The ‘High Rise’ of Twitter or TV and Twitter Showdown

Robert Cannon

Professor S. Reagan

COMS 501 Final Exam

17 Mar. 2011


The ‘High Rise’ of Twitter

or

TV and Twitter Showdown


 In early March, 2011, a devastating earthquake shook the world. Located just off the coast of Japan, the 8.9 magnitude quake posed a threat of tsunamis which was deadly reminiscent of the tsunami which hit Indonesia only a few hours earlier. Within hours, thousands of Japanese lives were lost. The rest of the world braced themselves; they readied themselves not just for the tsunami which would begin to circle the globe, but to deal with the devastation of the main Japanese island which would, no doubt, cost trillions of dollars in damage and would take thousands of lives.

 Of course earthquakes are impossible to predict. However, almost immediately, there was a Twitter hashtag which was established “#Japanearthquake.” Using this hashtag, users across the world were able to chime in on the devastating event, and users became more aware of the voices which were trapped by the tsunami. Sadly, some of the last words sent to the world, by some, were through the use of this Twitter hashtag.

 

 The media is, no doubt, changing. Traditional media (that of television crews and on-the-scene reporters) were nowhere near the speed of the locals who were broadcasting their perceptions of the quake. This poses the research question: Was Twitter more effective at distributing news during the 2011 Japanese quake than traditional television media? In order to answer this question, it will be necessary to utilize both qualitative and quantitative analysis to triangulate an answer.

 My hypothesis is that, while Twitter is certainly emerging as a mass-to-mass reporting medium, the more traditional media is still largely favored because of the apparent accuracy of the content. Therefore, it becomes essential to examine the accuracy of the news by both mediums: Twitter and traditional means.


Definitions:

 It is essential to understand what the term ‘effective’ means to the research question within this paper. In order to limit the field of view to a manageable amount, the definition used here will be shaped through the form of a question: were the messages sent as accurate as they were perceived? In other words, in order for a media message to be considered ‘effective,’ it must communicate the message which was intended


Background

 Twitter is simultaneously both limited and enhanced by its format. While users may only type out 140 characters at a time (a clear limitation when trying to report on such an earth-shattering event), it has the advantage of being bite-size. Users can read the entire message quickly. Moreover, users fully understand the limitation of Twitter, and often attempt to ‘get to the nugget’ of their message, so as to not waste characters. Furthermore, because Twitter is open to users worldwide, the amount of information is tremendous; users can add to discussions in real-time and there is no limit on the number of additions a user can make (which almost nullifies the 140 character limitation). Additionally, while Twitter is limited to the number of users who utilize a hashtag, it is also enhanced by these same users; Twitter can self-correct, in that, if a user sends out incorrect information, it is immediately read and most often corrected by other users in real-time. Twitter even has a pre-established system set up for users to accomplish this.

 Traditional television media, on the other hand, has a different set of limitations and advantages. Quite possibly the most important aspect is that it has been established as a reliable way of acquiring information. Backed by money, television can afford strong reporters and glossy graphics to make messages clear to the audience. However, this format also has its limitations. Because reporters may not be positioned in the center of the event, they must be dispatched. This eats up valuable reporting time, as most media-worthy events develop quickly, and without camera coverage, it becomes difficult for a reporter to re-establish the story.


 Research Design

 Qualitative:

 The sheer number of stories which have been published using Twitter compared to the number of American television media stories is almost unbelievable. Twitter users add stories in real-time, and with the thousands, if not millions, of users who were writing about the earthquake as it happened, the number of Tweets far outweighs the number of television stories.

 However, what needs to be established is where Americans were turning to get their news. A survey would be used with a large number of Americans from various socioeconomical backgrounds, in order to establish the way in which they found out about the earthquake. The survey would include, but would not be limited to, the following questions:

1. How did you first hear about the 2011 Japanese earthquake?

 a.) television  b.) Twitter c.) other

2. Once you heard about the quake, were you prone to researching more about the event on your own? (yes or no)

3. If yes, where did you go to find more information about the quake?

 a.) television  b.) Twitter c.) other


 By using a survey such as this, we can begin to divide the survey group into sections based on which media source they most prefer. Those who were surveyed who knew little about the earthquake or did not learn about it through either of these two means (such as the radio or Internet) would be discarded from the further process. An ideal candidate would be someone who would have answered either ‘a’ for #1 and ‘b’ for #3, or vice versa, as these people would have been exposed to both media message formats.


 Qualitative

 Having established a smaller group through the use of the survey, a more in-depth interview can be utilized so as to further understand how the given media format handled the information it projected. Here, users who valued Twitter more than television would be asked what aspect of the medium they like most. Additionally, were there aspects of Twitter which were limited, especially compared to the television depictions? Were certain events covered by Twitter users which never saw screen time on TV? On the flip side, were there aspects of the news reporting which went untouched by most Twitter users?



It should be noted that Twitter tends to skew to a younger crowd, whereas television tends to draw from most walks of life. One of the limitations of this study would be that, most likely, the subjects interviewed would be in a 18-35 year old range. The perceptions of news journalism are tremendously different for those who experienced journalism watershed moments, such as the depiction of the Vietnam war in the 1960s and ‘70s.


“American television media”

Previous
Previous

Are We Human or Are We Robots?

Next
Next

Perfection Incarnate or I Was Fading Already