“Alienation Emotions from the Pop Culture Mainstream”
by
Robert Cannon
TVF 460 Summer 2010
In the 1970s, the punk subculture burst into the rock musical genre. While the origins are still being debated today, bands such as Velvet Underground, Iggy and the Stooges, The Ramones, and The Sex Pistols established a style of music which put an emphasis on the performances of the band over the content of the music. Stripped down to essential three-chord progressions and simplistic vocals, the music was primal, yet catchy. However, the antics of the performers—in clothing, hair style, behavior, and rampant drug use—all created an edge to punk, which alienated the genre from the mainstream. Not since Elvis’s performance in 1956 on the Ed Sullivan Show were people this outraged over music. The punks couldn’t be happier with the separation from the masses.
However, during the 1980s, the punk genre was beginning to be viewed in a negative light. This time, it wasn’t getting a bad rap from parents or authority figures, but by those within the genre, itself. Emerging bands tried to cash in on the new style and were viewed as “posers,” thus defining a line between punk and hardcore punk. These hardcore bands cranked up the punk style and performed with a sense of rage, which became scary to the audiences. Bands such as Black Flag, Bad Religion, and Hüsker Dü performed with such energy that mosh pit style violence was common at many of their shows. Over time, the hardcore movement became compromised as well; music labels signed the best hardcore bands and the performance rage had become commercial. By the late 1980s, most punks felt that the movement was over.
However, some clung on to hope that the genre would be revived. The problem became that the punk genre was becoming appropriated and used by mainstream audiences. Punk found itself in a quandary: to continue with the punk movement meant to abide by the mainstream, and that was quintessentially non-punk. It seemed that the only punk thing to do was to become non-punk. However, one man saw the future of the subculture through a different light. In the late 1980s, singer Kevin Michael Allin, better known to his fans as G.G. Allin, created shockwaves in the punk genre.
Allin had been a musician on the sidelines of the punk scene since the late ‘70s, never gaining much attention. However, during the late ‘80s, Allin discovered an element to his performances which would make headlines and would challenge how “punk” the punk movement could be.
Because Allin’s performances were so universally crude and vile, they are worthy of study when considering the following research question: How does the pop culture react to non-conformist efforts? In order to answer this question, we will turn to the use of Max Horkheimer and Theodor Adorno’s essay “The Culture Industry: Enlightenment as Mass Deception (Horkheimer and Adorno).” Horkheimer and Adorno’s essay is a perfect lens for our analysis, because they directly discuss how the masses interact with media messages, especially when they have become complacent, just as G.G. Allin asserts that the punk subculture has done. Through this essay, we will come to discover if G.G. Allin’s motives were successful or not by first examining Horkheimer and Adorno’s essay, then applying it to the performances of G.G. Allin, before finally drawing some implications about the merit of Allin’s antics.
Theodor Adorno and Max Horkheimer were a students of the Frankfurt School, a method of theorizing based on a derivative of Marxist ideals. Already we can see that their essay expresses the concerns of Eastern European thoughts and attitudes prominent in the pre-World War II era. It was a similar line of thinking which led to the Bolshevik Revolution in October of 1917, and inspired films such as Battleship Potemkin (1925), with which, no doubt, they would have been familiar. This becomes important when trying to understand the theories being expressed in their essay.
Essentially, Horkheimer and Adorno state that the preponderance of popular culture has given way to a culture industry. This culture industry is designed and directed by an upper echelon group of people who are inclined to design the pop culture in a way which best suits them financially.
Adorno, having traveled out of Eastern Europe and into the United States in the late 1930s, would have been in for a culture shock, to say the least. From both his and Max Horkheimer’s perspective, it would have seemed as though only a few companies controlled the complete financial system of the United States. They may not have been far off, on that account. But both Horkheimer and Adorno, outright Marxists, would have seen this as furthering a divide between the upper and lower classes.
Horkheimer and Adorno view mass society, especially that in the Western world, as being directed by the desire for objects over the desire for subjects. Increasingly, they see humans focus on materialistic desires. Thus, they begin to formulate their theory of the culture industry.
This theory states that the ideas of what society wants are fabricated by those in charge of the society. Those in charge—that is, those with the money—claim that they are fulfilling the supply to a heavy demand of pop culture, however, these same people are the ones creating the demand, as well. Furthermore, the items which are being created—through images on television, movies, billboards, and the sounds of radio—all combine to make the audience feel as if they are unique. Horkheimer and Adorno assert, however, that these same sounds and images are the same ones which have been broadcasted to audiences over and over, recycling storylines and plot devices in no original manner. Thus, according to the theory, we are becoming “brainwashed” in our perception of media. In fact, our entire culture is being engineered.
According to their theory, the cycle is unbreakable; when auteurs attempt to buck the system by creating a seemingly new plot device, this only serves to solidify the true pop culture being pushed upon the masses by the upper echelon. The situation of pop culture, as Horkheimer and Adorno would have it, is on a definite downward spiral.
According to G.G. Allin, in much the same way that Elvis had been a leader of rock music in the 1950s, so too should punk have a leader. Allin idolized Elvis on many levels, but most of all, he respected that Elvis was a symbol for danger. Elvis was not filmed above the waist on the Ed Sullivan Show, and quickly thereafter, parents and communities viewed Elvis’s music as destructive.
Punk, as Allin viewed it, was in need for the same injection of danger. The genre of music and fashion had become too watered down by pop culture, and a new leader was needed to become a punk inspiration. But the more Allin looked for that leader, the more he realized that he was that inspiration. By the early 1990s, this was put into an all-out effect. In a 1993 interview on The Jane Whitney Show (episode dated July 16, 1993), Allin claimed, “Nobody will stop me because I am the true underground messiah. When you come to my show, you’re goin’ to a war, and I’m out for violence, chaos, lawlessness all the way.”
Allin’s shows were filled with revolting acts. In almost every performance, Allin would defecate on stage, often smearing the fecal matter on his body and throwing it at the audience. In the documentary film G.G. Allin: Live and Pissed 1988 (2002), Allin is asked by a fan before the concert if he would “shit on stage tonight.” Allin responded by saying that he would try, but hadn’t eaten anything in several days, however, he had ingested a few laxatives earlier in the day in preparation for the show. Clearly Allin’s antics were not spur of the moment gut reactions delivered by a performer who became caught up in a destructive moment. Instead, they were the work of a calculated performance artist, with foresight and (sometimes) sober intentions. In 1990, while incarcerated in the state of Michigan, Allin penned his G.G. Allin Manifesto (Allin, K.), which called for the masses of the punk youth to “take back” rock and roll from the mainstream music industry.
Allin created a world of total disorder. Violence against audience members and himself was a regular element. While this was similar to many hardcore bands before, Allin’s shows were fueled with a mind-numbing rage that was so destructive, few venues would allow him to play for fear of destruction of property, injury to audience members, or both. At a show in Texas, G.G. Allin’s arm was broken when a group of fans attacked him onstage, thus ending his 1993 tour. Moreover, urination, defecation, masturbation, urolagina, coprophagia, and even rape were typical acts which one would see at a G.G. Allin show. Allin defended himself by claiming that audiences who see these acts would prepare themselves for the real world. In an interview on The Jerry Springer Show (episode dated May 5, 1993), Allin stated, “If you get raped at my show, you’re probably better off for it.”
While this degree of anarchy would probably rival Horkheimer and Adorno’s taste, they would most likely agree with Allin… to an extent. That is to say, Horkheimer and Adorno’s theory can be applied to Allin’s performances, in that Allin is desperately trying to throw off the pop culture system which has grown like a fungus on the subculture of punk. Allin would agree with Horkheimer and Adorno that punk had become an industry. Similarly, Horkheimer and Adorno, most likely, would claim that the punk movement was hopeless to resurrect, since it was clearly designed by a wealthy group of directors. Allin, however, clearly felt that punk, and even rock music as a whole, could be saved, if only those involved would revolt against the punk industry which had been created in the late ‘80s.
In Ryan Moore’s essay “Postmodernism and Punk Subculture: Cultures of Authenticity and Deconstruction, (Moore)” he claims that the punk subculture can be broken down into two separate areas: the culture of deconstruction and the culture of authenticity.
Deconstruction serves to separate the punk subculture from the mainstream. Moore asserts that the punk movement broke off from the rock genre in order to establish itself as a more aggressive harder version of the look, sound, and lifestyle. The culture of authenticity served to validate the broken off movement, resulting often in a do-it-yourself (DIY) attitude. Often the DIY attitude would result in the band recording and distributing their music and promotional materials by themselves. Punk bands became self-reliant. This DIY stance evolved over time into signing with major record labels and then a stronger focus on monetary gain, which had not been prevalent in earlier punk movements.
Allin and Adorno most likely would declare punk’s culture of authenticity to have originated when the subculture began to contradict its earlier intentions: ultimately, it was the desire of many punk bands to become “authentic” in the eyes of the masses which led to the downfall of punk. DIY attitude or not, the validation of punk by the masses was what pushed the movement over the edge. Allin served to stem the avalanche by actually using his culture of deconstruction as a means of authenticity; he would become so destructive that he would gain notoriety.
Now that we’ve examined Horkheimer and Adorno’s theory and applied it to the performances of G.G. Allin, we can return to our original research question: How does the pop culture react to non-conformist efforts? The answer to this question is that the masses react through distancing emotions.
Because there has been so much repetition in media in the past, there are relatively few ways in which to create true change. Some avant-garde artists in the past hundred years have begun to challenge this notion, but perhaps none so much as Allin. While films like Stan Brackage’s Dog Star Man (1961) and Maya Deren’s Meshes of the Afternoon (1943) were definitely original, they also maintained some similarities to earlier pop culture films. G.G. Allin’s music, and especially his performances, were unlike any other. Even the concept that Allin, as a performer, should sing during his performances was challenged; Allin would regularly spend much of the time wandering through the audience attacking fans, much to their delight. While his backup band might be somewhat conventional, considering they played rehearsed punk music, Allin was on a whole different level.
But all of these examples of originality—Brackage and Deren’s films, and Allin’s musical experiences—did alienate the mainstream. Moreover, the mainstream culture reacted to these artistic outputs. Audiences call them boring, some might find them scary, while others might become angry and frustrated. The end result is that humans have a definite emotional response to creative media, and these emotions serve to isolate them from the new and unknown. Such is not the case in extreme examples of pop culture media. For example, MTV’s The Real World often elicits a reaction of glazed eyes when it is broadcasted. On the part of the audience, there is no thought about the show. Instead, viewers merely watch the spectacle unfold, never acknowledging that this media is designed by a wealthy group of people who do not want the viewers to experience truly original media, because it would cost them money to have to shift focus.
But the meaning of the message from these artists who are actually original is not always clear, and this could cause some viewers to rush back to safety: pop culture. As Stuart Hall explains (Hall, et al.), communication is a loop of information. It is produced, circulated, consumed, and then reproduced. However, in Hall’s model, the consumption step is critical. If a viewer does not understand the intention of the message, then a new interpretation is inserted, thus changing the intended meaning.
Therefore, we may not fully understand what G.G. Allin is trying to say by performing in such a disorderly way. Perhaps he is actually trying to enlighten audiences to the idea that the punk subculture has “sold out” to corporations, and that is a bad thing. If, alternately, we think that he is merely on drugs or insane, we miss the overall intention to Allin’s performances.
Only by truly understanding Allin’s message can we understand how pop culture reacted. If we do not fully understand his message, we are left to wonder if miscommunication has prevented the pop culture from understanding, and thus, ruined the message. Much like a scientist must make sure that there are no other variables, we, too, must make sure that the rejection which the pop culture demonstrated to Allin was not due to a fundamental misunderstanding.
Because Allin was allowed to speak on talk shows such as The Jerry Springer Show, Geraldo, and The Jane Whitney Show, we can determine that the popular culture did, indeed, decode Allin’s true meaning. At this point, Horkheimer and Adorno would claim that the mere understanding of Allin’s message was designed by those in power. Perhaps it was the executives in charge of the networks which chose to have Allin as a guest in the first place.
But this is where Horkheimer and Adorno’s theory fails; the very emergence of the punk subculture is proof that there can be an alternative to pop culture, without the influence or direction of a ruling elite. Revising Horkheimer and Adorno’s claims, however, we can see that these ruling elite will make attempts to turn cultures of authenticity into offshoots of the mainstream culture. In other words, those in charge of establishing a pop culture will try to highlight the strangeness of performers like G.G. Allin. But once the strangeness has been accepted, the pop culture adopts these elements, claiming them as its own. Even in television shows such as American Idol, bubble gum singers portray the same punk signifiers as those in the hardcore punk subculture: spiky mohawks, studded bracelets, and black leather jackets.
Clearly there is a contradiction in Allin’s beliefs, too. Allin made proclamations that there should be total anarchy, but at the same time, everyone should follow his direction. These two actions are mutually exclusive from one another, thus proving the conflict within Allin’s message.
By examining the shortcomings of both theories, we can see that most of what Horkheimer and Adorno say holds true, however, one must take into consideration the countercultures which attempt to become cultures of deconstruction, such as punk. Eventually, these, too, will become marketable, and those in financial power will seek to control this market. This is what led to the crumbling of the punk movement in the late 1980s. Allin’s attempts to revive the dying subculture were so vile that they became unmarketable (which, of course, became his marketability) to the mainstream. Knowing this, Allin sought to turn the punk subculture away from those with financial power, and instead continue punk’s movement through the culture of deconstruction.
In June of 1993, after years of promising to commit suicide on stage, G.G. Allin died from an overdose of heroin. He died quietly in his sleep, and was not discovered until the following day. As Hated: G.G. Allin and the Murder Junkies (2004), the definitive documentary about Allin’s life, stated, “He did not die like a hero. Instead, he died like a rock star.”
By examining Horkheimer and Adorno’s theory of The Culture Industry and applying it to the performances and music of G.G. Allin, we have discovered not only the mainstream reaction to original expressions, but also the catch-22 in both messages.
What we can learn by examining these theories is that non-conventionality is always met with some resistance from the mainstream. Over time, however, the mainstream will absorb these non-conventions, thus appropriating them into the popular culture. Whether it be the punk music subculture, or the avant-garde film movement, those in the mass culture will have emotional reactions which initially distance themselves from the unique, and then adopt it. Perhaps, as Horkheimer and Adorno might say, these very reactions are designed by those directing the ship of pop culture; perhaps not. As Noam Chomsky once said, “Either you repeat the same conventional doctrines everybody is saying, or else you say something true, and it will sound like it's from Neptune.”
Works Cited
Allin, Kevin Michael. “G.G. Allin Manifesto.” GG Allin Online. Skeeter. 1990. 22 Aug. 2010. <http://ggallinonline.com/mission.php>
Allin, Merle. G.G. Allin.com. 22 Aug. 2010. <http://www.ggallin.com/>
“Episode dated May 5, 1993.” The Jerry Springer Show. NBC Television Network. Chicago, Illinois. 5 May 1993.
“Episode dated July 16, 1993.” The Jane Whitney Show. NBC Television Network. New York, NY. 16 July 1993.
G.G. Allin: Live and Pissed 1988. Perf. G.G. Allin. MVD Entertainment Group, 2002.
“G.G. Allin.” Wikipedia. 2010. Wikimedia Projects. 22 Aug. 2010. <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G.G._Allin>
Hall, Stuart, et al. Culture, Media, Language. London: Hutchinson, 1980.
Hated: G.G. Allin and the Murder Junkies. Dir. Todd Phillips. Perf. G.G. Allin. Alpha Video Distributors, 2004.
Horkheimer, Max and Theodor Adorno. The Dialectic of Enlightenment. New York: Continuum, 1995. pp. 120-167.
Moore, Ryan. “Postmodernism and Punk Subculture: Cultures of Authenticity and Deconstruction.” The Communication Review. July 2004. 7:305-327.