Robert Cannon
Professor S. Regan
COMS 508
7 Jun. 2011
Gridlocked
or
The Politics of Traffic
If there is one universal feeling of anger, it might just be the frustration associated with sitting in traffic. As you begin to curse yourself for not having left the house earlier, it becomes a philosophical question: why? Why aren’t we moving? Why aren’t we going anywhere? And most importantly, why haven’t we solved traffic?
Increasingly, Americans are moving away from rural areas, and the urban edges are exploding with newcomers. Like the urban explosion immediately following the return of soldiers from World War II, cities today have become overwhelmed with the influx of more people. While the infrastructure starts to burst from the over usage of goods and services, the area which seems to show the most significant signs of wear and tear are through our mass transportation avenues.
While trains and buses certainly help alleviate these stresses, the principle form of transportation for most Americans is the automobile. However, local, state, and federal governments are turning a blind eye to the ways in which citizens use their cars.
Therefore, the proposed documentary, Gridlocked, and this related paper seek to explain the reasons why traffic exist, both from a tangible standpoint (out on the road), and from a less tangible one (behind closed political doors). By analyzing traffic in such a way, this project hopes to awaken viewers to a new political arena which has more of a direct impact on day-to-day life of most citizens than the majority of current political ‘hot topics.’
This paper will first, review a few significant pieces of support literature in order to establish a backbone of direction in which to steer the ultimate film. Then, the paper will address framework of the film by examining the problems, causes, and possible solutions to the issue of traffic, thus laying the groundwork for the documentary film to come. Finally, this paper will discuss the expectations and probable social impact of the film on society. In this way, it becomes possible to organize the issues surrounding traffic into a more manageable way, and then deal with these issues in an logical fashion. Moreover, this structure (especially the problems-causes-solutions section), will serve as the foundation upon which I can begin to base my expected results.
By analyzing traffic in a problems-causes-solutions way, the accessibility of the documentary will be enhanced; it is my belief that this simple system is highly effective and logistical, thus increasing the number of viewers who can both understand the topic and make sense out of a documentary, going so far as to, hopefully, reshape their view of political issues and vote according to what affects them on a daily basis over a hypothetical/philosophical vote. Simply put, traffic should become an issue on which to vote. Period. The film, Gridlocked, and this accompanying paper will have a dramatic social impact and the change can begin to be heard through the voting results.
Significant Literature
Before examining the structure of the film through a problems-causes-and-solutions-style scope, it becomes necessary to examine the effect of documentary films on society as a whole. Perhaps no other filmmaker in recent history has mad more of a political splash than the controversial Michael Moore. Moore’s films Fahrenheit 9/11 (2004) and Bowling for Columbine (2002) have proved to be mainstays in the documentary genre. These films, along with other works in Moore’s canon, have changed both public policy and the expectations of those seeking political office.
Moreover, filmmakers such as Morgan Spurlock’s Super Size Me (2004) have changed policy within major corporations (after Spurlock’s film was released, political pressure on McDonald’s forced them to remove the option to ‘super size’ value meals and to begin offering alternative options for side items, such as fruit or salad). Similarly, Davis Guggenheim’s An Inconvenient Truth (2006) served to change the national dialogue surrounding global warming. Al Gore’s speech, which was the basis of the film, became the definitive word surrounding the debate and earned the pair a best documentary Oscar and rewarded Al Gore with a Nobel Peace Prize in 2007. Clearly the film was a success (I need not even begin to discuss the box office power which these films achieved).
However, all of these films extend an already-existing debate surrounding a topic which is already in the forefront of citizen’s minds. Super Size Me was hardly the first word on overweight Americans, and scores of documentaries had already touched on the teen violence topic of Bowling for Columbine. Rarely is a documentary created about a subject for which there does not exist a significant number of preexisting materials.
Two notable exceptions to this rule are the documentaries Hot Coffee and Resurrect Dead: The Mystery of the Toyenbee Tiles (both 2011). The former is a film surrounding the contrary side of the debate: that we should are not litigious enough of a society. Here, filmmaker Susan Saladoff makes the unusual case that Americans need the ability to sue, and that the concept of tort reform is destructive to our society. Politicians on both sides of the aisle have favored tort reform, but Saladoff’s film is a slap in the face to a sleepy America; there is little discussion surrounding her side of the debate over tort reform, other than her documentary. Jon Foy’s film, Resurrect Dead: The Mystery of the Toyenbee Tiles touches on a rare type of graffiti art to which only a select group of people are even able to identify. This art, which has a complicated political message is so unknown to most viewers, that the film spends the better half of the movie explaining the background of the graffiti for the benefit of the audience.
However, while Super Size Me and Fahrenheit 9/11 are practically household names, the latter two films are not. Moreover, the political messages in the former films seem to ring more true because they are dealing with issues to which we are familiar.
Addressing the issue of traffic, there is, perhaps, no better traffic source to turn to than the Texas Traffic Institute’s deca-annual Urban Mobility Report (TTI). The institute has collected data since 1982, and while it is centered in Austin and uses the Texas moniker, it studies traffic from across the nation in every city where traffic is a problem. The information available within the Urban Mobility Reports is vital to anyone who is doing traffic research. However, the limitation of such literature is that citizens aren’t using it. While this information is available online for anyone to see, the sheer magnitude of information can be intimidating. Furthermore, many of those who would be interested in traffic study are unaware of where to go.
But like Marry Poppins’ song suggests, a spoon full of sugar helps the medicine go down. This documentary is that spoon full of sugar. The influence of documentaries in recent cinematic history has indicated that viewers are more willing to engage with strong political content if it comes from a documentary film. This film hopes to be that ‘digestible’ explanation.
I would be remiss if I were to exclude the Federal Highway Administration’s own research. Their study titled “Traffic Congestion and Reliability” serves as the damning evidence as to the causes behind the problems of traffic (Cambridge Systematics, Inc.). Moreover, these causes, as we will later see, are directly linked to the government. Thus, this piece of evidence is pivotal in proving that governmental politics play a significant role in the formation of traffic and the way in which it is effectively dealt with, or not.
This source, however, falls under the same limitations as those from the Texas Traffic Institute do; most citizens will never slog through the hundreds of documents needed in order to understand what the government or specialized agency is saying. Weighted within governmental politics is a red tape bureaucracy which makes a deeper understanding of governmental literature difficult to understand. Moreover, the document does not point fingers. No politicians are indicated as being inept in regards to traffic design and upkeep. Thus, it is the purpose of this documentary to weed out the unnecessary information and provide the ‘juicy’ bits.
Finally, the Environmental Protection Agency released multiple studies which attest to the dangers of traffic, not only to the environment, but also to the direct health and safety of motor vehicle operators (EPA). The EPA has made a consorted effort to inform Americans surrounding the hazards of traffic congestion and that this aspect of daily driving alone would greatly reduce the impact on global warming and heart disease.
Once again, however, these government documents are cast aside by the majority of Americans. Few want to take the time to read through copious amounts of government documents when there are shows like American Idol (2002). Since it is impossible to change the human desire to be entertained, this film hopes to incorporate these findings and others into its understanding of traffic as a political issue, and encourage American citizens to examine these articles in greater length, so as to become more informed for themselves.
Having examined some background literature and theoretical documentary underpinnings to the project, the next step becomes to lay out the framework for the film itself.
Framework
Similar to many of the previously mentioned documentary films, Gridlocked’s methodology is designed to follow a guide through the cockles of a bureaucratic government. Ideally, a host with some sense of passion surrounding the topic would be used. The dream candidate for the job would be Adam Carolla. Carolla, already known for his long-winded radio and podcast rants against traffic and the bureaucratic ailments associated with it, would provide not only a comical relief to the film, but also a built-in audience, as his fans have proved to be impressively loyal.
With Carolla at the helm, the film would be able to negotiate the difficult aspects of traffic as a political discussion without having to resort to copious amounts of ‘B roll footage’ of cars stuck on the interstate. In other words, having a guide, especially one as engaging as Carolla, would give the documentary something to shoot instead of showing lots of cars sitting in traffic. Using Carolla’s aggressive interview style, the film is free to interview local politicians in various cities (and maybe even national politicians), regarding their stances on traffic. Securing interviews with, not only successful traffic politicians but also seeking to interview those who have failed the public would be necessary. Ideally, the feel of these interviews would ring similar to the style of Roger & Me (1989).
Interesting data would be provided which has been accumulated though extensive research. While much of the research would, no doubt, need to be conducted after principle photography so as to be as current as possible, much of the research would also need to be completed ahead of time in order to make for more dynamic interviews and a stronger sense of direction for the entire film.
Fun experiments would be designed to better explain difficult traffic concepts, resulting in a lively atmosphere similar to an adult science fair. With Mythbusters (2003) as the model, the film would illustrate traffic theories in a practical, yet light-hearted way.
The overall design of the film plot is to address three main issues: the problems of traffic, the causes behind these problems, and some potential solutions. Thus, this paper will take a similar route of design.
Problems
Aside from the common problem that we all experience with traffic (i.e. having to deal with the frustration of doing nothing when we could be doing something), four main problems are the root issues.
1. Traffic wastes the time of Americans. According to an article by Katherine Dorsett, last updated Sept. 18, 2007, traffic congestion is the cause of 38 work hours lost per person per year in the United States (Dorsett). That’s an entire work week just spent sitting in your car. According to the Texas Traffic Institute, the worst city for traffic inside the United States is, no surprise, Los Angeles (TTI). In 2009 alone, the number of wasted hours by commuters who sat in traffic totaled 514,955,000. This colossal waste of time is hinders our ability to live life.
Time is our most precious resource and is the only true non-renewable one we have. While oil reserves may, one day, eventually become replenished—albeit, in a few million years— time is something we have no way of turning back. Thus, when we spend the better part of our lives waiting to do the things we want to do, Americans should be outraged. This aspect of traffic congestion alone should be enough to make citizens begin to ask political candidates the new tough question: what’s your view of traffic?
2. Our roads are killing us. The stress of having to wait behind thousands of others is not only a hindrance but is proven to be deadly. The Environmental Protection Agency has released a document from December, 2005 which focuses on environmental hazards which have adverse effects on the healthiness of an average human heart (EPA). In the EPA issuance, traffic is named as one of the chief influences of heart attacks. The reason given is that traffic causes, not only air pollution which affects the heart (more on this later), but also the stress of sitting in traffic. Waiting in line is shaving years off our lives, and yet, there is scarcely a word about it. While it may seem hasty to assign the responsibility of all heart attacks to traffic, it’s clear that waiting in line for your freeway exit isn’t helping.
Moreover, the road rage incidents of the 1990s are evidence that traffic stress can often become destructive, sometimes even violent. In 1997, these cases were discussed in a House of Representatives hearing before the Subcommittee on Surface Transportation of the Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure (SUBCOMMITTEE ON SURFACE TRANSPORTATION). During this hearing, studies by the Department of Transportation were revealed: 30% of fatalities on American roads were the result of poor road design. The government’s ineffectiveness in road design is being taken out on the taxpayers.
3. Traffic is costing us an arm and a leg. While traffic is hurting us in a multitude of ways, it a hemorrhage of money. The TTI’s Urban Mobility Report claims that, on average, we are wasting 2.9 billion gallons of gas just by sitting there (TTI). This, along with the lost man hours, results in a $78.2 billion loss in the economy. To think that this money is essentially being wasted is a travesty when, in these hard economic times, we are at an all-time high of national debt. Traffic is, in essence, the urban equivalent of leaving the toilet running.
Much of the money allocated for road repair (money acquired by gas taxes which are paid at the pump) is never spent. This money, if not spent by the end of the fiscal year, is considered surplus money and is funneled into more general funds, most of which have nothing to do with road repair or design. American taxpayers are, yet again, footing the bill to a problem which sees no attention from the government.
4. Pollution is a problem. The Texas Traffic Institute, the Environmental Protection Agency, the Federal Highway Administration, and dozens of other independent and government agencies have issued warnings against the tremendous amount of pollution associated with traffic congestion. The Environmental Protection Agency released findings on Sept. 8, 2008, that each year highway traffic causes over 41 million tons of carbon-monoxide pollution (EPA). Off-highway adds another 19 million tons. Combined, this 60 million tons, along with another quarter million tons of ammonia, and 10 million tons of nitrogen oxide, equals more than 70 million tons of highly toxic chemicals being released for no reason other than a poorly designed traffic flow. Clearly, the amount of toxic chemicals being pumped into the environment from traffic is having an adverse effect and must be addressed in a timely manner.
Causes
Having examined the four major problems with traffic, it is imperative to discuss the causes behind these problems. The Federal Highway Administration states that there are eight major causes of traffic congestion (FHWA). These eight categories can be partitioned into two distinct types: the reoccurring and non-reoccurring.
Non-Reoccurring
1. Incidents: When the mattress atop the over-stuffed pick-up truck falls off the top and lands in the middle lane of the interstate, traffic will, understandably, back up. However, while these times are few and far between, traffic is more often caused by ‘rubberneckers’ who are interested in looking at the accident by the side of the road or the police officer who is issuing a ticket to some unlucky soul.
2. Work Zones: The repair of roads will slow things down to a crawl, and this is amplified if the work is done during an opportune time. Los Angeles has historically avoided this issue by investing in a large supply of work lights and nighttime construction crews.
3. Weather events: There is nothing people can do to change the weather of a given area; if it’s going to rain, it’s going to rain. The issue with the FHA understanding of this is that many roads are not designed with weather in mind. Many streets in the troubled Los Angeles area are not adequately fitted with drainage, and thus, during a hard rain, the streets begin to flood. The Federal Highway Administration has begun to develop a Road Weather Management Program, but at the time of this writing, it serves little purpose, other than to inform Internet users about the dangers of fog and hot roads (FHA).
4. Special events: In a Los Angeles Times article from April 25th, 2011, writer Andrew Blankstein explains how the entire city was ground to a halt because President Obama came to town (Blankstein). Not only did presidential security shut down exits and halt cars in their tracks, but onlookers hoping to catch a glimpse of the president compounded the issue.
5. Emergencies: The least likely to be predicted, emergencies are also the least likely to cause our day-to-day lives to become altered. However, perhaps this cause alone should be of central focus to citizens, since it is during these emergencies which most directly affect the lives of a road’s users. Following the 2011 earthquakes which crippled Japan, the tsunami was suspected to hit Oregon. However, according to an article from The Oregonian, the tsunami escape route on March 11th was jammed shut due to heavy traffic flow (The Oregonian). It is the responsibility of the government to not only create roads but to create ones which are usable. This concept is only exacerbated when a natural disaster looms over the lives of thousands. The government must create adequate escape routes for a time of emergency.
Reoccurring
Much more influential in determining the reason why traffic exists in the first place are the reoccurring causes. These issues, more than the non-reoccurring, are almost always the responsibility of the local, state, and federal governments.
1. Insufficient capacity: if roads are not capable of holding a large number of vehicles but are still in high demand, traffic will necessarily occur. Many roads create a ‘bottleneck’ phenomenon, which according to the Federal Highway Administration, makes up 40% of traffic congestion (FHWA). Moreover, one of the primary instances of insufficient capacity is due to poor road design. The road design of many inner-city streets causes drivers to use unnecessary side streets. This is a dangerous side effect of poor road design, because this unnecessary traffic can easily result in automobile accidents and even the possibility of harming neighborhood children at play. Furthermore, the poor road design is confusing to drivers unfamiliar with the area, compounding the issue of stress, slower automobile movement and increasing the chances of accidents.
2. Unrestrained Demand: There are, simply put, some roads which are more popular than others. In Los Angeles, the intersection of the US-101 and the I-405 is, according to a Robert Malone’s article titled “America’s Worst Traffic Traps,” the worst intersection in the country, in terms of traffic (Malone). As an article from the blog LAist points out, Los Angeles ‘won’ four of the top 12 worst bottlenecks in the country (LAist). The city is unable or unwilling to make the flow a traffic a priority, and thus, the size, design, and upkeep of the roads, particularly in Los Angeles, are devastating.
Another major cause of traffic congestion is something called the ripple effect. According to author Johnathan Strickland in his article “How Traffic Works,” the Ripple Effect is caused when drivers needlessly tap on their brake light (Strickland). The light that the car emits causes the driver behind him or her to step on his or her brake light, and so on, until the entire flow of traffic is slowed to a crawl.
3. Ineffective management of capacity (e.g. poor signal timing): The timing of cars through intersections is, as of 2011, archaic. Designed in another technological time, these are remnants of a bygone era. But these anachronisms remain in use throughout the United States, despite the invention of myriad technological advancements.
Most traffic signals do not detect when a car pulls up to the intersection; they are on timers. Moreover, these are rarely timed with one another. As drivers move through a green light at one intersection, they are forced to slow down to a stop at the next because the second light has just turned red. Correctly timing the signals would allow for drivers to continue in a straight path, unaltered. This would significantly reduce the amount of pollution, alone.
Solutions
Having examined the causes of traffic, we can now begin to examine the potential solutions. While there are literally thousands of solutions to traffic, this paper and documentary seek to advance only but a few. While many solutions are fantastic additions to the perplexing problem of traffic, identifying a large number of solutions can be taxing to readers and documentary viewers alike. It is easy to become overwhelmed with ideas. Thus, this paper hopes to identify only a handful of useful ones which could realistically be implemented in a reasonable amount of time, a small budgetary impact, and with minimal controversy from the voting public.
1. Make traffic a voting issue: while dozens of other issues steal the spotlight in political debates, traffic is rarely discussed or even mentioned. By suggesting that citizens discuss traffic like so many other political issues, this ensures that politicians must develop an official stance towards traffic and will be held accountable for their results.
This is a win-win situation. Politicians can easily sink their teeth into this issue without worrying about offending constituents. No one in their right mind would suggest that traffic is good, and both sides of the party line would agree that it is a hindrance. Much like education and senior abuse, this is a political issue with a clear answer: we want less traffic.
For the voting public, this is also a beneficial topic of discussion. Traffic is a measurable thing. Studies can easily be conducted to discover how effective new implementations are. Highways can be examined to see if there is, as a hypothetical politician has promised, less traffic. Unlike test scores, which are a good, but not great, indicator of educational improvement, traffic measurements are accurate and easily felt; if a politician gets it right, the public will know, because that public lives on the streets which are no longer jammed.
2. Promote mass transit: While this is the same party line from the past, if politicians promote mass transit more, then there will be fewer people using the roads. In a Reason.com article titled “Politicians Love Transit, Just Not for Themselves,” New York mayor Michael Bloomberg rose in popularity when he was spotted taking the subway to work each morning, just like so many ‘regular’ New Yorkers (Balaker). However, few politicians are willing to do that. The subway is yucky, after all.
3. Seemingly paradoxically, raise gas prices: While most citizens shriek when they see a ten-cent pice hike at a gas station, this may just be the blessing in disguise we’ve been waiting for. According to an article in Businessweek Magazine from Aug. 4 2008, higher gas prices mean fewer cars on the road, plain and simple (Carey). When prices are high, drivers drive less. More people begin to consider alternative methods of transportation: biking to work, walking to school, taking the bus to the movies. Perhaps the price of gas, which so many feared, will be that extra push we need to begin relying on mass transportation more often.
4. Stronger emphasis on drivers to learn the conventions of driving: some drivers seem to know that when driving on the interstate, the left hand lane is for passing. Other drivers hang out in the fast lane far beyond the time it takes to overtake a car and prevent others from getting by.
Some drivers are not aware that in most states, it is legal to turn right at a red light, so long as there is no oncoming traffic. These conventions, and others like them, would help speed up the cities. Moreover, police should be on the lookout, not just for speeders, but also for those drivers who are inconsiderate and do not turn, when the opportunity is available. Police should be just as diligent in searching for those who slow the city down as they are for those who risk injury by speeding.
Expectations and Social Impact
Gridlocked would be designed to permeate the public sphere of political discussions. Similar to the documentaries mentioned earlier, it is necessary for the film to be seen by as many people as possible. In this way, the film should be considered a success only when considering the number of viewers who have either seen the film or have become more aware of the role in which ordinary citizens play in the creation and political action surrounding traffic. In order to stir the most amount of dialogue around the film and topic, the distribution strategy is simple:
1. Attempt entry into major film festivals:
Film festivals have long been the hunting grounds for major distributors. While independent production companies sweat all the details, the distributors swoop in at the last minute and offer to put the film onto DVD, into theaters, or make it available through Video on Demand. Festivals such as Sundance, Tribecca, South by Southwest, Berlin, Cannes, and Toronto have been instrumental in establishing a film as a must-see work. In no genre has this been more true than the documentary. These festivals, along with dozens of others, have created the preliminary buzz around many of the previously cited documentaries, thus creating the desire for non-festival audiences to check the film out, too. If Gridlocked were granted entry into these festivals, this would lend the right air of legitimacy which would put the traffic policy into the minds of viewers.
2. Attempt distribution through a studio:
While the chances may seem rather slim that this is a viable option, many major studios are beginning to develop smaller subsidiaries which often understand the critical power of a documentary release.
3. Internet or self-distribution:
Ultimately, the film would need to be seen. Since the film’s success is linked to the number of eyeballs which see it, it becomes essential to put the film into the world by any means necessary. If the previous two methods of distribution were to fail the Internet becomes the most likely means of dissemination. There are simply too many online outlets to allow the film to collect dust on a shelf, thus, options such as YouTube, Vimeo, a personal website, or even through iTunes would be preferred to nothing.
Having covered the distribution tactics, the expected results can be drawn: Through the use of these three distribution tactics, it is likely that the film will be seen by large audiences. Obviously the size of the audience depends on which release methods (or combination of them) are adopted. But the end result is that audiences should become more aware of a new political issue.
Audiences will, I believe, begin to question the concept of traffic when discussing local politics. While local politics are not a large concern for most of American society, the target audiences for the film are local-politically active members of the voting public. By narrowing the target audience in this way, it becomes easier to target advertisements towards this select group instead of wasting time, money, and efforts on an audience which is not likely to vote in local elections, anyway.
The benefit of creating a film about the political importance of traffic is that the film can be a political film, and yet, bipartisan at the same time. Both Republicans and Democrats would be likely to endorse the film, as there is no alienating part-specific political agenda surrounding the topic and almost everyone can agree that traffic hinders America.
Traffic is the bane of America’s transportation. However, as much as it affects us daily, we fail to mention the matter when politics count. Opting to discuss political hot points such as the death penalty, traffic is pushed into the backseat of political discussions even though it impacts us economically, environmentally, and recreationally. That is not to imply that issues such as the death penalty are not worth a political discussion; they certainly are. However, the odds of being effected by traffic far outweigh the odds of ever knowing anyone on death row.
Traffic has fallen through the cracks of society. The flow and function of cities is essential to those who live within them, and yet, rarely are members of these societies concerned with with this aspect of government. Gridlocked and this paper serve to both inform and inspire audiences to take control of this runaway issue; grab the steering wheel of life and give it a good yank! It is our responsibility to determine what are political issues deemed worthy of discussing, and these issues can be changed. But when an issue is symbolically eliminated in society, it becomes more difficult to address the topic within the political sphere. Therefore, a film such as Gridlocked would pay a service to society, as it would raise these issues for further discussion and eventually inspire the change which we all hope to see.