films emulating the emotions of Up. Some will make the mistake of trying to copy them, but many filmmakers will realize what worked actually in the film: sincerity. Somehow, the animators conveyed that sincerity in their characters, and audiences could tell the difference.
Up was nothing but pure, absolute, and beautiful art.
4. The Professional (1994 Dir. Luc Besson)
The history of cinema has seen some outstanding years. Some refer to 1939 as ‘the greatest year in cinema.’ Gone With the Wind (1939), The Wizard of Oz (1939), Stagecoach (1939), Of Mice and Men (1939), and Wuthering Heights (1939) were not only all released that year, but have gone on to make cinema highlight reels for most film historians. But when I saw Mr. Smith Goes to Washington (1939), something seemed different to me. It was better than the others, somehow.
By the same token, 1994 was a landmark year for films. The Lion King (1994), Pulp Fiction (1994), Forrest Gump (1994), True Lies (1994), Shawshank Redemption (1994), Speed (1994), and Clerks (1994) seem to be remembered most, and for good reasons. But The Professional (a.k.a. León) dances to the beat of a different drummer. The Professional is smarter, somehow. It takes a wildly unbelievable premise, and makes us believe it.
The film launched the career of Natalie Portman, and became a defining moment in Jean Reno’s repertoire. Moreover, Luc Besson’s writing and direction gave him both street cred and Hollywood buzz. While critics were split on the film and its depiction of violence, this film ranks high on the list because of the performances, the writing, and the high energy pacing.
In terms of influence, the film upped the ante for action films. The aforementioned pacing is what makes this film so special. The speed of the action scenes is immense. At the same time, the film never gets ahead of itself and loses the audience to that speed. This film inspired so many future action films that one, The Boondock Saints (1999) even quotes Jean Reno’s famous line, “No women, no kids.”
3. United 93 (2006 Dir. Paul Greengrass)
When I was in film school, one of my instructors explained to my class that he needed only one thing to tell him about the film he was about to see. When he went inside a theater and heard the ‘big music,’ he would turn right around and walk back out, ask for his money, and go home. While he never quite explained what ‘big music’ was, we all understood what he meant. United 93 has absolutely no ‘big music,” and I’m sure my film professor would have approved.
The tragedy of September 11th is sensitive material to every American. Thus, it’s no surprise that a film released only five years later would touch on some nerves. In fact, Ground Zero was still smoldering as America was waiting with baited breath to attack the first Hollywood film which would adapt the September 11th story into a major cinematic epic. Unfortunately, it was a film which didn’t deserve some of the negative press it got. Fortunately, Greengrass got it right and made an amazing film; he focused on the unique underdog story which was quintessential American: United Flight 93.
Unexpectedly, though, Greengrass took a turn for the realistic and fair portrayal of the story. America expected George Clooney, Matt Damon, and an American flag, yet Greengrass cast the actual people involved when possible (FAA workers, government officials, etc.) and cast unknown actors to portray those on the flight. Furthermore, he did not villainize the terrorists. Instead, he went for the realism of their actions, depicting them not as suicidal maniacs, but rather, human beings with dignity and a purpose.
The tragedy itself was emotional for me. I never got chocked up that September Tuesday because I just stared at the television in shock. When the The 9-11 Commission Report (2004) was released, I finally cried. I cried at a government document.
United 93 made me sob. Greengrass focused on the heroic aspect to the tragedy and did it respectfully, whereas Oliver Stone’s World Trade Center (2006) seemed like the same kind of American film we’d come to expect. While there was no Matt Damon or George Clooney, we did get Nicholas Cage and Maggie Gyllenhaal. And yet, the trailers to United 93 were pulled from theaters because of audience sensitivity and made relatively little money in comparison to World Trade Towers which dominated box offices. World Trade Center was the film which, in my opinion, should have been released first. It should have cleared the path for American hatred, and then, once the healing had started, United 93 would be there to reassure Americans.
The influence United 93 has on other films may not be felt quite yet, but I am convinced that Greengrass’ approach to the subject matter will stand the test of time. America hasn’t been hit with another tragedy the likes of September 11th, and thus can’t put Greengrass’ model of how to depict a true-life sensitive story into effect. While the film has many criticisms from audiences and reviewers alike, it is a different approach to the standard tale we’ve heard a thousand times before. Perhaps the influence that this film has on America is not for future films, but for America itself; we’ve become more transparent and want to see the cold hard truth, even if it hurts.
2. The Passion of the Christ (2004 Dir. Mel Gibson)
Mel Gibson is the only director to make my list twice. While I certainly don’t admire his social skills, his pension for creating interesting and controversial films that also dominate the box office is unparalleled. With that in mind, there’s little doubt that he would be an interesting and controversial person.
Personal characteristics aside, Gibson put his money where his mouth is on this one. Filmed using Aramaic, Latin, and Hebrew, the movie was originally planned to have no subtitles at all. Gibson shopped his ultra-gory depiction of Jesus’ murder all around Hollywood, to no avail, before finally deciding to front the money himself and create a masterpiece of filmmaking.
While many people credit Saw (2004) as being the inspiration to the tourture-porn sub-genre, I would argue that Passion had more of an inspirational influence, though, I doubt Gibson would appreciate the sentiment. While Saw was gory, the violence was occasional, whereas Passion’s violence was unrelenting for the entirety of the film. Indeed, Hostel (2005) seems to draw more elements of torture from Passion than from Saw.
Aside from the violence, Gibson took some huge risks. The financial aspect alone is one of the more risky endeavors, though, to be fair, we all know that Gibson could probably stand the financial hit if things turned south. Still, one has to give Gibson his due in this regard; he hired no A-list celebrities to guarantee the film’s success, and refused to make the same mistake as Bertolucci did in 1987 when he released The Last Emperor (1987), a film about the last emperor of China, entirely in… English? Why? No, Gibson was hellbent on authenticity — or at least, authenticity as Gibson saw it.
Perhaps most influential was the concept that a filmmaker can, indeed, make a film his or her own way, make it incredibly controversial, and still end up successful. In particular, Passion shows us that there is an audience ready to be mobilized. Passion made way for audience targeting, such as Fireproof (2008) starring Kirk Cameron. Fireproof is a film that the general public has probably never heard about, yet, the film made money hand over fist due to the targetization of a specialized audience: Kirk Cameron’s evangelically religious fans. Not only was money raised for the film through Cameron’s fanbase, but they turned out in droves to see it in the theater. Similar acts have been replicated with the Mormon Church such as The Flyboys (2008). But audience targetization is not limited to religious groups. Virtually all of Tyler Perry’s films have been supported similarly by black groups, especially those in the deep American South.
While certainly controversial, The Passion of the Christ warrants its place on this list because it so clearly influenced films to come.
1. Pulp Fiction (1994 Dir. Quentin Tarantino)
Topping the list, this film is arguably one of the most important of all-time. While that might seem like a bit of a stretch, the film made everyone rethink filmmaking for a while. It affected every film after it in the same way the Citizen Kane (1941) did. The non-linear stroyline, the revival of John Travolta, and the snappy dialogue are just the tip of the cultural iceberg that is Pulp Fiction. Almost no high school dance is safe from the Mia Wallace V-shaped-wipe-across-the-eyes move while doing the Twist. The music alone makes this film worth noting.
Pulp Fiction marked, for me at least, the first time I remember seeing a film critic change her mind. In my hometown of Knoxville, Tennessee, critic Betsy Pickle (possibly the most unfortunate name ever bestowed upon a human) originally rated the film at two stars. The rating stood until the hype around the movie began to rise, and she soon changed her review to five stars. Clearly it was ahead of its time.
Aside from the stylized dialogue and acting, the film is an important one. Bruce Willis was a surprise guest left out of the opening credits (which Michael Keaton would later replicate in Jackie Brown), and new names were thrust upon us, which have now become households: Ving Rhames, Uma Thurman, Samuel L. Jackson, and even the man who penned the whole thing: Quentin Tarantino. Sure, all of these names had credits before Pulp Fiction, but none of them had the notoriety like what this film brought. Its influence was unlike anything else.
As noted earlier, 1994 was probably the greatest year in modern history, and Pulp Fiction stands far above all the other ‘94-ers as the most influential. America was changing, and Tarantino quickly became the celluloid Kurt Cobain. He found something deep inside America dying to get out, and just as Nevermind (1991) set us free musically, Pulp Fiction set us free in theaters. Just as with Cobain, we may never be able to express what, exactly, it was about this film that spoke to that generation at that particular time. We may only be able to pick out certain parts, such as “Ezekiel 25:17…” But we know that we’ve been changed. As annoying as Tarantino can be, we, as a culture, should thank him for making this film.
20. The Sixth Sense (1999 Dir. M. Night Shyamalan)
19. Home Alone (1990 Dir. Chris Columbus)
18. Ace Ventura: Pet Detective (1994 Tom Shadyac)
17. Ocean’s Eleven (2001 Dir. Steven Soderbergh)
16. Punch Drunk Love (2002 Dir. Paul Thomas Anderson)
15. The Bourne Identity (2002 Dir. Doug Liman)
14. Star Wars: The Phantom Menace (1999 Dir. George Lucas)
13. Shaun of the Dead (2004 Dir. Edgar Wright)
12. Goodfellas (1990 Dir. Martin Scorsese)
11. Braveheart (1995 Dir. Mel Gibson)
10. Toy Story (1995 Dir. John Lasseter)
9. Blair Witch Project
8. Heat (1995 Dir. Michael Mann)
7. No Country for Old Men (2007 Dir. Ethan Coen & Joel Coen)
6. Amelie (2001 Dir. Jean-Pierre Jeunet)
5. Up (2009 Dir. Pete Docter & Bob Peterson)
4. The Professional (1994 Dir. Luc Besson)
3. United 93 (2006 Dir. Paul Greengrass)
2. The Passion of the Christ (2004 Dir. Mel Gibson)
1. Pulp Fiction (1994 Dir. Quentin Tarantino)