“Are We Human or Are We Robots?
by
Robert Cannon
TVF 460 Summer 2010
Walter Benjamin makes several claims in his essay, which fortunately for us, turn out to be based on a few logical fallacies. Otherwise, we’d be living in a really dark world. Obviously, I disagree with Benjamin, and will explain my own reasonings. But first, I will examine Benjamin’s theory before second, examining one of the major fallacies.
Benjamin states that art has always be reproducible. Essentially, we, as humanity, have always been able to make some sort of copy of whatever art we’d like. How many heads does Easter Island have, again?
He goes on to state that the problem with reproductions is that they aren’t the original. If you want to be able to say you saw the Eiffel Tower, you’re gonna have to go to France. Just looking at a postcard isn’t enough. He calls this the “aura” of art.
However, because reproductions have gotten so specialized, the aura of art is often tainted. So, for example, a film shot in Paris might leave out the top of the Eiffel Tower, thus undoing the artistic merit of the entire architectural structure of the thing. He states that the aura is altered by time and space, so if the Eiffel Tower were moved to, say, Arizona to be placed right next to the London Bridge (!), then the aura might, possibly, could, maybe be sorta slightly effected. It is at this point I would like to use that old cliché 1990s colloquialism: “No duh.”
But Benjamin furthers this idea when he says that art is created for two reasons: the cult and the exhibition. Basically, this means the self and the public. The self might include a spiritual self, such as making art for God(s). He says that the main reason was for cult and then exhibition was almost an after-thought. However, the modernization of art and reproduction possibilities makes these two elements switch. Suddenly, once we hit the 20th century, exhibition becomes more important than the cult. No other particular art best exemplifies this better than the film.
In fact, Benjamin states, the audience responds to the aura of a camera, not that of an actor. He implies that the actor is a shell of a vapid human. Personally, methinks Benjamin might be drinking too much absinthe and reading too much Poe, because this outlook on life is bleak, and paints a picture of a wold in which I don’t want to live. Not to mention that it smacks of a misunderstanding of technology and its impact on society.
He goes on to state that the evil of cinema is rooted in its ability to go through movements (German Expressionism, French New Wave, Dadaism, etc) within only a few years, whereas other arts took decades, perhaps centuries to cultivate. Again, though, this reeks of someone more afraid of the power of technology than someone who fully understands it. I make the same arguments to my father when he refuses to buy an iPhone 4, because he says his 1997 Motorola “works better.”
Benjamin then compares a cameraman to a magician, while a classic painter is a surgeon. Pish!
Assertions are made that paintings were never meant to be viewed by masses. Even viewings of chapel art was done by “hierarchized meditation.” However, he seems to forget that most art in churches was designed for the illiterate masses. They were invited into the churches and then encouraged to view the art, which often told the stories of the bible they could not read. Clearly, this art was meant for the masses. As were a multitude of sculptures, architecture, and magic lantern shows, which had been around for hundreds of years before cinema.
However, Benjamin does make a good point when he states that the emergence of cinema makes us more hyper aware of what is being said and shown. The repeatability of cinema means that it can be further analyzed, and I have to agree with Benjamin, here. It links in nicely to Benjamin’s final contention, which is that the number of artists and people who are obsessed with becoming a celebrity has become rampant. While I agree with Benjamin on some level, I would argue that what has actually happened is that fame has become the new religion. During the 1800s, the stars of the day were military and political figures (e.g. Robert E. Lee, Abraham Lincoln, Davy Crockett). For thousands of years before that, the famous members of society were all religious figures (e.g. Jesus, Mohamed, various Popes).
The problem with Benjamin’s theory is that he assumes all humans are robots. By asserting that humans are somehow losing an element of the actual “art experience” by witnessing a replica, Benjamin comes across as more than a little dark. What he fails to recognize is that the dissemination (Dime-store word!) of art is only made possible by the advancements in communication. For example, as Benjamin points out, the lithograph enables us to view pictures. True, but we would never have an opportunity to see those pictures were it not for the newspaper. Since communication has become so incredibly intertwined in our lives, it makes it possible to enjoy art for other reasons that what the author intended.
Consider a lonely farmer in the mid-1800s somewhere in what is modern-day West Virginia. Let’s just call him Fred. Fred has heard all about this newly-known artwork called Mona Lisa. This poor peasant farmer would never have the chance to view the painting, because of a lack of communication.
However, what with new inventions of communication, we can learn to appreciate art in ways that take it out of the hands of the elite and put the power of opinion in the hands of the people. That same farmer today would rush right over to the high-speed Internet and view a reproduced image. There is a beauty in that, alone.
Benjamin fails to see that without the invention of the lithograph, this farmer would never have any appreciation for art, whatsoever. Take an informal poll, and one will quickly realize that the majority of people are happy to have sloppy-seconds on art; most people would rather experience an inferior version of the Sistine Chapel than to never have any idea of what it looks like. True, there is probably more beauty in the actual experience of the original. To quote the movie Good Will Hunting: “So if I asked you about art, you'd probably give me the skinny on every art book ever written. Michelangelo, you know a lot about him. Life's work, political aspirations, him and the pope, sexual orientations, the whole works, right? But I'll bet you can't tell me what it smells like in the Sistine Chapel. You've never actually stood there and looked up at that beautiful ceiling; seen that.”
But Benjamin takes such a cynical stance that the only natural conclusion is that he must believe that all humans are actually robots programmed to have no feelings regarding art until presented the original. Benjamin would have us look only at original art auras and never experience art, if even a reproduction, for the enjoyment it brings.
In the end, we can see that while Benjamin’s assumptions might seem correct to him, on the whole of humanity, they are flawed. That is, unless we all have oil running through our veins.