Robert Cannon
Dr. Classen, Dr. Hackel, Dr. Madison, Dr. Regan, Dr. Vianello
Advancement to Candidacy
15 Feb. 2011
Justifying the Comprehensive Exams
or
Why Test Taking Is Right for Me
In the summer of 2010, fresh to the Cal State campus, I spoke with a number of the faculty about the possibility of taking the exams as opposed to writing a thesis. I carefully weighed the options and despite my initial instinct to write a thesis—which I had already decided would be about the merits of short films to studios—I took a peek into the notebook which contained several of the previous years’ comprehensive exam questions. Befuddled, I wasn’t quite sure what some of the terms meant, and I became more resolved than ever to plunge ahead into the world of thesis writing, even going so far as to purchase several books on how to write theses.
Sometime the next quarter, I took another look at the comprehensive questions, and they suddenly made sense. While I wasn’t sure that I could provide the strongest possible answer to them, I did feel more confident that the exams seemed like something which was within my grasp if I was so inclined to only reach out to take it.
During that same first quarter, many of my graduate peers began to discuss the merits of exams and theses. At one point a student pointed out a line of reasoning which solidified in my mind that I would be taking the exams instead of writing a thesis: “In order to take the exams, you have to understand everything. If you write a thesis, you just have to understand your own little world.”
Such is the case with me; I can see the benefits of taking an exam which forces you to prepare for any possible number of areas, whereas when writing a thesis, a weak area of expertise can be avoided. The amount of research and preparation, by all accounts, is as much or more for the exams, but it covers a wider breadth of knowledge, and this aspect seems valuable to someone in my position who is targeting his sights on joining academia. Moreover, by understanding and being tested on such a wide variety of topics, I feel that this would sharpen my skills to the point that, when teaching my own classes, I can explain these concepts to my students.
While thesis writing certainly has its merits, I think taking the exams is the better option for me given that I plan on teaching at the college level. While it does sadden me to not add my ‘drop in the bucket of knowledge’ by conducting research and carrying out experiments, I think that my drop in the bucket will be more beneficial to the knowledge bucket by helping future students understand complex topics in a way that makes it easier for them to carry out their own research and experiments.