Down to The Wire or The Greatest Story Never Sold: Dissolving the American Dream

Robert Cannon

Professor R. Vianello

COMS 506

16 Mar. 2011


Down to The Wire

or

The Greatest Story Never Sold: Dissolving the American Dream


 In 2002, a new television show emerged which would win a total of zero Emmys and would be largely ignored by the public. However, by the end of the decade The Wire would be listed on dozens of critics’ “Best Television Show Ever” lists, garnering more critical acclaim than arguably any other show. The result was clear: those who saw the show, loved it. The problem was, no one was watching.

 Over the course of five seasons, the HBO cop drama broadcasted a message different from typical police shows, such as Hill Street Blues and Miami Vice some twenty years earlier. But while critics loved the program, and with HBO drawing national attention with The Sopranos, Curb Your Enthusiasm, Oz, and Sex and the City, it may seem odd that such a highly extolled show would go largely ignored by viewers.

 This paper seeks to prove that the television show, The Wire, was ahead of its time for audiences because it was one of the first shows to openly address class stratification and determination through a postmodern lens, which runs counter to the traditional American idealism which was prevalent after the September 11, 2001 attacks (which, in part, included the masking of class stratification through the use of racial discourse). In order to illustrate this concept, it is necessary to first establish some basic background information about the show so that the reader will have a better understanding of the characters and motifs. Then, this paper will use textual analysis to establish three principles: that The Wire directly acknowledges class determination; that The Wire is a ‘quality’ program created with a specific audience in mind; and that The Wire is one of the few (if any) postmodernist television texts to openly address class issues. Having established and examined these three principles, a comparison can be made between the critics’ and audiences’ perception of The Wire.


Background


 Set in then-contemporary Baltimore, the show revolves around a group of police officers who are attempting to disassemble a large, organized drug distribution gang. Unlike other police dramas, this show dedicates just as much screen time to the criminals of the show as the police. Viewers often find themselves rooting for both criminals and officers; both rationales are explained so thoroughly that it is difficult not to empathize with simultaneous and often conflicting perspectives. Moreover, unlike traditional cop dramas, the dichotomy is shattered; there are areas outside the good/bad binary dialectic. Dope fiends—who are regularly portrayed by white actors—depend on black drug dealers. The fiends are seen as a lower class than the predominantly black gangs, shattering the traditional racial discourse America has generally come to accept. Perhaps the show’s biggest hero, Omar, is neither a cop nor a villain; he is also simultaneously and paradoxically both. Indeed, the same can be said of almost every character throughout the series.


A few of the characters:


 Jimmy McNulty - If the show has a main character, it is McNulty. A constant troublemaker, he is more akin to Shakespeare’s Puck than to CSI: Miami’s H. Caine. McNulty starts the ball rolling in the show by informing a judge of a drug kingpin who has gone unnoticed (and unarrested) by police. The judge orders that the kingpin be arrested, and the result is that McNulty is vilified by the Baltimore police department; virtually none of the higher ranking police officers maintain respect for him, as they view his actions as defiant, creating more work for the police while also making them look bad.


 Avon Barksdale - The drug kingpin, Avon is crafty and runs a tight ship. Aided by his right hand-man Stringer Bell, he oversees a multimillion-dollar drug empire.


 Stringer Bell - Where Avon rules with might, Stringer rules with brains. Clearly a money man, Stringer takes business classes at a local college in order to educate himself and apply the business tactics he learns to the drug trade.


 Kima - A lesbian cop who works alongside McNulty, she might be one of his few friends. Maybe.


 Bubbles - A black dope fiend whose white best friend, Johnny Weeks, was badly beaten by the dope gang. Bubbles seeks revenge and thus enlists as a CI (confidential/criminal informant) for the police.


 D’Angelo Barksdale - Avon’s cousin who, freshly released after being acquitted from a murder trial, goes back to working for the gang. He is struggling with the moral dilemma of working for his cousin when he begins to understand the carnage the gang creates.


 Omar - A modern day Robin Hood, Omar is the fan favorite of the show. An openly homosexual vigilante, he is highly respected by those in ‘the game’ of selling drugs. He forms his own gang which profits from stealing drugs and money from Avon’s gang. As the series progresses, his reputation on the streets of Baltimore grows, and he is widely feared by criminals and cops, alike. However, he also establishes a clear code of integrity, thus endearing himself to audiences.


 The similarities between the drug distribution business and the police surveillance business are astonishing. There is internal bureaucratic red tape for both groups; soldiers on either side of the law receive constant ‘dressing downs’ from superiors whenever something doesn’t go quite right, which is almost always.


 This paper will focus on the series as a whole as well as examine one episode in particular: Season 1, Episode 3: “The Buys.”


1. The Theme of Economic Determination


 The Wire goes where few shows have gone before. While passive viewers might misinterpret the show to be about race (most likely because of the large number of black actors), the show is actually addressing class. More specifically, the class discourse is about economic stratification and determination, pure and simple. By this, I mean that the show centers on the theme that those who are poor are destined to stay poor. As Sut Jhally and Justin Lewis point out, “We are used to seeing class issues treated in other ways [than the frank unequal and unfair depiction of class barriers] on prime-time television. When class barriers are presented, it is invariably to show them being overcome, not reinforced (Jhally and Lewis 1992).” While the police storylines tend to focus on governmental bureaucracy (though, they, too, are portrayed as economically stratified), those who live in the projects are concerned with their class status and the ‘glass ceiling’ which prevents them from upward mobility. But there is a class hierarchy within the projects; the ghetto understandings of class break into smaller bits. Clearly Avon is on top; he has all the power and money. Stringer Bell and a few close aids to Avon are just below, while the ‘soldiers’ round out the upper-class (to be clear, all of this is a microcosm of class, all taking place within the lower-class of the Baltimore ghetto). Those who live in the housing projects but do not sell drugs are middle-class, while the lowest of the low are the addicts, and upward mobility is not tolerated. The episode “The Buys” provides a typical look into this issue. In the opening scene, a dope fiend bothers some of the drug soldiers if they have any free dope, but gang members Bodie and Wallace yell at him to leave. D’Angelo, a higher ranking officer than Bodie and Wallace, reprimands them for yelling at the addict:


 D’Angelo: Yo, why you act like that?

 Bodie: What, for these junkie motherfuckers?

 D: So, you’re just gonna take his money all day and treat him like a   dog?

 B: How I supposed to treat him?

 D: I don’t know, but you ain’t gotta punk him like that.

 B: What, the customer’s always right?

 Wallace: We’re in the projects. The customer be fucked up. You can’t   give these niggas shit.

 D: Why not? Why can’t you? Shit, everything else in the world get   sold without people taking advantage. Scamming, lying, doing   each other dirty. Why it gotta be that way with this?

 B: ‘Cause they dope fiends.


 Clearly, there is a large disregard for the dope fiends, who are stratified beneath the gang members. A similar conversation could have been created between police officers depicting the difference between the cops and the criminals, but the message might have been clouded; viewers might mistake the maltreatment of a black criminal as being a racial discrimination, or they might confuse maltreatment of a white criminal as a critique about the abuses of police power. However, the alternative ideology within this text is evident: the gang members are often the victims of racial discrimination, if anything, not the purveyors of it. Instead, they employ class discrimination. Within the gang culture, there is a tremendous amount of value placed on class (it is often colloquially referred to as the ‘bling culture’). But the fiends are economically downtrodden, thus they are seen as worthless by those who, in turn, are seen as worthless to the larger sphere of middle- and upper-class Americans.

 Later in the same episode, D’Angelo tries to teach Bodie and Wallace how to play chess. In so doing, he reveals the show’s thinly veiled message about class determination:


 D’Angelo: See this? [Kisses the king chess piece] This is the   kingpin. And he the man. You get the other dude’s king, you got   the game. But he try to get your king, too. So you got to   protect it. Now, the king, he move one space any direction he   damn chooses, ‘cause he’s the king. Like this, all right? But   he ain’t got no hustle. But the rest of these motherfuckers on   the team, they got his back. And they run so deep, he really   ain’t gotta do shit.

 Bodie: That like your uncle [Avon].

 D: Yeah, like my uncle. Now, you see this? This the queen. She   smart and she fierce. She move any way she want and as far she   want. And she is the go-get-shit-done piece.

 Wallace: Remind me of Stringer [Bell].

 D: And this over here is the castle. It’s like the stash. It moves   like this.

 W: Dog, stash don’t move, man.

 D: How many times we move the stash house this week? And every time   we move the stash, we gotta move a little muscle with it, right?   To protect it.

 B: True, true. You right. All right, what about them little

  bald-headed bitches right there?

 D: These are the pawns. They like the soldiers. They move like this,   one space forward only, except when they fight. Then it’s like   this. They like the front lines. They be out in the field.

 W: So, how do you get to be the king?

 D: It ain’t like that. See, the king stay the king. Everything stays   who he is… Except for the pawns. If the pawn makes it all the   way down to the other dude’s side he gets to be queen. And like   I said, the queen ain’t no bitch. She got all the moves.

 B: All right, so, if I make it to the other end, I win?

 D: If you catch the other dude’s king and trap it, then you win.

 B: All right, but if I make it to the end, I’m top dog…

 D: Nah, yo, it ain’t like that. Look, the pawns, man, in the game,   they get capped quick. They be out the game early.

 B: Unless they some smart-ass pawns.

 

 D’Angelo clearly illustrates to Wallace and Bodie that they are merely pawns within the stratified game of drug dealing, and they will remain as such. If, as Bodie puts it, they are some smart-ass pawns, they might have the opportunity to transform themselves into a queen, but they can never become king, no matter how hard they try or how smart they are. This metaphor falls in line with the ideology of the show: class position is fixed.

 Earlier in the series, the same trio are sitting on a couch enjoying some Chicken McNuggets from McDonald’s; D’Angelo explains to Wallace and Bodie that the inventor of the McNugget most assuredly did not get paid any more money for creating the product. Instead, he just made “the real payers” that much more rich. He notes that it isn’t what’s ‘right,’ but that it’s about money.

 D’Angelo: You think Ronald McDonald is gonna go down in that basement   and go, ‘Hey, Mr. Nugget. You the bomb! We sellin’ chicken   faster than you can tear the bone out, so I’m gonna write my   clowny-ass name on this fat-ass check for you!’ The nigger who   invented them things is still workin’ in the basement for regular   wage trying to think of some shit to make the fries taste better,   or some shit like that. Believe.


 Dialogue such as this clearly illustrates the creators’ intent to address class stratification and determination. Moreover, throughout the series, there are many attempts by both Avon and Stringer Bell to move into a legitimate upper-class business—real estate in particular. Stringer Bell is intent on leaving his lower-class status behind, but the political and bureaucratic inroads make it impossible for him; he may dress, talk, move, and act like an upper-class citizen, but the system is clear: he is not one of them. Eventually, it is his lower-class roots which prevent him from ever achieving the upper-class status.

 Through and throughout, the message of the series is clear: economic determination is an aspect of truth. The show’s ideology also seems say to the viewer: that’s what makes this show so special, we talk about the ‘real’ issues. Which then brings up the issue of audience: what type of audience was the show targeting?


2. The Type of Programming and Audience


 The Wire is, without a doubt, quality programming. As Robert J. Thomspson discusses in his essay “From ‘The Golden Age of Television’ to ‘Quality TV,’” quality television programming meets a set of tenets (Thompson 1996). Thompson lays out twelve guidelines for the definition of quality TV programming, and The Wire embodies all of them except the last: “[Quality television series] are usually enthusiastically showered with awards and critical acclaim.” As this paper will address later, the number of awards which this show received is practically non-existent, though to be fair, the critical praise was like none other. The single camera shooting and stylized dialogue make for an easy pick in the quality arena. The production value is high as well as the caliber of acting; indeed, many high-end films do not have this level of acting.

 The show’s ensemble cast is a clear example of Herman Gray’s discursive practice: multiculturalism (Gray 1995). The show dealt with issues of race (though, the primary issue is always class stratification) but it never did so through a “gaze of an idealized white middle-class audience.” In fact, in contrast to most cop dramas, the majority of the characters on the show are black. However the variety of ethnic backgrounds and cultural differences between characters make this a multiculturalist aspect which lends itself to the concept that the show is one of high quality; it has transcended race to now discuss a more important issue: class.

 But of particular importance, here, is the concept of the audience. The creators of the show (David Simon in particular) thought about the audience every step of the way. The show aired from 2002-2008 on the HBO network, which is a premium cable channel. The daypart of the show, which changed often—one of the attributed causes to the show’s demise—was what we might expect: weekday evenings during late primetime hours. In particular, The Wire aired on Friday nights, a time when few shows that target a young audience are likely to make a splash. But the network itself is aggressive. HBO made a name for itself in the late ‘90s/early ‘00s by entering into the foray of high quality programming with an edge. The aforementioned shows The Sopranos and Oz were wildly popular because of the intense violence and graphic depictions of controversial subject matter. Perhaps none of the shows on HBO had more of an edge than The Wire.

 This, Simon notes, was not an accident. In an interview at the Edinburgh International TV Festival reported by BBC, Simon felt that advertising was killing television. "Television as a medium, in terms of being literate and telling stories, has short-changed itself since its inception. […] That is because of advertising. (BBC 2009)" He went on to add that, “HBO came to the conclusion ratings no longer mattered. […] If everybody has to watch a show then it can't really say anything.” Simon aimed to air his show on a premium cable channel such as HBO so that he would not have to worry about adapting his message for potential advertisers. Clearly, this show is anything but lowest common denominator, least objectionable programming.

 But if it is clear who the audience isn’t, it is still muddled as to who the audience is. The majority of HBO subscribers are upper-middle-class with enough money to spend on premium cable. Generally speaking, they are relatively older than the apparent target demographic of the show, but make no mistake about it, HBO is interested in subscribers who have money, regardless of their age. With that said, the target audience is not the same low income group depicted in the show, itself.

 On the surface level, the show seems paradoxical. While the characters are black, the show skews white. While the politics and actions depicted may seem conservative, the show skews liberal. While the characters are often uneducated, the show skews to the audiences with an educational background. And while the issues most central to the series are ones of class stratification, the show skews upper-class. Perhaps this is ironic. Perhaps this is intentional, so as to inspire a political discussion about the subject matter. Or, perhaps this is the only route the creators of the show could take without compromising their political message. Either way, the show is unlike any other before it because it dives straight at the topic of class without losing focus on separate issues along the way. While race and power are intertwined with the issue of class, The Wire understands and focuses its message very clearly.

 This show works to tell a cohesive story. Almost like a miniseries, the show has a point, never losing track of it along the way. TV critic Laura Miller claims that The Wire is more like a novel than any other television show out there (Traister and Miller 2007). “The series is complex, with a lot of characters, and it's never going to hold your hand through the intricate curlicues of each season's story line. You have to pay attention, even when you're not sure what's going on.”

 While the theme of the show is evident, and the intended audiences are clear, the show’s status as a revolutionary program deserves attention.


3. The Wire As a Postmodern Text Like None Other


 Before assigning The Wire as a postmodern text, it is important to fully understand the meaning of ‘postmodernism,’ itself. It is a term that is defined by what it isn’t; it is the rejection of various frameworks of reality, and seemingly contradictory, an acceptance of them. Dick Hebdige claims that postmodernism emerges out of the historical “frustrated rhetoric” which was dominant in the late 1960s (Hebdige 1986). Moreover, he points out that postmodernism consists of three general rules: 1. it runs counter to totalisation, 2. it runs counter to teleology (determinate causes), and 3. it runs counter to utopia.

 Similarly, Robert Vianello explains a more historiographic approach to the term, interpreting postmodern to mean a period of time and thought after the ‘modern’ age (commonly thought to have begun in the ninetieth century). Paraphrasing Vianello, the modern age is based in scientific perspective of truth, and thus, a postmodern age would reject any and every perspective of truth; there is no truth, which, paradoxically, could mean an infinite number of truths. The modern era, historically speaking, came about after the ‘medieval’ period, which followed from the ‘ancient’ period (Vianello 2011).

 Indeed, the term can come to mean just about anything, but perhaps this is, itself, postmodern. No doubt, The Wire reflects this. The show does not reflect a totalisation ideology; instead its message is mixed; it is without a specific stance regarding the essence of human nature. Similarly, it does not seek to explain the ‘why’ of why things are the way they are, but instead, seems to pile on more questions. Finally, the show makes no hope of reaching a utopia. At the end of virtually every episode, every season, and even the series, we are left to believe that things have not gotten any better because of the effort of the police. As one drug dealer is dealt with, a new one takes his place. A new steet-wise murderer swapped for a dead one. A new hard-nosed cop put in the place of a transferred one. This is not the work of the show creators having to deal with unruly acting talent; the characters are killed for a message. The show demonstrates that class position is determinate.

 Interestingly, there is a feeling to the show which many interpret as ‘depressing’ because there is no light at the end of the tunnel; there is only the tunnel. In the very first episode, a snippet of dialogue between two cops reveals the show’s philosophy:

 Herc: “You can’t even call this shit a war [the war on crime].”

 Ellis: “Why not?”

 H: “Wars end.”


 But the show is not depressing, at least, not in my textual analysis. Instead, it is refreshing—a breath of fresh air in its stance about a classist America. Moreover, this stance is shown through a postmodern lens, both by Vianello’s and Hebdige’s defintions, adding a new layer of alternative ideology to the airwaves rarely seen previously. This show would never have appeared on any of the ‘big three’ stations, because the message would have been compromised by both the network executives (in an effort to make the show more family friendly) and the advertisements (which would have likely scoffed at the class determination discourse, quickly pushing the show into obscurity, if not outright cancelation).

 The show has no God. There is no center of the series. There is no higher calling or determined moral code. The cops are often just as crooked as the criminals—in some cases more so—and the criminals are surprisingly adherent to their code. More than just inverting the dialectic, The Wire depicts complex characters and plots that Americans have never seen. Few, if any, characters are completely despicable, while none are without their significant faults as they seek to control power over their lives. The entire first season is predicated upon the fact that only one cop (McNulty) cares about putting away the bad guys, while the rest of the police force seems more concerned with getting a paycheck. Even McNulty is motivated to satiate his desire for revenge, not for any true sense of carrying out justice. His character is ostracized by other cops because he’s not ‘supposed’ to care; he’s not supposed to become effective; it’s not his job.

 Lasting a total of five seasons, The Wire dedicated each season to a pressing issue. In the first season, The Wire focused on the drug trade, while the second season centered around the shipping industry and the unions therein. The third dealt with education, the fourth with politics, and the fifth season discussed the newspaper media industry. The central cast of characters are seamlessly interwoven throughout; however, one of the show’s drawbacks is the extensive cast.

 The sheer number of actors who appear in the series over the course of five seasons is staggering. As a result, viewers can easily become confused, especially if they are not regular watchers. Many Internet sites are devoted to ‘family trees’ which display the complex web of relations within the gangs or police department structure. While a few characters make their way through the entire series, many more are cast aside in an effort to ‘clean the clutter’ of characters. The creators of the show understood from the beginning that adding a multitude of characters would complicate things, and keeping with the show’s postmodern ideology, many fan favorites are killed off, much to the chagrin of audiences and critics. The show is never shy with death, dealing out executions of characters at almost every turn in the road. Perhaps this is one of the bittersweet aspects of the show which made it as critically celebrated as it is.


Critics vs. Audiences vs. Academia


 The Wire flew under the radar for America. While the majority of Americans never saw it because they did not subscribe to HBO, even those with subscriptions sought something else. Perhaps they never saw a single episode. Perhaps they tried to pick up in the middle of a season, which could easily have been overwhelming and confusing. Or, as I believe, perhaps this show’s ideology countered the American ideology which dominated the media at the time.

 Critics praised The Wire almost from its beginning. Currently, it holds a coveted top seat atop the Metacritic all-time highest rated television series, earning a score of 98/100 with critics (Metacritic 2011). Journalist Joe Klein, who regularly writes for Time, The New York Times, The Washington Post, Rolling Stone, and The New Yorker summed up the show up by stating, "The Wire hasn't won an Emmy? The Wire should get the Nobel Prize for Literature! (Evans 2009)”

 Additionally, current UK syndication has lead to an explosion of British television critics to laude praise upon the show; both London newspapers, The Telegraph (April 2009) and The Guardian (Wilde 2007) have hailed it as “the greatest television programme ever made.”

 Even the few non-critic audiences who saw the show seemed to agree. User reviews from the aforementioned Metacritic hail similar sentiments, such as this one from user Sumsar:

 Without a doubt the best TV show made, pretty big statement but once you've seen it you'll agree, to really enjoy the wire you have to watch every episode of every season, it's not a show like csi where you just sit down and watch a random episode here and there… The Wire is famous for its great characters and excellent dialogue, there are so many memorable quotes from the film that its hard to pick your favourite. MUST SEE


 Or this one from user Podaddy:

The greatest achievement in television history. In five years, I never heard one single exchange of dialogue in this show that wasn't wholly believable. I have had my fill of cop, doctor and lawyer shows over the years,but The Wire is so much more than that. It navigates complex story lines between the drug dealers, the school system, the entrie heirarchy [sic] of the police force, the politicians, addicts, media and what have you with tremendous ease. Best show ever.


 Such reviews are not cherry-picked; dozens of websites devoted to television reviews share a similar sentiment. This begs the question: if audiences and critics agree that she show was masterfully created, why wasn’t the show a financial success to the same level as The Sopranos or Oz? Perhaps HBO was not confident in the alternative ideology inherent in the show and did not provide the advertising push that would propel The Wire into the public limelight. While this factor certainly played a part to some extent, I find it more likely that the attitude in the post-September 11th America to be intolerant of any ideology which would run counter to the mainstream. This media sentiment—of American Dreamism—continued for several years; one might easily argue that it is still present in television, today. While American Dreamism is nothing new, the patriotic positivism of the country at the time was easily illustrated in the new television shows of 2002.

 America was still reeling from the blow delivered a year earlier. The new fall lineup of shows reflected this: cop shows such as CSI: Miami began airing the same old cop drama which reinforced American Dreamism. At the same time, several non-cop drama shows hit the airwaves which also reinforced the traditional ideology; The Bachelor, Dr. Phil, American Dreams and American Idol all premiered in 2002. It was a year filled with new programming focused on the return to American core values.

 Americans were not ready to address class issues. New shows brought out in 2002 and those already on the air opted for a ‘middle-class morality’ ideology, which was nowhere to be found in The Wire. Instead, the series seemed to deconstruct the prominent American ideology. This is evident in David Simon’s earlier cited BBC interview, as he clearly makes a ideological statement with the show: American classism is the root problem for the country and it has been largely ignored in television media. Simon and the other show creators have clearly created the show for the embodied spectator. Where many shows would sacrifice the issue of class determinism for the trite topic of race, The Wire doesn’t take the bait. As critic Thomas Burchfield of Red Room notes (Burchfield 2009):

 It’s not all about Race. In fact, it’s more about Class as in the gulfs and struggles between the rich and the poor and those with power and those without (in one episode, a knee-jerk liberal naively accuses a rural white male of being a racist cracker … only to have the accused’s African-American wife walk into the picture.) The Wire is unapologetically anti-unregulated Capitalism.


 If viewers even begin to think that this show is business as usual, the creators continually send messages that it is anything but. Perhaps it is no surprise that audiences stayed away.


 John Fiske writes about popular culture by stating, “For a cultural commodity to be popular, then, it must be able to meet the various interests of the people amongst whom it is popular as well as the interests of its producers (Fiske 1987).” The Wire doesn’t. Fiske points out, “The gap between the cultural and financial economies is wide enough to grant the cultural economy considerable autonomy, but not too wide to be bridgeable. The producers and distributors of a program can exert some, if limited, influence over who watches and some, though limited, influence over the meanings and pleasures that the audiences may produce from it.” Thus, The Wire must adhere to two economies, those of culture and finance. The show’s creators have gravitated to the cultural economy at the sacrifice of the financial one; the show was politically controversial because it was ahead of its time, delving into areas where few shows dared to go, but this resulted in a poorly received show, financially speaking.

 But the ideology is worth it. As Stuart Hall points out, “An ideology empowers people, enabling them to begin to make some sense of intelligibility of their historical situation (Hall 1986).” It is my opinion that we owe a debt of gratitude to the creators of The Wire for bringing an issue to light which is seldom discussed in such an overt way, because Americans have become more aware of this new ideology. To rephrase Arthur Schopenhauer, new ideas are ignored and opposed before becoming widely accepted. The Wire has laid the tracks for the locomotive of class discussion within American television.

 As Michel Foucault states, “Power comes from below; that is, there is no binary and all-encompassing opposition between rulers and ruled at the root of power relations (Foucault 1981).” With Foucault’s paradigm, The Wire awakes in viewers a discourse which enables them to act against class stratification in a similar way that race and gender have been dealt with in America. Viewers are enabled to address class stratification and determinism like never before, because, for many of them, they have never been aware of the issue before. Even if, conversely, they have been aware of it, they certainly have not seen it in a context such as The Wire. The syndication of the show in the UK demonstrates this, as they have a different ideology in their mainstream television, and it is one significantly separate from the post-9/11 ideology America saw in 2002.

 But Americans can change their ideologies. As we have seen, historically, changes in practices and in social acceptance have been made because of inroads to the national ideological discourse. Television has played a significant role in such changes. Years from now we will look back to The Wire to see that it was a show which addressed an issue which was largely silent beforehand.

 This effect may already have started. According to The Wire’s Wikipedia page, several prestigious American universities have already centered classes around the text (Wikipedia 2011). Harvard, Johns Hopkins, Duke, UC Berkeley, and even the boarding high school Phillips Andover Academy have all designed classes surrounding The Wire. While it is possible that such classes might misconstrue the meaning of the text, this seems unlikely given that the show is widely regarded as an advocate for class struggles.

 Moreover, it is the goal of this paper to add to the collective discourse surrounding class stratification and determination. The Wire uses television as a medium to convey a political agenda, but the message is not one which has been widely discussed in previous efforts. Thus, the show is a success; while financially it may have ben largely disregarded and culturally unacknowledged, it may be through academia that the show receives a second life. Because the show is so strongly linked to technologically advanced distribution efforts, it is relatively easy to watch old episodes. Thus, audiences can easily return to study the series in a way unlike shows from twenty years ago. By watching and studying these episodes, we can change the cultural dialectic regarding class struggles and begin to make that change. If academia is to lead the way in this discourse, there will need to be many drops in the bucket. This paper serves as just such a drop in the bucket of discourse about class determination and stratification.

 The Wire has already set the stage for the change in the way Americans view class, because it represents a shift in the discussion of power. Since power comes from below, the discourse surrounding economic stratification will pick up momentum and, ideally, be addressed in a similar way to the women’s suffrage movement of the 1920s and the civil rights movement of the 1960s. In so doing, the power is no longer dictated to a silent consent; only through the discourse about class can the power relational system can be changed.


Conclusion


 2008 was a sad year; The Wire came to a close. DVD sales since then have strengthened the reputation of the series, and it has started to find a new home through syndication, VOD, and online distribution.

 Make no mistake, the series is not easy to watch. At times it tells us what we may not want to hear, but like a patient who has been diagnosed with cancer, we are better off hearing it. America has skirted the issue of class stratification for decades, and while The Wire alone may not change the structure of the discourse, it certainly lays the framework that it is possible to have programming which tackles such issues, something largely thought impossible before 2002. But the real message of the show, whether the creators knew it or not, was that the issue of class determination will not simply go away; the cancer will not reverse itself, and we will only become more sick as time goes by if we do not address the situation. To ignore class determination, as Harry G.Frankfurt might say, is bullshit.


Works Cited

"American Dreams (TV Series 2002–2005) - IMDb." The Internet Movie Database (IMDb). Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0319930/>.


"American Idol (TV Series 2002– ) - IMDb." The Internet Movie Database (IMDb). Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0319931/>.


"The Bachelor (TV Series 2002– ) - IMDb." The Internet Movie Database (IMDb). Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0313038/>.


"BBC NEWS | UK | Scotland | Wire Writer Says Adverts Kill TV." BBC News - Home. BBC News, 29 Aug. 2009. Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/scotland/8227864.stm>.


Burchfield, Thomas. "15 Reasons You Should Watch The Wire (All True and Unarguable!) | Red Room." Red Room | Where the Writers Are. 23 June 2009. Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://www.redroom.com/blog/thomas-burchfield/15-reasons-you-should-watch-the-wire-all-true-and-unarguable>.


"CSI: Miami (TV Series 2002– ) - IMDb." The Internet Movie Database (IMDb). Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0313043/>.


"Curb Your Enthusiasm (TV Series 2000– ) - IMDb." The Internet Movie Database (IMDb). Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0264235/>.


"Dr. Phil (TV Series 2003– ) - IMDb." The Internet Movie Database (IMDb). Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0329824/>.


Evans, Erin E. "Googling ‘The Wire’." Home | The Root. 9 Mar. 2009. Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://www.theroot.com/views/googling-wire>.


Fiske, John. "The Popular Economy." 1987. Cultural Theory and Popular Culture: a Reader. Harlow, England: Pearson Longman, 2009. 564-80. Print.


Foucault, Michel. Method. 1981. Cultural Theory and Popular Culture: a Reader. Harlow, England: Pearson Longman, 2009. 313-19. Print.


Frankfurt, Harry G. On Bullshit. Princeton, NJ: Princeton UP, 2005. Print.


Gray, Herman. "The Politics of Representation in Network Television." Watching Race: Television and the Struggle for &#x27;Blackness&#x27; Minneapolis: University of Minnesota, 1995. 70-92. Print. Media and Cultural Studies: Keyworks. Blackwell. 439-61.


Hall, Stuart. "On Postmodernism and Articulation: An Interview With Stuart Hall." Ed. L. Grossberg. Journal of Communication Inquiry 10.2 (1986): 45-60. Print.


Hebdige, Dick. "Postmodernism and &#x27;The Other Side&#x27;" 1986. Cultural Theory and Popular Culture: a Reader. Harlow, England: Pearson Longman, 2009. 429-43. Print.


"Highest and Lowest Scoring TV Shows at Metacritic." Metacritic - Movie Reviews, TV Reviews, Game Reviews, and Music Reviews. Metacritic. Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://www.metacritic.com/browse/tv/score/metascore/all?sort=desc&view=condensed>.


"Hill Street Blues (TV Series 1981–1987) - IMDb." The Internet Movie Database (IMDb). Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0081873/>.


Jhally, Sut, and Justin Lewis. "The Myth of the American Dream." Enlightened Racism: the Cosby Show, Audiences, and the Myth of the American Dream. Boulder: Westview, 1992. 75. Print.


"Miami Vice (TV Series 1984–1990) - IMDb." The Internet Movie Database (IMDb). Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0086759/>.


"Oz (TV Series 1997–2003) - IMDb." The Internet Movie Database (IMDb). Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0118421/>.


Podaddy and Sumsar. "The Wire - Season 1 Reviews, Ratings, Credits, and More at Metacritic." Metacritic - Movie Reviews, TV Reviews, Game Reviews, and Music Reviews. Metacritic. Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://www.metacritic.com/tv/the-wire/season-1>.


"Sex and the City (TV Series 1998–2004) - IMDb." The Internet Movie Database (IMDb). Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0159206/>.


"The Sopranos (TV Series 1999–2007) - IMDb." The Internet Movie Database (IMDb). Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0141842/>.


Thompson, Robert J. "From ‘The Golden Age of Television’ to ‘Quality TV’" Preface. Television&#x27;s Second Golden Age: from Hill Street Blues to ER ; Hill Street Blues, Thirtysomething, St. Elsewhere, China Beach, Cagney & Lacey, Twin Peaks, Moonlighting, Northern Exposure, L.A. Law, Picket Fences, with Brief Reflections on Homicide, NYPD Blue & Chicago Hope, and Other Quality Dramas. Syracuse, N.Y: Syracuse UP, 1996. 11-17. Print.


Traister, Rebecca, and Laura Miller. "The Best TV Show of All Time - Laura Miller - Salon.com." Salon.com - Salon.com. 15 Sept. 2007. Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://www.salon.com/entertainment/tv/feature/2007/09/15/best_show>.


Vianello, Robert. "Television Programming." Class 1. California State University: Los Angeles, Los Angeles. 5 Jan. 2011. Lecture.


Wilde, Jon. "The Wire Is Unmissable Television | Television & Radio | Guardian.co.uk." Latest News, Comment and Reviews from the Guardian | Guardian.co.uk. The Guardian, 21 July 2007. Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://www.guardian.co.uk/culture/tvandradioblog/2007/jul/21/thewireisunmissabletelevis>.


"The Wire: Arguably the Greatest Television Programme Ever Made - Telegraph." Telegraph.co.uk - Telegraph Online, Daily Telegraph and Sunday Telegraph - Telegraph. The Telegraph, 2 Apr. 2009. Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/5095500/The-Wire-arguably-the-greatest-television-programme-ever-made.html>.


"The Wire (TV Series 2002–2008) - IMDb." The Internet Movie Database (IMDb). Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0306414/>.


"The Wire." Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia. Web. 06 Mar. 2011. <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Wire>.

Previous
Previous

20 Films of Influence in as Many Years or The Top Twenty Transformational Talkies in Twenty Twelvemonth

Next
Next

Five Years or The Whimper We Will Go With