The Dangers of Peeping Through the Blinds or How Voyeurism in Body Double Depicts the Female

Robert Cannon

Dr. Ken Windrum

TVF 462

29 Nov. 2010


The Dangers of Peeping Through the Blinds

or

How Voyeurism in Body Double Depicts the Female



 Brian De Palma maneuvers Body Double (1984) through the waters of voyeurism in a style reminiscent of Alfred Hitchcock. From the beginning of the film, literally every pivotal scene possesses some sort of voyeuristic moment, whether it is Jake discovering that his girlfriend is cheating on him by walking in on her having sex with another man; Jake spying on an Indian satellite dish repairman, who in turn, is watching Holly Body dressed as Gloria perform a strip tease; or the über-meta porn film scene which reveals the camera crew in the bathroom mirror.

 But the voyeurism in the film is not simply gazing for gazing’s sake. Instead, it is loaded with meaning. Like an assassin’s bullet, each time a person is being watched (usually a woman), it gives the audience an uncomfortable feeling of looking into someone else’s private life — something that most of the characters in this film do not seem to find morally reprehensible. The act of gazing, especially when the subject is not aware, is a violation of privacy and strips the subject of this right. Moreover, women are almost always the subject of this gaze.

 The violation of privacy of women through voyeurism can be best identified through three major scenes: (1) the scene in which Jake first watches Gloria/Holly Body dance in the window; (2) the extended Rodeo Drive Shopping Center chase scene, which extends into the following Beach chase scene; (3) and the pornography film-within-a-film-within-a-film scene. These scenes are exemplary of a different way in which women are treated: objectification, helplessness, and sexualization, respectively. In order to understand each of these depictions throughout this film, we will examine these scenes and their implications, and then finally draw some conclusions about the film’s overall depiction of women.


 To begin, it is perhaps best to examine the most on-the-nose scene in the entire film: Jake using a telescope to watch Gloria dance in her house. The scene begins with Jake’s friend, Sam, setting up Jake by allowing him to spend a few nights in the Chemosphere, an oddly shaped house high in the Hollywood Hills. From the panoramic view, Jake can easily see into the equally high-priced houses below, one house in particular seems to be almost built so that someone inside the Chemosphere can see directly into the master bedroom. With floor to ceiling glass walls and blinds which are always open, this is a peeping tom’s paradise. For the sake of clarity, I will refer to this second house as the Glass House.

 Sam shows Jake how to operate a nearby telescope to get a better view of the woman, Gloria, inside the Glass House, who, ostensibly, dances erotically to no one every night “like clockwork.” This scene gives the implication that Sam watches Gloria every night, to the point that he even knows her schedule. When Sam leaves Jake alone to watch the stripping Gloria inside the Glass House, the tension of the film rises. Jake is clearly objectifying her, and Gloria almost seems to show herself off — this later comes into play, as we discover that it is not really Gloria at all, but rather, it is Holly Body hired to dance for a peeping tom. With all of this in mind, Jake and Sam are both characters who value the privacy of women very little over their own pleasures (note that I have refrained from emphasizing sexual pleasures — while Jake’s intentions might become sexual, at this point, his character could be merely curious, and Sam, while he claims to have sexual pleasure, actually has an ulterior motive). The literal meaning of objectification is meant here; Jake and Sam reduce Gloria to the level of becoming a mere object. In their eyes, she has no human rights: that of privacy. Furthermore, the character of the Indian repairman (which is later revealed to be Sam, and thus, for the purposes of this paper will be referred to as Indian Sam) also values his own visual satisfaction over the privacy of Gloria, and demeans her by violating her privacy. While we don’t know Indian Sam’s intentions of watching Gloria, the music of the film lets us know that it isn’t good. Perhaps Indian Sam is trying to kill Gloria, perhaps he intends to rape her, or maybe he simply hopes to steal her purse. Whichever the reason, Indian Sam is objectifying Gloria. To be clear, the point of examining this scene is not to show the sexualization of women — that comes later. Instead, the point is to show that the male gaze, in this usage, turns women into mere objects.

 However, perhaps there is another side of the story that is worth examining. One might also argue that these male characters are simply reacting to the spectacle. Whether exploitative or not, it becomes difficult to not watch someone in their own home when they have no idea that they are being watched. Seemingly contradictory to my earlier statements, it is important to consider this aspect of the gaze. In response to such an argument, I would challenge anyone equipped with a telescope and a nearby neighbor with a pension for leaving the blinds open to not watch what is going on next door. Some psychoanalytics might claim that people who leave their blinds open are subconsciously wanting others to ogle them, such as the scene in which Gloria tries on underwear in the Beverly Hills store, yet fails to close the dressing room curtain all the way. With that said, De Palma clearly intends for the women to be objectified, and thus the earlier analysis holds. Perhaps both Jake and Sam are also looking at the spectacle, but there is definitely a objectification inference being made.


 Second, we can examine the portrayed helplessness of women. None of the women in the film are seen as capable of handling themselves in dangerous situations. For example, when Jake watches Gloria being followed by Indian Sam, he never bothers to actually tell Gloria that someone is following/watching her. Instead, he takes it upon himself to stalk both Gloria and Indian Sam all through the Rodeo Drive Shopping Center, never stopping to tell anyone that Gloria is possibly in danger. After a long and unnecessary chase, Jake confronts Gloria on the beach and finally tells her that she is being followed, only to have Indian Sam suddenly appear out of nowhere, snatch Gloria’s purse, and run away. Gloria does nothing to try to stop Indian Sam; she simply shrieks. Jake gives chase, and this scene becomes the stereotypical damsel in distress. She is too weak/scared to prevent the danger, and only a “real man” can save her.

 The voyeurism in the preceding scene plays a pivotal role. Because Jake has very little experience in actually communicating with people (one begins to wonder if he is cut out to be an actor), he seems to feel more comfortable watching scenes play out than he is being a part of them. Because of this characteristic, he does not become involved with Gloria’s stalker until the damage has already been done. In other words, Jake has many opportunities to tell Gloria that someone — other than himself — is chasing her, yet, incredibly, he would rather watch her than say a word to her.

 Moreover, the mere act of following her instead of explaining the situation to her from the beginning furthers the idea that De Palma views women, at least in this film, as being helpless. Presumably, Gloria can’t handle the situation because she is a woman, and thus, Jake must follow her and watch after her. Because the characters are all so drunk on voyeuristic tendencies, they fail to act on what is the right thing to do: save Gloria’s life. If we are to believe Body Double’s perception of women, they cannot give chase if they are robbed, nor can they handle a strange man who might be stalking them. Men, conversely, are well adept at handling both such situations and must be called upon to solve these difficulties for women.

 

 Finally, by examining the porn film scene, we can discover how, through voyeurism, women are viewed as sexual objects. Jake, now at a loss after having failed to capture Indian Sam, happens to turn on a pornographic film which depicts Holly Body performing her signature dance move. To an untrained eye, this might have gone unnoticed, however, to Jake, the voyeuristic pro, the exact dance moves which he noticed in Gloria’s house only a day earlier are clear. Within a few hours, Jake has identified the producers of Holly’s latest film, secured an audition in their next porno, and is suddenly the star of their next big budget porno musical production. Despite the ridiculousness of the timeframe and the apparently uncharacteristically big budget sets and extras, this scene plays out in a fun and enjoyable way. However, it is not without its sexual exploits.

 Set to the Frankie Goes to Hollywood song “Relax,” the porno filming scene provides example after example of how women are sexualized in the film. As Jake is lead through an elaborate porno set designed to look like a cantina, the men are all dressed in a variety of clothing which represents the various classes of men that would be present in this bar. The women, however, are almost all dressed alike: as scantily clad as possible. But this is only the tip of the iceberg. Jake follows a woman to an area of the bar which is designated by a sign which reads, “Sluts.” This area is for women only, and as Jake secretly slips inside, he notices another door, this one also marked, “Sluts.” This door leads into the “Sluts” restroom. His sexual lust obviously taking over, he feels the need to wander inside the restroom to get a better look. The voyeurism is out of control at this point, as even the camera crew filming the scene is shown in the mirror on the back of the restroom door. The scene hits a tongue-in-cheek peak when Jake utters the line, “I like to watch.” Meanwhile, Holly Body dances in assless chaps to the song being blasted over the speakers. Jake says nothing else to Holly, and she immediately begins to take off his pants, verifying the sexualization that De Palma has assigned her. Finally, at the scene’s apex, the voyeuristic porno camera crew begin to wonder out loud, “Where’s the come shot?”

 This scene illustrates just a few of the dozens of ways within the film which depict women as merely sexual beings. The porno film is made with men in mind, and yet, Jake is dressed in non-sexual clothing, while Holly is in a skimpy leather outfit. Throughout the entire scene, it is always the men looking at the women sexually, never the other way around, and even the porn crew is made up of entirely males. The women are sexual, first and foremost. They are there only for the sexual gratification of men. Even the name of their gender, women, is demeaned and sexualized when it is converted into “Sluts.” The cherry on top of the sexualization sundae is the notion that the scene is not complete until the male orgasms, thus nullifying any sort of sexual gratification perspective of the female.


 By examining these scenes, we can see how Body Double depicts women in a negative and limiting way. Through the use of objectification, helplessness, and sexualization, the film demeans the feminine gender throughout. Voyeurism plays a central role in each of these three depictions. By examining the Chemosphere telescope scene, the Rodeo Drive Shopping Center/beach chase scene, and the pornographic film scene, we can gain a better insight into the subtext of the film and discover the ways in which females are portrayed through voyeurism. If one were to extend a psychobiographical approach to De Palma’s films, these themes tend to return time and time again. Films such as The Untouchables (1987), Carlito’s Way (1993), and Scarface (1983) all contain similar elements. While the voyeurism may not be as prominent in these other ventures, the demeaning depiction of women is evident.

 It could be also argued that De Palma is aware of the derogatory way in which he depicts women in his films. Indeed, Body Double seemed to take an almost comical approach to the ending sequence which plays underneath the credits. In it, a vampire scene is shot with a body double’s breasts becoming the center of the focus. Once again, this is seen through the voyeuristic nature of the film industry, and seems almost over-the-top in its sexualization of the female body. One might begin to wonder if De Palma is being ironic in his portrayal of women. If this were the case, De Palma would be making a presumably calculated risk: many viewers would not understand the irony and mistake it for actual sexualization.

 Whatever De Palma’s intentions are, the film is laden with voyeurism which then leads to negative depictions of women. Whether De Palma was mirroring Hitchcock’s sexist portrayals from decades earlier or making them on his own, Body Double contains more than a few. Perhaps an interesting remake would be to film the story with switched gender roles; the female character character now objectifies, finds helpless, and sexualizes the male. The only question then would be: would Sam’s character still be portrayed as a Native American Indian? But then, that’s a whole different can of worms…

Previous
Previous

America vs. Europe

Next
Next

Alienation Emotions from the Pop Culture Mainstream